We’ve reviewed the draft paper from Breakthrough Listen (Jacobson-Bell et al., 2025) regarding the radio scans of Interstellar Object 3I/Atlas.

The mainstream headlines are already running with it: "No Technosignatures Found." They are using this "Null Result" to claim the object is just a rock.

However, when you look at the actual search parameters used in the paper, a massive strategic flaw emerges. The "official" conclusion relies on two assumptions that contradict the physical behavior of the object:

1. The Physics Contradiction: They admit the object is accelerating, yet they found no radio noise. Natural comets that accelerate due to outgassing are messy and "loud" in the radio spectrum. 3I/Atlas is accelerating like a rocket but is as silent as a stone.
2. The "Cell Phone" Fallacy: The paper explicitly states they searched for "isotropic continuous-wave transmitters" signals broadcasting in all directions simultaneously.

This begs the question: If you were a probe entering a potentially hostile system ("The Dark Forest"), would you be broadcasting omnidirectionally like a cell tower? Or would you use tight-beam, directional comms that look like silence to an outside observer?

We argue that this lack of signal doesn't prove it's a rock. It confirms Anomaly XVII: The Dark Mode Protocol.

We’ve published the full strategic dispatch, including the breakdown of the "471,198 hits" found in the raw data and the "Blind Spot" analysis.

Read the full Sentinel Report here.