When someone plays it against me, I get obliterated. Sometimes I just know it's about to happen, but don't know how to prevent it from happening (defend against it) and keep me king safe when it has been played.
Hey, OP! Did your game end in a stalemate? Did you encounter a weird pawn move? Are you trying to move a piece and it's not going? We have just the resource for you! The Chess Beginners Wiki is the perfect place to check out answers to these questions and more!
The moderator team of r/chessbeginners wishes to remind everyone of the community rules. Posting spam, being a troll, and posting memes are not allowed. We encourage everyone to report these kinds of posts so they can be dealt with. Thank you!
Let's do our utmost to be kind in our replies and comments. Some people here just want to learn chess and have virtually no idea about certain chess concepts.
Sometimes, the greek gift is only a symptom of the real issue, where the opponent has way more space than you do. Could you post some games where you got greek gifted?
The general ingredients for a Greek gift are a bishop able to capture the h7 pawn, knight that can go to g5, and queen with access to move to h5, while you have castled kingside.
To fight against it, the first thing is not to move your knight from f6 if they have the ingredients. Your f6 knight prevents it. Often, they will try and first kick this knight, so your first defense to a Greek gift is actually fighting against their initial plan to kick your knight.
Playing h6 can also often prevent it (which of course has its own downsides).
Controlling g5 to prevent the followup knight check can often prevent it.
If you can move a piece to defend h7 after the sac, check, and Qh5 has occurred, this can often stymie the attack.
Of course, this is chess, and there are exceptions to everything and your opponent will have their own say in how things play out. But if you keep these things in mind, you can generally avoid allowing too many (sound) Greek gifts. Now of course, even unsound Greek gifts can be problematic in faster time controls. But that's more a matter of calculation than anything strategic.
to add on to what others have said, if you still find yourself getting greek gifted, very rarely you can defend against it by bringing your king out to g3/g6 (depending on what color you are) after the knight part of the sequence (Ng4+/Ng5+) because the strategy for a greek gift after you bring your king out is to position their queen behind their knight for a discovered check, if you can stop that discovered check, you can parry the greek gift
Dubious advice but...: echoing other beginner posts, consider not castling kingside?
Or, more accurately, you need to understand that high-level players and engines will intentionally make "equivocal" moves that don't precisely indicate where they're going to castle.
Consider the basic concept behind 1. d4 for White: the entire reason why 1. e4 is so violent and strong is because White is now just 2 moves away from being able to castle (which, in this case, means getting the h1 rook "into the game" very quickly). However, by playing 1. d4 first, White says, on one hand, "I'm attacking e5 and c5, I'm opening up my dark-square bishop, I'm giving space and a nice passive role to my powerful queen"; but on the other hand, "I'm now 3 moves from castling on either side of the board...Which way do you think I'll go, eh?"
The Greek gift primarily works if you just play into your opponent's plans. It's one of the many, varied reasons to try to have active play on both sides of the board: if your opponent attacks one side, you start "pushing"/developing on the other.
If you watch computer chess, engines basically never succumb to the Greek gift, because they always come up with nasty ways to punish their opponents who spend turns launching these attacks.
Once you learn how to be "misleading", by skillfully pushing your c-pawn/f-pawn (yes, you must learn to ignore Binegold's advice every now and then) or otherwise correctly timing "opposite-side" pre-castle moves (like Nc6 after e5...wait...isn't that the entire idea behind...?), you'll realize that, while castling is good, the more-correct ideas are 1) keep your king safe, so that you don't let your opponent get extra tempi and 2) castle AWAY from excessive action, TOWARDS safety, even if it takes an extra turn or two.
Nonetheless, if you can "defang" your opponent's Greek gift attempt (by removing a critical knight; by making a necessary bishop/queen move 1-2 tempi late), then you're usually fine to castle kingside as quickly as possible.
Watch a Greek gift lecture eg by Ben Finegold on YouTube to understand the signals required for the Greek gift to be a “go”.
And then you can better look out for it.
Key signals though (although not always essential);
1) Opponent has played e5 (if you’re black) because e5 often removes your defensive knight from f6 that would ordinarily defend h7. Especially common in French defence when e4+d4 is already played and they bush e5.
2) Their light squared Bisop (white) is on d3 or at least the b1-h7 diagonal - to sacrifice on h7.
3) the g5 square is under whites control, most commonly with their c1 dark squared bishop - this is to support the Ng5+ check continuation of their attack, as if defended, your queen usually can capture their Knight. If they do not have a dark squared Bishop defending that square, they can alternate with a preparatory move like h4, especially if their rook is still on h1.
4) Queen is on its original square or at least the same diagonal that allows them to safely access the h file. Eg. D1 or e2.
5) your knight is on f3, or a square ready to jump to g5.
Now let’s talk about some basic signals that show the gift is not possible:
1) they need to have h7 undefined, hence e5 to kick the common f6 knight… but obviously if they have a Knight on f8 too… the sac doesn’t work.
2) their light squared bishop (usually on c8) can’t have access to f5. Usually the e5 pawn push locks their light squared bishop out of the action however if you have bf5… usually this is often a commonly overlooked defensive resource where after a typical 1. Bxh7 Kxh7 sacrifice… 2. ng5 kg8. 3. Qh5 bf5! Is played and your bishop backward defends the mate on h7 and you can cement it on g6 next to chase their queen away and give you time to defend.
3) you NEED to have g5 secured for your Knight Jump. So usually if black has the queen on d8 and their dark squared Bishop on e7… white often needs to over defend g5 with something like h4 with the rook still being on h1 to “double down” on the idea.
I appreciate a lot of this is hard for a beginner to visualise in your head without a board, but these pointers will make more sense when you’re looking at a board with typical Greek gift set ups.
A YouTube lecture will be a good starting point. Good luck
Hey, OP! Did your game end in a stalemate? Did you encounter a weird pawn move? Are you trying to move a piece and it's not going? We have just the resource for you! The Chess Beginners Wiki is the perfect place to check out answers to these questions and more!
The moderator team of r/chessbeginners wishes to remind everyone of the community rules. Posting spam, being a troll, and posting memes are not allowed. We encourage everyone to report these kinds of posts so they can be dealt with. Thank you!
Let's do our utmost to be kind in our replies and comments. Some people here just want to learn chess and have virtually no idea about certain chess concepts.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Sometimes, the greek gift is only a symptom of the real issue, where the opponent has way more space than you do. Could you post some games where you got greek gifted?
Greek gift only works if you dont have a knight protecting a short castled king. So make sure you have a knight there and you can get greek gifted
Also impossible if u control G4/G5, or have H3/H6 on board
The general ingredients for a Greek gift are a bishop able to capture the h7 pawn, knight that can go to g5, and queen with access to move to h5, while you have castled kingside.
To fight against it, the first thing is not to move your knight from f6 if they have the ingredients. Your f6 knight prevents it. Often, they will try and first kick this knight, so your first defense to a Greek gift is actually fighting against their initial plan to kick your knight.
Playing h6 can also often prevent it (which of course has its own downsides).
Controlling g5 to prevent the followup knight check can often prevent it.
If you can move a piece to defend h7 after the sac, check, and Qh5 has occurred, this can often stymie the attack.
Of course, this is chess, and there are exceptions to everything and your opponent will have their own say in how things play out. But if you keep these things in mind, you can generally avoid allowing too many (sound) Greek gifts. Now of course, even unsound Greek gifts can be problematic in faster time controls. But that's more a matter of calculation than anything strategic.
to add on to what others have said, if you still find yourself getting greek gifted, very rarely you can defend against it by bringing your king out to g3/g6 (depending on what color you are) after the knight part of the sequence (Ng4+/Ng5+) because the strategy for a greek gift after you bring your king out is to position their queen behind their knight for a discovered check, if you can stop that discovered check, you can parry the greek gift
If you wanna completly avoid it for a while play an opening that includes g6 bg7
Dubious advice but...: echoing other beginner posts, consider not castling kingside?
Or, more accurately, you need to understand that high-level players and engines will intentionally make "equivocal" moves that don't precisely indicate where they're going to castle.
Consider the basic concept behind 1. d4 for White: the entire reason why 1. e4 is so violent and strong is because White is now just 2 moves away from being able to castle (which, in this case, means getting the h1 rook "into the game" very quickly). However, by playing 1. d4 first, White says, on one hand, "I'm attacking e5 and c5, I'm opening up my dark-square bishop, I'm giving space and a nice passive role to my powerful queen"; but on the other hand, "I'm now 3 moves from castling on either side of the board...Which way do you think I'll go, eh?"
The Greek gift primarily works if you just play into your opponent's plans. It's one of the many, varied reasons to try to have active play on both sides of the board: if your opponent attacks one side, you start "pushing"/developing on the other.
If you watch computer chess, engines basically never succumb to the Greek gift, because they always come up with nasty ways to punish their opponents who spend turns launching these attacks.
Once you learn how to be "misleading", by skillfully pushing your c-pawn/f-pawn (yes, you must learn to ignore Binegold's advice every now and then) or otherwise correctly timing "opposite-side" pre-castle moves (like Nc6 after e5...wait...isn't that the entire idea behind...?), you'll realize that, while castling is good, the more-correct ideas are 1) keep your king safe, so that you don't let your opponent get extra tempi and 2) castle AWAY from excessive action, TOWARDS safety, even if it takes an extra turn or two.
Nonetheless, if you can "defang" your opponent's Greek gift attempt (by removing a critical knight; by making a necessary bishop/queen move 1-2 tempi late), then you're usually fine to castle kingside as quickly as possible.
Watch a Greek gift lecture eg by Ben Finegold on YouTube to understand the signals required for the Greek gift to be a “go”.
And then you can better look out for it.
Key signals though (although not always essential);
1) Opponent has played e5 (if you’re black) because e5 often removes your defensive knight from f6 that would ordinarily defend h7. Especially common in French defence when e4+d4 is already played and they bush e5.
2) Their light squared Bisop (white) is on d3 or at least the b1-h7 diagonal - to sacrifice on h7.
3) the g5 square is under whites control, most commonly with their c1 dark squared bishop - this is to support the Ng5+ check continuation of their attack, as if defended, your queen usually can capture their Knight. If they do not have a dark squared Bishop defending that square, they can alternate with a preparatory move like h4, especially if their rook is still on h1.
4) Queen is on its original square or at least the same diagonal that allows them to safely access the h file. Eg. D1 or e2.
5) your knight is on f3, or a square ready to jump to g5.
Now let’s talk about some basic signals that show the gift is not possible:
1) they need to have h7 undefined, hence e5 to kick the common f6 knight… but obviously if they have a Knight on f8 too… the sac doesn’t work.
2) their light squared bishop (usually on c8) can’t have access to f5. Usually the e5 pawn push locks their light squared bishop out of the action however if you have bf5… usually this is often a commonly overlooked defensive resource where after a typical 1. Bxh7 Kxh7 sacrifice… 2. ng5 kg8. 3. Qh5 bf5! Is played and your bishop backward defends the mate on h7 and you can cement it on g6 next to chase their queen away and give you time to defend.
3) you NEED to have g5 secured for your Knight Jump. So usually if black has the queen on d8 and their dark squared Bishop on e7… white often needs to over defend g5 with something like h4 with the rook still being on h1 to “double down” on the idea.
I appreciate a lot of this is hard for a beginner to visualise in your head without a board, but these pointers will make more sense when you’re looking at a board with typical Greek gift set ups.
A YouTube lecture will be a good starting point. Good luck
Just play h6 or h3 before casting greek gift will be impossible.
Just play h6 or h3 so they have nowhere to sacrifice the bishop