I'm also baffled by this choice of title. "Dude hooks up with a girl on her birthday." Yes, she's at the club seemingly alone on her birthday. She's 100% not gonna do something like that?
I’m usually a ‘benefit of the doubt’ person with anything but this? Definitely fake.
People do dumb stuff, but the ‘I chased away the guy who liked her then left bc I’m a bad boy and women bad only choose bad men who want the sex, me good because put her in her place!’ Is the oldest incel tripe in the book.
Exactly, it’s not that this situation never happens or couldn’t happen, it’s more that it reads like incel fic. “Dumb women are always turning down the nice guys who care about them and having casual hookups instead! Then they complain no one loves them!”
The bit at the end “that dude would have died for you” and the casual hookup chastising the girl for not choosing the right guy is just a little too on the nose.
Even if it is a real story, the woman wouldn’t be in the wrong for turning down a guy she has no attraction to. That’s just how it is sometimes and it’s no one’s fault.
I could believe it until he got to the part about the next morning. How some guy shows up and he runs the guy off but then she begs him to stay. Nope, not buying it. This is a revenge fantasy by someone who got rejected at a club
Nah this one actually seems written by a Nice Guy trying out different POVs in his creative writing. Absolutely sees himself as the man with flowers and cake being snubbed for a Bad Boy Who Only Wants Sex
Not to a misogynist. If the bad boy were actually bad, the woman might seem like a victim. In the world of whoever wrote this story women are the only ones who are evil about sex and the men just happen to be there
You’d be surprised. There are some very daft and unaware (or just not caring) folk out there. The part that shows that it’s fake is everything else. The phrasing, the description of the other guy, the supposed words said by the woman, etc.
It is not daft or unaware for a woman to be willing to go to a public place alone at night lol. Yes there’s some level of risk, just like there is in driving a car, but it’s the kind of risk that plenty of people decide is worth being able to live an independent life and meet new people.
Rewrite: no girl in her 20s socially adept enough to have a dude showing up at her house with cake is out alone. That girl has friends. It’s not about safety.
I would. You are the one scared of everything. You are projecting that onto everyone else. That's a you problem.
One of my favorite nights out by myself was running into another women out at a bar reading by herself. I was like hey I am not the only one that does that.
I somehow haven't died. I ust refuse to be bored at home because I have a vagina.
Love how he’s the one who chased off the “good guy” but then shames her for not being with him. If you respected her, why sleep with her if you don’t plan to stay with her? Just admit you wanted to get your dick wet and save your moral judgements for the next woman you stick your dick in 🙄 but yeah OP, this is definitely fake. No one thinks it’s fake cuz “nobody does dumb stuff on their birthday” we think it’s fake cuz no one who has sex talks like this lmao and no woman says that “he’s a good guy but I just don’t feel anything for him” then begging her one night stand to be her day date? Come on now
Lol. The theme is there though…she never likes that nice guy does she? Ugh, if only life was that simple. Btw, those nice guys aren’t really nice, just passive aggressive or seething with anger inside.
👍🏾 ✨
I knew someone like her, kept someone in her orbit so when shit hits the fan with her choice of partner she could monkey branch to another. Ends up both ended leaving her. I think when you see someone pass up something serious to go play for feel feels you know you don't want to do anything long term with such a person. It's not necessarily women bad, but don't put your eggs into a red flag covered sinking ship. You can swap the genders and still have a man bad story if you want. Guy goes to bar, gets drunk, gets laid, then you see he's got fan girls who are begging for his attention. Then you walk away and never entertain his games.
I think the doubt more comes from this looking like the classic “nice guy” story about Women Bad.
Of course people can do dumb stuff on their birthdays, but I think the POV it’s written in doesn’t help.
I’m usually a ‘benefit of the doubt’ person with anything but this? Definitely fake.
People do dumb stuff, but the ‘I chased away the guy who liked her then left bc I’m a bad boy and women bad only choose bad men who want the sex, me good because put her in her place!’ Is the oldest incel tripe in the book.
Exactly, it’s not that this situation never happens or couldn’t happen, it’s more that it reads like incel fic. “Dumb women are always turning down the nice guys who care about them and having casual hookups instead! Then they complain no one loves them!”
The bit at the end “that dude would have died for you” and the casual hookup chastising the girl for not choosing the right guy is just a little too on the nose.
Even if it is a real story, the woman wouldn’t be in the wrong for turning down a guy she has no attraction to. That’s just how it is sometimes and it’s no one’s fault.
I could believe it until he got to the part about the next morning. How some guy shows up and he runs the guy off but then she begs him to stay. Nope, not buying it. This is a revenge fantasy by someone who got rejected at a club
Yep. Thought the same.
Nah this one actually seems written by a Nice Guy trying out different POVs in his creative writing. Absolutely sees himself as the man with flowers and cake being snubbed for a Bad Boy Who Only Wants Sex
Nah. The bad boy who only wants sex wouldn't seem so moral if that was the case, he'd be a dick
Not to a misogynist. If the bad boy were actually bad, the woman might seem like a victim. In the world of whoever wrote this story women are the only ones who are evil about sex and the men just happen to be there
you seriously misunderstand the brain of an incel. women are the villains in every scenario.
"he looked like having an upper hand in terms of looks as well as FINANCIAL STATUS"???? Lmao dude this is both fake and cringe as hell
As soon as he said "did the deed" I knew it was fake, this is definitely some incel making up stories
Ikr they can’t even pretend they know what sex is enough to write something believable
Nah, this one is bullshit. “I just want someone to like me and do things with me,” is so unnatural.
r/mansfictionalscenario
He “understood the scene and had to break the guys bubble”. So this person knew the guy at the door was there to celebrate her birthday and…what?
Sorry, this doesn’t seem real.
It's clearly not real. Not because the story is crazy impossible but the way it's written. It's written by an incel
This is some incel fanfic.
No girl in her 20s would go out for their birthday by themselves. That's dangerous and they know it.
You’d be surprised. There are some very daft and unaware (or just not caring) folk out there. The part that shows that it’s fake is everything else. The phrasing, the description of the other guy, the supposed words said by the woman, etc.
It is not daft or unaware for a woman to be willing to go to a public place alone at night lol. Yes there’s some level of risk, just like there is in driving a car, but it’s the kind of risk that plenty of people decide is worth being able to live an independent life and meet new people.
Rewrite: no girl in her 20s socially adept enough to have a dude showing up at her house with cake is out alone. That girl has friends. It’s not about safety.
I would. You are the one scared of everything. You are projecting that onto everyone else. That's a you problem.
One of my favorite nights out by myself was running into another women out at a bar reading by herself. I was like hey I am not the only one that does that.
I somehow haven't died. I ust refuse to be bored at home because I have a vagina.
Glad you are alive.
This one is totally fake
no, this actually didn't happen
this is so clearly a creative writing project by an incel and its alarming you didn’t pick up on that
no this one's fake i think
"I, a Super Attractive man who Gets Laid at The Club, got revenge on this Shallow Bitch for rejecting a Nice Guy"
really, OP?
Look people do hook up and do dumb birthday shit but this is so obviously incel fanfiction lol
This is incel fan fiction.
Love how he’s the one who chased off the “good guy” but then shames her for not being with him. If you respected her, why sleep with her if you don’t plan to stay with her? Just admit you wanted to get your dick wet and save your moral judgements for the next woman you stick your dick in 🙄 but yeah OP, this is definitely fake. No one thinks it’s fake cuz “nobody does dumb stuff on their birthday” we think it’s fake cuz no one who has sex talks like this lmao and no woman says that “he’s a good guy but I just don’t feel anything for him” then begging her one night stand to be her day date? Come on now
Nah sorry lol I think this one’s made up
The last 3 paragraphs are where I think it’s bs
This is probably just ai, not being sure of the point of the story.
Lol. The theme is there though…she never likes that nice guy does she? Ugh, if only life was that simple. Btw, those nice guys aren’t really nice, just passive aggressive or seething with anger inside. 👍🏾 ✨
I knew someone like her, kept someone in her orbit so when shit hits the fan with her choice of partner she could monkey branch to another. Ends up both ended leaving her. I think when you see someone pass up something serious to go play for feel feels you know you don't want to do anything long term with such a person. It's not necessarily women bad, but don't put your eggs into a red flag covered sinking ship. You can swap the genders and still have a man bad story if you want. Guy goes to bar, gets drunk, gets laid, then you see he's got fan girls who are begging for his attention. Then you walk away and never entertain his games.
OP this is so clearly fake 😭