Hey all I’m looking for some feedback on a couple of albums I recently released. The genre is country but there’s also country/rap country/pop There is a bunch of songs for different emotions. Breakups, heartbreaks, rollercoaster of good and bad, fun, vibes, party, love, prospering in your own skin and loving yourself, and a couple of marriage type songs, and songs for truckers, and beer drinkers . Also 1 awesome Christmas song if you love Christmas music. My inspiration comes from my love for all kinds of music and the joy it can bring people.
The first album “heartbreak hotel” tells a story from first song to last
The second album “American Roads and Sunday toasts” is a mix of hanging with the boys driving semis and a bunch of other stuff
The third album “beautiful facades” is about loving yourself woman and memories you created also I think there’s a really good marriage song in there called .moonlight on your shoulder.
This was made using Suno, with help from ChatGPT for lyrics and instrument concepts. I just wanted to share it with you. Whether you like it or not, I’d love to hear some honest feedback.
Artist name is Dusty Wiles
You can find the albums on all platforms YouTube TikTok instagram iheart
And here is the links for the main music sites
Apple Music - https://music.apple.com/us/artist/dusty-wiles/1856562465
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/artist/1bPux4aGBsRM5qMxP7rfMl?si=yyP-gIWhQr6LjMq_XMbKog
This is going to sound harsh. Because im sure you think you did something profound here...
You used AI to write your lyrics. You can't convince me you wrote the lyrics, because all of the AI lyric cliches are present here.
If you want to generate 100% AI generated music for yourself or for a YouTube channel or w/e, thats great. But you should not be distributing music like this to Spotify or any other music streaming platforms.
Its shit like this that causes so many to dislike AI music.
I am of the opinion that some AI assisted music does have its place on Spotify, when the person generating it puts time and effort into ensuring quality and originality. But this, this garbage.
Sorry not sorry.
Appreciate that. I know that I’m not the founder of ai music just creating something people can enjoy. I certainly enjoy it. And you’re right majority of the lyrics are from chat gpt I write a couple lines and it generates the song I want and the tone I want it in. Definitely appreciate your feedback. I’ll incorporate a lot more personal lyrics into the songs
You seem to have a decent ear for AI vs not, lyrically. Would you mind listening to a few songs to see if they sound "too AI" or if they feel lyrically authentic?
Dream in the Machine
A dark electro pop-rock song about over reliance on technology.
Rise Up
A punk rock Christian anthem about using faith faithfully, and not weaponizing it.
Tell Me
A track from the same Persona (Dead Orchid) as Rise Up. Mainly curious if the vocals feel similar enough to one another.
Reflections
A Megadeth inspired song about history being doomed to repeat itself.
I agree with this.
I really enjoyed your Heartbreak Hotel EP. What stood out to me is that the AI vocals aren’t constantly overpowering or drowning in excessive backing tracks like many others tend to be.
I also appreciate that every song is guitar-driven. it feels clean and authentic without being cluttered by heavy drums or distracting sounds.
“Missed Call” and “Wash You Away” were definite highlights for me; I genuinely enjoyed both.
That said, in the last three tracks the vocal inconsistency was quite noticeable. The voices didn’t feel cohesive, and I could tell some of the same ChatGPT-generated lyrics were being reused more often, which took away from the uniqueness.
I genuinely appreciate your review and will definitely look closer into your suggestions as I proceed further with my AI guy Dusty. I tried to tell a story in that album but I see how the same use of lyrics could destroy that. I feel my knowledge on the way ai creates is getting better if you haven’t listened to the 3rd album I feel like you would appreciate that one a little bit more thanks again for taking the time to review and lecture me on my ai crap as some call it
Of course! I’ll definitely listen to more of your singer and follow the Spotify artist
3 albums this year, and the songs all sound like Chatgpt. This sounds like AI, not a person composing.
The songs are all chat gpt. I give it a few lyrics and a concept and it gives me full lyrics. I’m not musician but I love music and wanted to create for me and if others enjoy it then that’s a plus. I appreciate your feedback and will look to incorporate more than just a few lines of lyrics.
I’d like to give my two cents on this as well. I’ve been writing songs for over 20 years, and I’d say I’m a decent guitarist and pianist. In all that time, I managed to record only about five songs ,none of them commercially viable so I ended up buried in the graveyard of the forgotten.
Then I discovered Suno. It helped me bring my visions to life in a way I never could before. I re-created most of my old tracks and melodies, and it retained the core of what I made—but the additional stems and assisted vocals it generated to enhance my work were absolutely game-changing.
I know some people show animosity toward AI, especially those who spent an arm and a leg on studio equipment or rentals. That’s expected. But honestly, just keep doing what you do. Music is a universal language, and creating it should be inclusive—not exclusive to those who can afford it.
A year or two from now people will be more accepting as this is how everything evolves
You may check out my songs here, my songs were created on some shape and form and accumulated for 2 decades now but I only get to give them a home now :)
https://open.spotify.com/artist/5w5cRDwSiozLxfb4r10pEo?si=zoG8v6YoQ5yopvrvM4MYJA
Yes ai is powerful and can do so much and bring so much back to life. It’s not all bad. I will definitely give your stuff a listen I appreciate your input into the ai
Will check yours as well :) giving you a follow
Will check it out when I'm home tonight.
Thank you I appreciate it. I’m here for all feedback good or bad.
Thanks ! Will check it out.