My original rating for this movie was 7/10. Solid, but a bit out of what I expected a Johns era movie should be about. All this time later, rewatching the movie I think there are more layers to enjoy in it, but I also deepened by problems with it. I think the movie rushes a lot through Hal's origin and it doesn't establish well neither Hal as a character or Abin Sur (he's one of the most important lanterns in the lore, but here he looks like an afterthought), but that's relatively okay since the movie does a great job establishing Hal's personality, resourcefullness and heroism later on. Anyway, although I love early Silver Age Hal Earth adventures, we know from the Ryan Reynolds movie how much to detriment of an adaptation focusing on Earth can be, so I get Burnnet in this one. This being an Alan Burnnet film, DCAU alumni, actually explain some of my issues with it: there is so much unnecessary violence in it, which is something I feel in all DCAU alumni projects after DCAU itself, like they have a need to express their freedom from TV censors, but I don't know, it goes too far for me. The Boodika death is super gruesome, and the ring not having a lethal force block (which was a pretty big plot point in Sinestro Wars) frustrates me. I also think the Boodika villain twist works in the sense that it shows Hal being resourcefull and brave to fight an experienced lantern without the ring, bit it has veru flimsy buind up. In this rewatch, I also noticed the first half-hour is very influenced by "Training Day", where the corrupt cop played by Denzel Washington shows the ropes to a young idealist cop played by Ethan Hawke, who step by step realises he's been trained by a criminal. I think this segment is brillant and should have lasted longer. Actually, the movie is just too rushed, we go from storyline to storyline burning through decades of Green Lantern history. This takes me to the fusing of Esmerald Twilight and Sinestro Wars: it is a fun idea, but it forces the viewer's sense of verissimilitude to believe Hal would become Ion/Torchbearer in his first days as GL (and I can totally see Kyle fans being frustrated by that, just as much as with Beware my Power). Also, to have Tomar-Re killed to show how evil Sinestro has become and how much devastating the Esmerald Twilight is makes sense, but it follows an unfortunate trend to treat Tomar-Re as an unimportant or side lantern, who can even be killed to show how powerfull the antagonist is, when he's the first non-human lantern we've ever meet jn the comics, and the most important one until Killowog was created (love our big pink pig, but ge stole Tomar's limelight). I also strongly dislike Isamot Kol being a background lantern who dies in the same scene, obviously). All in all, I'll keep my rating of 7/10, I could see this movie improving if it was a trilogy covering the beginning and development of Hal, and also developing the Sinestro threat and trason in the background, until we had a whole movoe just for tge Twilight.
All images must be correctly sourced depending on what type of image it is. Comic book-related images should have the name of the artist OR the issue it came from. Other types of images must also be correctly sourced where applicable. If your post was made without the source, you can do so as a post edit or as a comment. Failure to include the source will result in your post being removed. If this was already done, we thank you for your diligence.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
With all of its faults (and tbh I prefer Emerald Knights), it at least provides a framework that the Reynolds movie could have followed.
Didn't like it much? I liked it a lot. It's a one-and-done movie. Maybe it was meant to springboard the animated series, but it didn't.
I don't think Abin Sur needs much characterization. He's there to give the ring to Hal. Then it's a matter of where the story takes place: Earth or space? The live action movie tries to split it's time and kind of fails at it. I think concentrating on space is the right idea.
I also don't think it fuses Emerald Twilight and Sin Corps. It just uses Sinestro newest costume and ramps up his threat level to movie level proportions for his "fall of Sinestro" story. If anything it fuses Emerald Dawn and Emerald Dawn II, fusing the threat of Legion and Sinestro. There Hal also taps the power of the CPB to solve the big problem and save OA and the GLC.
Hal saving the GLC on his first day or so ... it doesn't bother me. It's a super hero story. There's a bit of a time skip where he could have slept. I really don't think the movie is just one long lay; I never got that sense.
The deaths of prominent GLs and Boodika's betrayal hurt my feelings, but also ... it's a one-and-done movie too. I guess I don't care as much. You see it as "burning through decades of GL history", but I see it as a one and done movie that introduces fans to decades of GL history and concepts more effectively and the live action movie.
But I do find fault for saying it should be three movies. It is what it is. This is the format. Even Wondy got the one movie. Non Batman and Superman characters get the one movie. GL isn't going to get three right off the bat. Trying to hold back Sinestro for the future is what stopped both the live action movie and the animated series from actually getting to use him as a villain. They assumed they had more time than they did and what was the result? No time at all.
I agree with you that it is nice we got a good villain Sinestro adaptation because of this movie
I love this movie as a kid and I still love it as an adult. I do agree they coulda fleshed out the move as a whole more but it’s like an hour and 17 minute animated movie made on a 2000s WB animated movie budget so it’s great for what it is. Emerald Knight clears tho.
the only reason was the real hero sinestro lost.
15 YEARS LATER?
Dammnn I'm old...
It is actually 16 years old, I only watched it in 2010 lol
Honestly, think it's the best GL story in a moving medium. (film, tv animation). Full stop.
I honestely prefer Emerald Knights and TAS