ah communism
the idea that never ever works due to human nature
and that is a convenient excuse to commit genocide spread hate and indoctrinate the population while a small elite rules over everyone else nad has soul less goons at their command
Just saying: people who repeated most Slava Stalin during their life time... were nkvd/kgb executioners, who said Slava Stalin before putting 7,62mm tokarev behind some pool person left ear...
Didn't he like commit a genocide in Ukraine? Holodomor? Also didnt he persecute anyone that followed religion hence explaining the drastic decline of Islam and Christianity in the Soviet Union
Ok, but like I am genuinely curious because I want to hear an answer to this question from someone who actually believes in communism rather than just capitalists who are pushing their agenda.
He was a nightmare for the Soviets. He would be like Trump today but worse. Watching him purge his political opposition day by day. He was also very far right.
There is no such thing as a communist state. Communism is a classless, moneyless, and stateless society where things are distributed according to peoples ability to work and to their needs.
He was the leader of what's called a state-capitalist state. A society in which the capitalist class was abolished and/or absorbed into the state.
Ya but we can't implement true communism in reality cause it's against human nature, people can't just work selflessly for the collective, that's why we (all Collectivist movements) support realistic vertion of communism called Socialism.
Unless we replace humans with AI for governance we can't reach true communism... And no I don't want to rule by some machines.
Communism in this time period wasn't modern and didn't allow stuff like Gay Rights. Stalin was a Slavic Supremacist and the Soviet Union often acted in racism towards its minorities. The Soviet Unions leadership was divided amongst the left and right itself and Stalin purged many progressive members who were in opposition.
Stalin believed that LGBT stuff is western Capitalist concept which explains his homophobia, and his purges are more about paranoia then Ideological difference.
but ya I can't explain his Slavic Supremacism, he wasn't himself a slavic.
Gonna attempt to twist your brain here. He was a Soviet Fascist!
He was radical about a Communist and Soviet identity. Communist and Soviet Culture. Communist and Soviet Traditionalism. He was a fascist about Soviet Culture!
Dude, no, Stalin was one of the best soviet rulers, the USSR literally flourished under him, I say this as a person who spent a lot of time studying the history of the USSR, and I am from Russia, I know
yes, it happened, and it's very sad, but it's worth considering that collectivization and forced industrialization had a huge impact on the Soviet economy in the future. It is also worth knowing that russian peasants did not want to transition from the capitalist system, selling agricultural products not to the authorities, but to private entrepreneurs. Revolution and communism are communism, but everyone wanted to live well, they can be understood
Hey there u/Confident_Law4842, thanks for posting to r/SuddenlyCommunist!
Please recheck if your post break any rules. If it does, please delete this post.
Also reposting and posting obvious non-sudden communist posts can lead to a ban
JOIN OUR DISCORD SERVER - > https://discord.gg/agcKtyv74Q
Send us a Modmail or Report this post if you have a problem with this post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Clearly the voice of of the workers!!!
That's how they occupied Berlin. A homeless person doesn't have a home; they have a location where they are staying.
https://preview.redd.it/7ihzuv9zy44g1.jpeg?width=952&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=37b41b902cb4bf58c0427b4c5ef1816bd8ec6aef
Over 170 million dead. Thanks communism 💪
Correction: 170 million per day
Who genocided > 8 milion people
ah communism
the idea that never ever works due to human nature
and that is a convenient excuse to commit genocide spread hate and indoctrinate the population while a small elite rules over everyone else nad has soul less goons at their command
🤣🤣🤣
He was pretty bad
What about you?
https://preview.redd.it/r12wibdutg4g1.jpeg?width=600&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a1ac35afa7ff27ca78b6e96d20f0f2c6735949a4
Just saying: people who repeated most Slava Stalin during their life time... were nkvd/kgb executioners, who said Slava Stalin before putting 7,62mm tokarev behind some pool person left ear...
когда тонул корабль, сталин первым прыонул в шлюпку. ему кричали: товарищ сталин, на корабле остались дети! но он ответил: спасибо, но я не голоден
Gaucho like the adolf
While he murdered millions. Don't wanna bring that up, huh? Nothing great about this cretin ever. Think for yourself.
I didn't wanna get dematized or banned.
Didn't he like commit a genocide in Ukraine? Holodomor? Also didnt he persecute anyone that followed religion hence explaining the drastic decline of Islam and Christianity in the Soviet Union
Ima bout to delete this post and my account 😀
Ok, but like I am genuinely curious because I want to hear an answer to this question from someone who actually believes in communism rather than just capitalists who are pushing their agenda.
The leftist's magic excuse: it's not to my taste so it's the extreme right.
He was a nightmare for the Soviets. He would be like Trump today but worse. Watching him purge his political opposition day by day. He was also very far right.
How can be he far right if he was a Communist leader leading a Communist state.
There is no such thing as a communist state. Communism is a classless, moneyless, and stateless society where things are distributed according to peoples ability to work and to their needs.
He was the leader of what's called a state-capitalist state. A society in which the capitalist class was abolished and/or absorbed into the state.
Ya but we can't implement true communism in reality cause it's against human nature, people can't just work selflessly for the collective, that's why we (all Collectivist movements) support realistic vertion of communism called Socialism.
Unless we replace humans with AI for governance we can't reach true communism... And no I don't want to rule by some machines.
Communism in this time period wasn't modern and didn't allow stuff like Gay Rights. Stalin was a Slavic Supremacist and the Soviet Union often acted in racism towards its minorities. The Soviet Unions leadership was divided amongst the left and right itself and Stalin purged many progressive members who were in opposition.
Stalin believed that LGBT stuff is western Capitalist concept which explains his homophobia, and his purges are more about paranoia then Ideological difference.
but ya I can't explain his Slavic Supremacism, he wasn't himself a slavic.
Oh I thought Georgians were Slavs, my bad!
Nope Georgians are Kartvelian
[deleted]
Gonna attempt to twist your brain here. He was a Soviet Fascist!
He was radical about a Communist and Soviet identity. Communist and Soviet Culture. Communist and Soviet Traditionalism. He was a fascist about Soviet Culture!
Dude, no, Stalin was one of the best soviet rulers, the USSR literally flourished under him, I say this as a person who spent a lot of time studying the history of the USSR, and I am from Russia, I know
Don't mean this as a cheap jab. Didn't he cause a famine for large regions and portions of people?
yes, it happened, and it's very sad, but it's worth considering that collectivization and forced industrialization had a huge impact on the Soviet economy in the future. It is also worth knowing that russian peasants did not want to transition from the capitalist system, selling agricultural products not to the authorities, but to private entrepreneurs. Revolution and communism are communism, but everyone wanted to live well, they can be understood