Hello everyone, I have been living in Japan for about 8 years and just finished visiting all 47 prefectures last year.

Something sad that has happened to me a few times, however, is paying for a seemingly vegan-friendly attraction just to find suffering animals.

Example 1: The Sun Messe Easter Island sculpture park in Miyazaki, where they randomly have 2 tortoises in a super small area - they seemed distressed by it too.

Example 2: Beppu's Hell Onsen, where they randomly have one with endless alligators crammed together - I bought a ticket where you get access to all of the springs, but would have gladly bought the more expensive admission if it meant not supporting that.

My question to save myself (and others) from future experiences like this: have you encountered any similar places that seem vegan-friendly but should be avoided?

  • I think it’s safe to say any tourist attraction with an animal in the title is going to be cruel in some way here in Japan.

    I personally would prefer it if people suggested places that WERE vegan friendly, because I’ve yet to see one!

    I like the snow monkey park they are free to come and go as they please

    That’s true! I first went there 20 years ago when it wasn’t popular, The Monkeys seemed very chill and at peace.

    Yes, I already avoid animal-related attractions - I meant places that don't even mention animals.

    However I am also working on an Osaka guide for vegan-friendly non-food activities, maybe will expand this in the future too :)

  • Was in Okinawa last year (Naha area) and both Ryukyu mura and Okinawa world had pretty abysmal conditions for their animals. Recommend avoiding them.

    Thank you! Planning to go this year so this is really helpful!

    Okinawa world absolutely horrified me. The live show with the snake/ hamster looking animal and the zoo where very unpleasant to see …better save your bucks and enjoy the beach instead !

    I didn't know about that beforehand and we didn't even go in. I had such a hard time with the animals in cages - especially the bats in such a small box forced to be in sunlight, and the mongoose with absolutely zero shade. But all the animals there were being mistreated and it was so depressing I had to leave as soon as possible.

    Same thing.. I was following my group on friend and relied on their jugement for the day . Before the infamous show with the snake and the hamster looking animal, the animator was telling that before the 2000 the were making them fight as a show and they had to stop because they got in trouble for animal cruelty??!

    Yeah, when I saw there was a show I basically flat out told my boyfriend they better not be making them fight and he was like 'Oh no, they used to. But not anymore.' Just yuck. But we ended up skipping it anyway because I just wasn't going to support that regardless.

  • How is paying for a ticket for one thing that happens to have an animal on the property unrelated to what you paid for not vegan friendly…? Your examples seem like too much of a stretch honestly

    If you’re an ethical vegan (as opposed to a plant based dieter or a vegetarian), you want to avoid supporting any animal abuse or exploitation (at least as much as possible). This includes facilities that use animals for entertainment or decoration. If you pay entry to such a place, you’re also technically paying to support the exploitation of that animal. For example, I’ve been to a lot of facilities that have a random pet animal… it just makes me feel bad and not want to go there anymore.

    I hear you but if they’re a random side part of the site it seems like one is causing themselves too much mental stress feeling they’re responsible for every action of others. Plenty of places have bad parts that doesn’t mean you support the whole. You can’t know everything before you purchase…

    I really feel being vegan is about intention not pretending we are vegan Jewish, that having even a single grain of animals involved somehow makes us responsible for planetary disaster 

    It's not about purity but principle, yes - I personally am not that stressed about it but still where's the harm in trying?

    Well, this is just something I'd like to avoid supporting where possible, so I asked for help here...

  • https://preview.redd.it/j6b5zfbklwcg1.jpeg?width=3038&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=86d28b406c141130e14dae4a22df5d198221d4b4

    This place in Okinawa. Across from our hotel. Not that you'd be fooled into checking it out as the idea just screams gross! They have a few poor penguins that are on display inside and there are even times you can feed them between 9:00 pm and midnight. (Definitely a Penguins feeding time.) Google reviews say things like "wow! cool to have penguins to see even if their cage looks small." Ugh!!

    Thanks for sharing! Awareness is always good while we can't do much else 💜

  • Every Urban area you have ever visited or lived in has involved the mass killing and suffering of animals through deforestation and environmental destruction. All vegan food that has been produced on a farm involves the same killing and destruction of animals and environment. The only way to live a truly ethical vegan life would mean going back to a hunter gatherer existence.

    Yes, every urban area involves environmental destruction. Yes, crop agriculture causes harm. Most vegans I know already acknowledge this.

    IMHO jumping from “harm exists” to “therefore all choices are morally equivalent” is lazy reasoning.

    By that logic, trying to reduce harm is pointless, because some harm will always exist? Intentional exploitation is fine, because no system is pure? Our efforts aren't meaningless just because perfection is impossible.

    Let's get back to the basics since this thread seems to be shown to more non-vegans than it should ben... veganism doesn’t claim to eliminate all harm. It is a moral stance against exploitation and killing as far as is practicable and possible. There’s a massive moral difference between simply unavoidable systemic harm and direct, unnecessary, intentional violence. Pretending otherwise is just flattening moral distinctions to avoid responsibility.

    Your hunter-gatherer line is also a false dilemma. The options are not perfect zero-impact existence vs “Guess I’ll fund animal agriculture then”...

    Reducing harm within modern constraints is how every ethical framework works. We don’t abolish labour rights because global supply chains are imperfect. We don’t legalize murder because death exists. We don’t say “well slavery existed historically so ethics are fake.”

    As a consequence of our moral stance, we aim to choose the option that avoids directly breeding, confining, and killing animals for pleasure or convenience (which btw also demonstrably uses less land, less water, and causes fewer deaths than animal agriculture).

    If your conclusion from “the world isn’t perfect” is “nothing matters unless we return to the Stone Age,” that says more about your unwillingness to engage with nuance than it does about veganism.

    It’s just a long way of saying “I don’t like ethical pressure, so I’m going to pretend reduction is meaningless.” And again, this sub and thread aren't here to debate basic philosophy that’s been answered a thousand times elsewhere. I am simply a vegan who has adjusted their lifestyle choices as much as possible, and will continue to adjust with new information I learn, while also brining awareness to attractions as I mentioned above.

    For me and the animals, this impact matters.

  • Just don’t visit any animal related attractions??

    ...did you read my post?

    You are in JAPAN. Known to have pretty bad conditions for any animal related activity. Just don’t visit any animal related attractions. I learned that my first year here and I’m a hungry guy with a hankering for meat. The only place I could actually recommend animal wise are actual sanctuaries, which there are a few of.

    OP is explicitly talking about animals at attractions that are outwardly not animal related.

    Thank you <3 I'm not sure how I could have made this any clearer and why non vegans feel the need to rage around in the vegan subreddit

  • Perhaps some of you guys can answer something for me if you can spare a moment.

    I'm wondering how you deal with vegetables grown with animal manures ? We grow organic vegetables and use various manures, fish emulsion and oyster shell for minerals as do many many other farmers. Much of that manure or emulsion will be taken up by the growing plants which you will then consume later. Whilst you aren't directly supporting animal farms there is indirect support as we farmers use some of your purchase price to pay for the manure so a percentage of your money is passed along to the animal farms.

    Not meant as a dig against your personal choices but the thought popped into my head on seeing the title of this conversation in my feed that by buying vegetables you are supporting animal farming.

    This is a subreddit about veganism in Japan. We’re not here to debate. If you want to ask for general opinions about veganism, take it to /r/debateavegan

    Would you not say this relates to the vegetables you consume in Japan from Japanese organic farmers like myself ? I hear what you are saying about the other sub reddit but was curious about vegans in Japan specifically as I don't know much about farming practices outside of Japan and you guys are specifically vegans in Japan where I am based not generally in other countries.

    Not trying to be argumentative but the title of this conversation suggests the OP is after a discussion on animal exploitation and vegans or did I read that incorrectly? 

    You read it incorrectly. OP is asking for people to share experiences of activities in Japan that, on the surface, appear to be without animal exploitation. But after ticket purchases, they discover animal exploitation. They want to know of other places they, and other vegans, can avoid in the future. That's really all it is. 

    Also, the commentator above made it clear that this isn't a place for "whataboutisms". Your question is a valid one, and being open to a conversation is important, but it would be better posed in r/debateavegan instead of here. 

    And you can't see a connection between activities in Japan that, on the surface, appear to be without animal exploitation and buying vegetables grown with animal inputs that initially might not have seen to be exploiting animals ?

    I honestly wasn't after a debate, merely curious how folk reconciled eating vegetables grown with animal inputs with veganism. Not trying to provoke an existential crisis in you guys but maybe you are feeling a little uncomfortable answering a simple question ?

    Thanks for the downvote by the way ☺️

    If you read the op carefully and then re-read your original comment, I think it’s quite fair to say that they are not related 😅

    This isn’t anything against you or your vegetables but I just think it’s out of place in this thread.

    Depending on how you word it I think it would be fine to make a new thread discussing our opinions of organic farming and what fertilizers to use. But not in this thread.

    Also you’d definitely get a better variety of responses in the debate a vegan sub.

    I think you’re getting downvoted mainly because it doesn’t have anything to do with the op.

    Honestly didn't come for a debate, not even sure why Reddit put this thread in my feed either but as I read the title a thought occurred and I thought to ask a simple question to Japanese vegans about eating Japanese vegetables that are nearly always grown with animal inputs, whether they be organic or not.

    Are there many Japanese vegans in the other reddit you mention ? Don't wish to be insulting in any way but this one feels pretty toxic with all the down voting, how to you folks hope to have any chance of reaching out to non-vegans with an attitude like that ? That would be like me telling potential customers they are monsters for eating non organic vegetables, not going to work is it.

    Please do note I haven't down voted you for replying, that's not how adults behave.

    Okay, well I’m not downvoting you, but also I don’t really care about downvotes, so I don’t think that’s very relevant 😅

    If people are downvoting you it doesn’t necessarily mean this space is “toxic”… in this case it just means the post is unrelated to the topic. Feel free to make a new post in the sub. That being said, I can’t say if asking questions here will get the answers you need/want. Most of this subreddit is probably made up of foreigners—I don’t think many Japanese natives post here. I don’t know anything about the debate sub other than that it’s for debating vegans, but I’m sure you can ask questions there too. If you want a good representation you should probably do a market survey or something. Thanks for understanding

    Thank you for taking the time to reply. Whilst you and I may not be particularly bothered that random internet strangers don't like what we are saying it gives the community a certain image when nearly every post from an outsider is ruthlessly down voted. It's worse than r/japanlife here and we all know the image that subreddit has.

    I appreciate you bringing up the debate subreddit but that doesn't specifically cover what is happening here in Japan whereas the description of your community specifically says

    Any content and questions related to both Veganism, or animal rights more broadly, and Japan are welcome here

    But your members unfortunately don't seem to share that sentiment. That's not a personal dig at you as you engage with outsiders rather than down voting and refusing to interact.

    I'm not sure if your members want to increase awareness of veganism in Japan but if they do refusing to engage or acting hostile towards outsiders rather than answering questions isn't the way to do it. As I said to veg.anita.dollar I can't convert regular farmers to a no till organic system by telling them how wrong they are and refusing to talk with them.

    I really do appreciate your offer to start another conversation here but am not sure your community is able to take that step at this moment in time and it's current mindset, which is unfortunate. It could have lead to some interesting conversations.

    But the question isn't about the manure use in agriculture.

    That's like coming into a conversation about, say, gun control in a metropolitan area, and saying "Well, what about the guns that rangers have to use when they're out in the wild?" Your question is related, but it's not what the topic is about. It's like another branch. So by asking it, and then expecting OP to engage with you (and when they don't/other people get frustrated with you, getting upset about it) is derailing at best and sealioning at worst.

    I had no expectation of the OP answering, it was more of a general question to the community but your response and that of the other members is very telling. It was a simple question about what you folk thought about supporting animal farms when you buy vegetables or consuming animal products when you eat them but you interpreted that as an attack.

    Conversations on reddit go off on tangents all the time and not many people have an issue with that, except for the more toxic places.

    If you folk can't abide curious non vegans coming in to this sub reddit you should make it private and invitation only. Would stop delicate egos getting bruised by the real world.

    If you don't expect an answer why are you getting upset when OP/people aren't answering? That doesn't make sense.

    Again, this is a question that's been asked many times before in other forums. You're welcome to pop over and check out the answers.

    Who's getting upset ? You are projecting your own feelings on to others, please do show where I expressed any form of upset.

    I asked a simple question about animal products used to produce vegetables and you guys got really upset about it down voting every non vegan post in the subreddit.

    They’re super defensive. You should try the other sub anyhow

    It's funny how their first reaction is to down vote rather than just give a simple answer, almost like they know they are consuming animal products and supporting animal farms but can't admit it

    Bestie you’re literally just in the wrong subreddit lol

    So it would seem, although I do wonder how the OP was able to

    Places that tricked you into paying for animal exploitation

    Without being told they were asking in the wrong subreddit

    Yeah it’s sad. They have this severe conviction, but they can’t explain their points.

    They are less tolerant than your average MAGA supporter

    They aren’t going to answer you because they can’t 

    Hi Felix!

    I get that this post probably just landed on your timeline, and I do appreciate that you’re clearly trying to think critically about how to make the world better. That intention matters.

    That said, this question has been discussed extensively already, and you were even pointed to a more appropriate sub. At some point, making a conscious effort also includes doing a bit of research yourself rather than continuing to debate people in a space that isn’t meant for it.

    From a vegan perspective: veganism isn’t about personal purity, it’s a philosophy opposed to animal exploitation. In a non-vegan world, it’s impossible to opt out of all indirect harm. We acknowledge that openly. But that doesn’t make the stance meaningless.

    Saying “by buying vegetables you support animal farming” is a bit like saying “you use products that involve forced labour, so I’m going to pay someone to whip people for fun.” The fact that harm exists systemically doesn’t invalidate efforts to reduce direct, avoidable exploitation where it’s realistically possible. It’s far easier to exclude animal products from our diets than it is to guarantee completely manure-free supply chains under current agricultural systems.

    There are farming methods that don’t rely on animal inputs (veganic / stock-free agriculture), which you probably know more about than most people here, and I’m happy to link resourcess ,but educating on very basic vegan questions isn’t really what this sub is for. People here want to share experiences about veganism in Japan, not constantly re-litigate foundational philosophy.

    Reddit conversations derail easily, but if you’re genuinely interested in debating or exploring the topic further, going to the appropriate channels will get you better, more engaged answers.

    Thank you for a considered reply and I get where you are coming from. You folk within the vegan community probably have endlessly discussed topics those of us outside your community have no idea about but as a non private subreddit topics from your community will pop up in the timeline of non-vegans and prompt questions we haven't seen an answer to so will naturally ask a question there without any ill intent. If that is something your members are uncomfortable with taking the subreddit private will eliminate that entirely.

    If you want to just post reviews of vegan restaurants or products fine but you may want to alter the description of your community in the right hand sidebar, it currently says

    Any content and questions related to both Veganism, or animal rights more broadly, and Japan are welcome here.

    Instead of just saying "we won't discuss this here". That's not a criticism of you folk just a suggestion to avoid similar confusion in the future from someone else that reads that and thinks it's ok to ask questions.

    I'm not sure if your community is interested in promoting veganism to a wider audience in Japan or prefers to keep it to themselves but if you do want to spread the word you're going to have to do something about the hostility towards outsiders. I browsed some other threads here after contributing to this one and there is a consistent pattern out hostility (down voting) outsiders. I don't convert other farmers to organic or no till agriculture by telling them how wrong they are. I show them the benefits, cheaper inputs, more productive soil, higher income, etc, etc

    I sort of get the point you are making when you say this

    is a bit like saying “you use products that involve forced labour, so I’m going to pay someone to whip people for fun.”

    but think the analogy misses the mark somewhat when the person could just buy from a different retailer that is more diligent in their purchasing choices. However I get your point about reducing harm while you personally admit some of your buying choices support the system you dislike.

    Why don't you as a community set up your own growing space and supply vegan grown vegetables to other vegans so you don't support a system you disagree with ? Although you maybe surprised by the final costs you have to charge using only plant based inputs or you could use conventional factory made inputs that are cheaper but have a higher environmental cost.

  • Japan is small, so it can’t really be helped. And when you say ‘Then just get rid of zoos,’ people respond with, ‘Children need to see real animals.‘

    The schools are pretty awful too, keeping unfixed rabbits in outdoor pens where the children view them as a chore and often scream around them.

    The schools insist that it’s teaching children to love animals, while admitting that the rabbits die young and also teaching children to eat animals at lunch.