It’s too fast, Theia doesn’t take up enough of the sky, and It doesn’t even show the actual impact. Just a strobe at the end. The impact would have taken hours and Theia would have swallowed the sky and all light of the day as it collided.
Not to mention the trajectory, it looks like fucking galactus picked theia up and threw it at earth, not a good representation of movement among the heavens
Edit: I now realize that’s what you meant when you said too fast, still, I needed to highlight the cartoonish levels of wrong
And wouldn't it have been deformed by tidal forces long before collision? I'm no physicist but my understanding is that by the time it hit it wouldn't look nearly like a perfect globe.
The atmospheric perspective isn't right. Dark things in space take on the same colour as the sky the observer is looking through. It's why the dark side of the moon appears blue during the day. This planet looks like it's already in the atmosphere.
I’m not feeling the scale.
1. Only the highlights from the planet should be visible. The atmosphere turns the black of space into the color of your sky. Theia is outside the atmosphere, so we shouldn’t see the dark parts of it at all.
2. As a planet that large gets closer, the surface of the earth will bulge towards Theia due to gravity. Same thing happens on Theia. These aren’t large rocks, they are cosmic scale droplets of molten rock. The ground should kinda disintegrate and start floating upwards in the final moments before collision.
3. I want to see the moment of impact before you cut out.
Look at that. Not a single phone in sight. Just two planetary bodies living in the moment.
Nature is healing
They look so peaceful and happy to be reunited. Back when there were family values…
No it isn’t.
It’s too fast, Theia doesn’t take up enough of the sky, and It doesn’t even show the actual impact. Just a strobe at the end. The impact would have taken hours and Theia would have swallowed the sky and all light of the day as it collided.
Not to mention the trajectory, it looks like fucking galactus picked theia up and threw it at earth, not a good representation of movement among the heavens
Edit: I now realize that’s what you meant when you said too fast, still, I needed to highlight the cartoonish levels of wrong
Galactus passing Theia like a basketball.
"Here comes the Devourer of Worlds ... FROM DOWN TOWN!!" 🔥🔥🔥🏀
It was annoying that the power failed just before impact there..
And wouldn't it have been deformed by tidal forces long before collision? I'm no physicist but my understanding is that by the time it hit it wouldn't look nearly like a perfect globe.
The atmospheric perspective isn't right. Dark things in space take on the same colour as the sky the observer is looking through. It's why the dark side of the moon appears blue during the day. This planet looks like it's already in the atmosphere.
It also doesn’t show a collision
Meloncholia was a cool movie
It was a good one indeed.
I’m not feeling the scale. 1. Only the highlights from the planet should be visible. The atmosphere turns the black of space into the color of your sky. Theia is outside the atmosphere, so we shouldn’t see the dark parts of it at all. 2. As a planet that large gets closer, the surface of the earth will bulge towards Theia due to gravity. Same thing happens on Theia. These aren’t large rocks, they are cosmic scale droplets of molten rock. The ground should kinda disintegrate and start floating upwards in the final moments before collision. 3. I want to see the moment of impact before you cut out.
I thought that Earth was still molten when Theia hit. Has that been overridden?
I’d be fine
Just duck
i feel like the scale would be off, no?
also, surely there would be floods/tides/other natural phenomenon in conjunction?
(disclaimer* did not watch the full youtube video)
The earth was a dry, barren rock at the time. There were no oceans to flood/tide.
It's not a scary sight if you're facing the other side, am I right? Jk lol
I get so many nightmares that are exactly like this 😅
Same!
No point running, no point hiding. Nothing you do will make the slightest difference.
So sit back and enjoy the show.
[deleted]
God I hated the scaling in that scene
You just gotta dodge roll right before it hits. Easy attack to dodge if you don't panic roll. You get like three seconds of punish right after too.
I wouldn’t want to miss that
When you're trying to fall asleep and your brain starts making your thoughts too big. does anyone know what Im talking about