So AI called me a liar on this, and have not seen anything to confirm and/or deny this but The Record Book from Season 6, Episode 9 "The Golden Child" that Amy retrieves from breaking into a filing cabinet in a Brazilian Mob Club to prove her brother's (David) innocence is the exact same record book produced by Winona Ryder's character (Babe Bennett AKA Pam Dawson) to prove that Longfellow Deeds gave away money that didn't rightfully belong to him, the record book in Mr. Deeds is used to show everybody at the shares meeting that the only female cleaner working the floor was Emilio's Mother.
Given how close Andy Samberg and Adam Sandler are and their close working relationship, it boils down to coincidence, an homage or the possibility that it is the exact prop from Mr. Deeds.
Anyway, that was how I spent my morning.
Perhaps it's the same prop because they used the same prop team