• Didn't he also nearly kill one of them from strangulation?

    Correct.

    This will definitely be a repeat offender. I don’t think those habits or impulses change at all during life. Hope he commits a lesser crime that puts him behind bars before he gets back to doing what his kink is.

    more than a Kink, it's a mental problem that makes him don't understand consent, kinks aren't something like this.

    in a perfect world this guy would be in jail, a jail where you don't just get punished, but fixed.

    still, he didn't even get jail time, which is an HUGE L from the judicial system (Or whatever system it is idk)

    Oh he understands consent, he just doesn’t care or feels entitled to their body. Narcissists only care about their own feelings and needs, other people are just objects to them.

    that's even worse tbh, i still wonder how tf he didn't get behind bars, that is disgusting.

    Punitive justice is earned for crimes like this. If it were my daughters, I would never be accepting of restorative programs for irreparable damage done to my children

    He just knows to be more careful now. He’ll probably find a woman with some self esteem issues, manipulate and marry her. He’ll beat her at home, cheat on the side, and keep it as quiet as possible. The only happy ending anyone is getting from this is if the woman he ends up with snaps at some point.

    Let's just say they weren't able to prove the rape. Hypothetically. He still almost fucking killed the girl. Isn't that a prison sentence in itself? There's gotta be some assault charges there that stick or something. I hope those family sue him in civil court to at least hold him financially accountable.

    This case always reminds me of that judge who gave Dahmer a slap on the wrist for raping and kidnapping a CHILD. Had that judge done their one job, THEIR ONE JOB, we wouldn't be here.

    I feel like this MFer will re-offend. No doubt about it.

  • One had to have surgery on her neck because of him choking her out to the point of unconsciousness. He also filmed it.

    Holy shit he FILMED it and still got off? I wonder if there’s more dirt on the judge than just her alumni. That’s freaking insane!

    I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s related to the DA/judge or their families are really tight with each other. Something definitely fishy about this considering there was so much evidence..

    His dad was a director over OSU football and the judge got a couple degrees from OSU. Apparently they knew each other. Small town buddy buddy shit.

    That would make sense. Imagine if the kid got what he deserved and we didn't have to worry about him getting better at not getting caught. He won't stop. Unless he makes a spiritual change, he may be the next serial killer.

    His father is the athletic director of OSU and you can even see on the body cam footage when the kid is arrested the mother says don't worry nothing will happen to you. Because the father pulls a lot of water in the area the female judge threw it out.

    Jfc if it didn’t mean abandoning actual people I swear to god I’d say kick some of these states out of the union

    Dude, they vote against their own interests regularly. There's a lot of good about Oklahoma, but there's a lot of WTF stuff too.

    He’s the son of a former OSU football director, which in that region may be worth more than a judge…

    Don't have to be related at all. If money can so easily buy a presidential pardon it can damn sure buy leniency from a corrupt judge (most of them are, just fyi). It doesn't have to be a straight cash transaction. It can be legal corruption just funding a campaign.

    just shit kids do /s

    [deleted]

    Boys will be boys and girls will be punished and suffer because of it.

    The judge did have to watch the evidence. Maybe he saw something promising.

    It's a woman, Judge Susan Worthington in Payne County OK. Apparently she has long standing ties to OSU and her father was also a Judge.

    These counties are very despotic and ruled by nepotism. Butler's father was the athletic director for Oklahoma State so she worked out a sweetheart plea deal.

    These were extremely violent assaults - Butler was charged with 10 felonies and another one a month after his arrest for violating the no contact order.

    He has to do less than 200 hours of community service, get therapy until he's 19 (which is a few months), and doesn't have to register as a sex offender in addition to no jail time.

    He was allowed to stay enrolled at the local high school - wasn't even expelled. Meanwhile the victims had their lives destroyed and one had to get plastic surgery to fix the massive scarring from the strangulation which could have easily been charged as attempted murder.

    The system is a fucking joke when it comes to sex crimes. I will never judge any victim for not reporting. The trauma from the justice system is often worse than the assault.

    Thank you. I figured it was nepotism but not a woman judge. For every Epstein there's a Maxwell.

    Greed transcends race and gender.

    Luckily ICE is protecting the public from guys like this. Oh wait, he's white in a red state. Nevermind.

    That was sarcasm. Judge should've thrown out the appeal. At the very least have him evaluated at the Michigan place. Forgot the name but it's a predator only jail and chemical neuter therapy.

    If I'm remembering right the mother was home when this was happening. Absolutely horrible people

    She sure was. She heard at least one of his victims screaming for help and didn’t do anything. As far as I’m concerned she should be thrown on the trash pile with her rapist son, Jesse Butler.

    How about just set on fire in a public square, seems good enough for me.

    Fuck this entire legal system. And fuck anyone who wants to argue that point.

    i sometimes wish we can bring back the old public prosecution methods.

    You can do pretty much anything if you get enough like minded people together.

    Just like the affluenza kid and the rapist Brock Turner, trash begets trash.

    You mean rapist Brock Allen Turner who goes by Allen Turner now?

    They are both rapists.

    Oh Allen Turner, I almost forgot that was Brock Turner, right right.

    Yes. Allen Turner the rapist and and Brock Turner the rapist are same person. So is rapist Brock Allen Turner.

    "say your prayers in jail, son" This whole family, man. I just can't.

    If he choked her then he should also be charged with attempted murder. Our justice system does not protect girls and women.

    The doctor that testified said she was about 30 seconds away from death if he had continued to strangle her.

    Which makes that choice to charge him as a minor all the more shocking!

    Hes a serial killer in training Seriously.

    It's just a matter of time before he at least tries to go further

    Fine then, don't get him on rape, get him on assault! But to get NOTHING at all is infuriating. If a black man committed these crimes, he'd be looking at the death penalty.

    He's a adult now. Im sure these young girls have brothers and fathers itching to meet the pos.

    At 16-17 you know right vs wrong, the fact he did it twice shows he knew what he was doing, therefore he should be tried as a adult

    "He raped when he was 16 and 17", without reading any further that just got a lot worse...

    He’s lucky he made it to the court, if that was my daughter. I’ll most likely be in prison rn

    I used to think people were corny for saying this. Since then I had a baby girl, and now I completely understand. Same here, man.

    Just make sure she doesn’t know that you would take it that far. My dad always said the same thing, so when I was assaulted I didn’t tell him because I didn’t want to lose him. You can make her feel protected without telling her you would take it that far for her, otherwise she might not feel safe telling you about anything out of fear of losing you.

    I’m so sorry that happened to you. You’re so right, and while I love my daughter more than anything and can’t imagine this, I’ll admit I’m a little embarrassed that I missed this element. Clearly being there for her is better than some sort of justice in revenge.

    Very wise words you shared. Thank you

    Thank you for listening to them. You sound like a very good dad.

    I'd imagine someone involved feels like this hero.

    Meanwhile in the Kids for Cash scandal black children were imprisoned for multiple years for shit like cursing in school.

    We live in hell.

    I know how their father's feel about this, and he would never again feel safe again.

    i wonder what their community thinks about all this

    I've never been a fan of crimes like rape and murder being charged in the juvenile system. It shouldn't even be an option.

    How much do you want to bet the whole family owns red hats?

    Well, the judge that sentenced him was a registered democrat.

  • Reading here what the attacks actually involved. Basically attempted murder by strangulation, 2 different times on 2 different girls, his mother being in the house during 1 attack and no doubt hearing the screams, the judge trying to get him a lesser sentence by reducing it to a juvenile charge then getting a plea that let him off altogether. Also a lot of talk about how money can keep you out of jail.

    Not exaggerating here, that’s all the ingredients for an entitled murderer in the making. I very much doubt this has taught him any lesson at all and unfortunately for some girls poor family it won’t be the last we will hear of him

    One victim required surgery after. This animal is absolutely going to keep doing it until he murders someone.

    Or vice versa.

    The rage I feel for her. I cannot imagine what she is going through. More girls will surely suffer dearly for this egregious failure of our justice system. People like him do not change, there is something deeply sick and depraved inside them that does not just go away as though it was never there. God forbid but mark my words, this is not the last we hear of him and it makes me sick to my stomach knowing they let demons like this walk free when prisons are full of non violent offenders.

    Maybe the two victims will team up before he strikes again 🙏🏻

    No.. They're traumatized for life. Unlike in the movies, they will just suffer silently for the rest of their lives 

    Oh he learned a lesson alright. He learned that with money and influence, he can do what he wants without consequences. I hope whoever helped him escape his sentence will rot in hell.

    Now he’s free to actually kill someone. And I don’t believe for a second that he’s miraculously able to stop his despicable behavior. There should be extra charges, people losing jobs and being sued when that day comes. This is beyond sickening to see.

  • I'm hoping to one day see a post that design wise looks like this, but his picture is in black and white...

    May he burn in hell but even so the damage is done, next time someone thinks of this guy and decides not to report their own rape/rapist. 

  • Just a reminder that Jesse Butler is a rapist and judge Susan Worthington thinks raping deserves no jail time…if your daddy can pull the right strings.

    Edit: At the beginning of December the judge announced she will retire at the end of the month, due to everyone hating her fucking soulless guts. May she never enjoy another day of her miserable life.

    No kidding:

    "His father was previously tied to Oklahoma State University where he was the former director of operations for Oklahoma State University's football team, the USA TODAY Network previously reported. In addition, the special judge who granted Butler youthful offender status, Susan Worthington, also has longstanding ties to OSU, where she earned two bachelor's degrees, The Oklahoman, part of the USA TODAY Network, reported."

    How is that not a conflict of interest?

    Because money plays by different rules

    Rules are for poor people

    Pretty much the status quo around the world

    Susan Worthington, also has longstanding ties to OSU, where she earned two bachelor's degrees

    Unless there's more to the story, I don't think simply attending a university is enough to create a conflict of interest to anything related to the university.

    Would it have been that hard to assign a judge that didn’t go to OSU?

    That would have made a rich person upset so yeah; way, way too much to ask.

    More to the story is probably a bribe

    football is a scourge on the american psyche.

    the highest paid public employee in most any state is a college football coach

    There are so many cases where the judges say the perpetrators life shouldn’t be ruined by ‘this incident’; it’s truly disturbing. Obviously what goes hand in hand with this, is more sympathy for perpetrators who come from rich families or the kid has sports or academic potential.

    With these sorts of things happening, and the rise of people trying to lower the age of consent so men can’t get charged for grooming minors - it feels like we’re going backwards. It’s so incredibly depressing. Thank you for sharing - being in the uk I might not have heard about this otherwise. We all need to share these stories and keep making noise.

    This has been happening for awhile and it makes me fucking sick.

    My ex husband's best friend was run over by a drunk driver as he crossed the street. That driver (who is a murderer) didn't serve any time. His parents had connections to politicians in the city of the murder. His lawyer argued that he had a bright legal career ahead of him and shouldn't have his life ruined. He. Killed. A. Man. Ruin the fuck out of his life.

    I'm oddly thankful the men who murdered my cousin were poor so they got life in prison.

    It is usually always white men and teens who get that treatment. The judges feel like their lives have value and they will contribute to the world.

    Jesse Butler = rapist. Judge Sarah Worthington = trash.

    Currently providing therapy for a student and she has been through a situation similar. Dad of the boy is a higher up in the school district the boy only got a suspension for like a week as punishment and had to "apologize".

    So minor get off easy for raping people now. I'm sure that will go well...

    Sounds like he got the Brock Turner treatment. Let’s keep their names out there. It’s only a matter of time before this little asshole strikes again.

    Edit: Now known as Allen Turner

    What in the 3rd world country is this shit

    Judge probably thought its a bit extreme to send someone to jail for 20min activity- like the rapist Brock Turner

    THE rapist Brock Turner!? That rapist??

    Are you guys talking about convicted rapist Brock Turner? Who raped a woman behind a dumpster? That Brock Turner?

    You guys must be thinking of convicted rapist Brock Allen Turner who now goes by Allen to distance himself from his disgusting crime.

    Brock Allen Turner, who now goes by Allen Turner. Got it!

    Wait, The Rapist Brock Allen Turner, who raped behind a dumpster, is now The Rapist Allen Turner, who raped behind a dumpster?

    Who is it again? For the cheap seats.

    Rapist Allen "The Rapist" Turner, the rapist. Know for, believe it or not, raping.

    Ah, got it. We’re not only talking about the rapist Jesse Butler but also the rapist Brock Turner who now goes by Allen Turner who, despite the name change, is still a rapist.

    Hey we don't deserve that, as a convicted rapist his man in my third world country wouldn't see the light of day again, and as rapist he'll soon start serving others in prison

    Susan Worthnothington.

  • HIS NAME IS JESSE MACK BUTLER, THE RAPIST FROM STILLWATER, OKLAHOMA

    Wait, are you talking about Jesse Mack Butler, the rapist from Stillwater, Oklahoma?

    I heard the rapist Jesse Mack Butler of Stillwater, Oklahoma was a violent, sadistic rapist.

    I hope that this rapist, Jesse Mack Butler of Stillwater, Oklahoma, gets the karma he deserves.

    I bet he’a friends with Brock Allan Turner, that other rapist.

    Not if you write news articles, then he’s “former Stillwater high school baseball player Jesse Mack Butler”.

    Surely they mean former Stillwater high school baseball player Jesse Mack Butler, the rapist.

    All my homies hate the rapist Jesse Mack Butler.

    You mean Jesse Mack Butler the rapist from Stillwater Oklahoma?

    Oh yeah, I think it’s that former baseball player from Stillwater, OK? Jesse Mack Butler, the piece of shit rapist?

    Jesse Mack the piece of shit rapist

    Yeah I heard of that disgusting person 😒

    Oh Jesse Mack Butler, the rapist from Stillwater Oklahoma?? Yea, the one that videoed and strangled one of the girls to the point of surgery and still got community service? . oh THAT Jesse Mack Butler, the Rapist from Stillwater Oklahoma. Yea, we heard of him

  • What the fuck?! I already thought the dude was behind bars.

    In Oklahoma, we put the victims behind bars. Much simpler that way. 

    In my native language we'd say "Omgekeerde wereld". But seriously, this is beyond fucked up

  • Oh no. I hope nothing horrible will happen to him, now that he is out in the open.

    Honestly, probably not in shitty Stillwater Oklahoma

    Still water is the perfect breeding ground for bacteria.

  • Not to be confused with rapist Brock Allen Turner!!

    Not the convicted rapist, Brock Allen Turner?

    Not Brock Allen Turner, the rapist, who now goes by Allen Turner?

    Yes, the rapist Brock Allen Turner is not to be confused with the rapist Jesse Mack Butler, who is from Stillwater, Oklahoma, despite them both receiving offensively light punishment for their crimes.

    You mean to tell me the Rapist Brock Allen Turner isn’t the Rapist Jesse Mack Butler? On second thought, you’re right. Brock, who goes by Allen Turner, who is definitely a rapist, is not the same as Jesse Mack Butler, who is also definitely a rapist.

  • I just looked up an article and dude basically got away with rape.

    He gets to stay at home enjoy theAC, stream movies, play video games and have fun while these girls will have to live with the mental damage done by this fucking piece of shit.

    While his mom happily brings him tendies and tots all day

    Hopefully we get some 4chan justice where even his virtual life is a constant knightmare

  • He is 100% going to do this again

    His face and name is everywhere now. Main stream news even picked up on this. If he gets to college, he's likely going to be noticed and probably get his ass beat or at the very least shunned by everyone.

    From this point on he will likely live in constant fear like how Brock Turner still is

    Hopefully everyone he meets moving forwards has the forethought to google his name.

  • Fuck this kid. I hope this ruins every moment of his life to come. I hope he’s still getting trolled and bullied in his 90’s. He’s fucking repulsive and his parents should be ashamed (they aren’t).

  • HIS NAME IS JESSE MACK BUTLER, THE RAPIST FROM STILLWATER, OKLAHOMA

  • This kid is going to kill someone..

    He will rape again and likely kill them. He believes he can get away with it because they've now shown piece of shit human beings, like him, can.

  • The girls traumatized and the suspect is legally not responcible. Good job👍🏿🤨

  • Shit like this is why I didn’t bother reporting both my rapes.

    I understand. And I’m sorry.

  • Street justice?

    Not enough of that anymore

    Yup. The justice system isn’t even just a “flawed system” anymore, it’s a straight up failure of a system. Too many people walking around with way too many priors these days. Judges need to start losing their seats when they release someone and they reoffend. Need to light a fire under their asses to encourage them to make smarter decisions.

    Edit: typo

    With frequent incidents like this are I always wonder why Gary Plauchés are so rare.

  • He’s legit the real-life Bryce Walker from 13 Reasons Why.

    Seems way fucking worse tbh considering the level of violence involved in the rape. Like as a rape victim there’s guys who will back off if you fight back and they are just looking for victims who freeze and then there and violent sadists like this who will strangle and get physically violent if you resist. Obviously rape is violent in itself I just mean in terms of using violent physical force as a method to stop the victim resisting.

  • He literally choked one girl so brutally that a few seconds longer and she would have died.

  • I'm sure the family of his next victim will appreciate this decision...

  • Hes a sexual sadist just getting started. He will 100% kill a woman.

  • Give him the same treatment that brock turner got

    Oh you mean Brock Turner, who raped a woman behind a dumpster? Convicted rapist Brock Turner?

    I believe he legally changed or unofficially changed his name to Allen Turner.

    Oh, you mean convicted rapist Allen Turner? Who changed his name from Brock to distance himself from the rape he committed?

  • I hope this guy gets what's coming to him before he dies. Whether it's today or 10 years from now, hopefully he will get what's coming to him.

    Before he kills some poor girl. Because thats 100% where this is headed.

  • [deleted]

    If I was one of your jurors I would vote NOT GUILTY all day long.

  • If the court won’t give the victims the justice they deserve, then I hope someone else comes along and serves that justice. Fucking disgusting piece of shit.

  • So he should still be arrested and so should the judge. SINCE WHEN ARE ILLEGAL CRIMES NOT ILLEGAL???

    Nothing is illegal if you have enough money and power.

  • To any good ol boy/law enforcement/ex military vet with a punisher logo on their pick up… this young man deserves a “polite talking to” in regards to his bad behavior

  • We need to throw the judges name around.

    She’s corrupt.

    Susan Worthington is corrupt and shouldn’t be a judge!

    She has ties to the college his father worked for. She was not fit to make a ruling!

    Jesse Butler is human garbage.

  • The fuck you mean he's walking free‽

    Judge has ties to the university the kids dad worked at.. She clearly has a bias and or corruption going on.

    Her name is Susan Worthington

  • I pray that the streets will enact justice 😤

  • Jesse Butler, the rapist? Like Brock Turner, the rapist?

  • Raping people and nearly strangling them to death to the point of requiring surgery on the neck

    No jail time

    Thanks justice system for always being absolute trash and never doing anything right

  • You mean Jesse Butler the rapist?

  • I hope both victims use the reverted minor status to make a civil liability suit against the parents: if he was a minor at the time of the assault living under their care and was criminally charged as minor, much of the civil responsibility of the crime could fall on them. Much like a dog-owner is legally responsible for the dog's bite.

  • Th judge retired over backlash from this ruling. Susan Worthington also deserves no peace!

  • Would someone please confirm that I've read the comments correctly here? Right now, it's my understanding that the person of interest in this discussion is

    Jesse Mack Butler of Stillwater, Oklahoma, a raping rapist who

    rapes.

  • What did the judge say as the reason he isnt getting jail time?

    I’m pretty sure it’s because they tried him as a minor, Oklahoma has some weird laws about minors committing crimes and most of the time they get off way too easy.

  • The judge says: “boys will be boys” and then he chuckled and hit the gavel.

  • Man if I knew I could rape two girls and get off with a warning well goddamn high school would have been the same as it was because I'm not a fucking rapist.

  • Jesse Butler, the rapist from Oklahoma, who strangled a girl to the brink of death causing her to need a surgery? That Jesse Butler?

  • Since rapists aren’t the sort that can be rehabilitated, especially when facing zero consequences, I wonder what this judge is going to say to his next victim(s)? Because you know it’s going to happen with all the enablers in his life. This is a case where I’m totally ok with both vigilante justice and the death penalty and outright encourage it.

  • Shit like this is why I get so heated at the whataboutism when women commit crimes of sexual violence. No! "If a man did it" he actually would not be thrown in prison for life. Apparently nobody gets punished appropriately for crimes like this!!!

  • Jesus christ.

    So lemme get this straight, they had him dead to rights on all charges, but somehow this guy gets tried as a minor and gets a plea deal for no jail time?

    He must have...Connected parents.

  • I wonder if he is friends with the rapist Brock Turner. Seems like they could start a little club of privileged kids who are rapists with no consequences.

  • I seriously hope we can make sure people in his life know about this for the rest of his life

  • Why are there even plea deals for cases like these when there is evidence of the crime?? Just throw the whole book at the damn criminal.

  • Murdering this animal should be a counted as community service.

  • This headline is missing that it was attempted murder for one of them.

  • Jesse Butler is a rapist. He is Jesse Butler, the rapist. Rapist Jesse Butler. Make sure to let everyone online know!

  • This happened in my hometown, everyone here really fuckin hates not only Jesse, but the piece of shit judge too who let him walk free just for knowing his family. Fuck the both of them, I hope their justice gets served properly. Unfortunately we can no longer rely on judges around here to pass out the proper justice. Edit: Also, those weren't the only girls he's tried to lure away and do this too. My own sister-in-law has had this fuckin creep also try to lure her to come hang out with him by herself, luckily she had heard about these at the time rumors and stayed very far the fuck away from him. Fuck this guy and everything he stands for.

  • "Men" cry how false accusations will destroy lives, meanwhile women can bring evidence and more to court and the guy might still go free, either because of money ties or because we "can't ruin his future".

    Back as a kid, if I did anything wrong/different, as I am most likely neurodivergent, or got a bad grade, folks yelled at me how being like that makes me a failure etc. Glad to constantly see that being a lil quirky is seen as a bigger problem than being a fucking Rapist.

    I genuinley believe people are more annoyed by victims than by the bullies/Criminals

  • Oklahoma is an awful place

  • We need to start giving Jesse Butler the Rapist the same treatment as Brock Allen Turner the Rapist

  • Give it 6-12 months and he'll get a government position with a fat retirement plan. I'll be keeping an eye on this prick.

  • Cause he's a nice white Christian boy, if Jesus can forgive him so should we............NOT !!!!!

  • Where does The Rapist jesse butler live?

  • Fuck this guy and that other guy that was a college swimmer that got caught behind a dumpster doing the same shit to two girls, what’s his name? Brock? Was it Brock the rapist?

  • Given that this took place in backwards ass Oklahoma, he’d better grow eyes in the back of his head. That's potentially a LOT of brothers, uncles, cousins, and 2 extremely pissed off dads that will be gunning for his ass for the rest of his pathetic life. Looking forward to reading about how this all shakes out in the long run. I wouldn't want to be that judge either.

  • 2309 E will rogers drive, Stillwater OK

    Just gonna leave this here for anyone curious

  • This is one of those situations where everyone across the board wants him put in prison for life or worse so idk how he plans to live his life when everyone around him hates him

  • "Oklahoma teen found beaten to a pulp in back alley"

    Soon, is my prediction.

  • "boys will be boys" - the judge, probably

  • Yo i just saw the body cam vid of his arrest and the way his mom is just like hugging him and saying “it’s ok i love you we’re gonna win this” while he’s being taken away for violent rape by also a female officer

    bro. what. i feel like im taking crazy pills over here. what kind of mother? but i guess it makes sense in some sick way that she would be like that too

  • If one of the girls was my daughter, Jesse Butler the rapist would be about to learn a new and valuable lesson in life!

  • He wasn't even placed on the sex offender registry. He admitted guilt and literally nothing happened to him.

    He absolutely will hurt someone again. It will be on the judges hands and she needs to be investigated.