They won’t shut up

I posted one of my ai generated art on a sub Reddit called art is for everyone and I got good comments but then this asshole just attacks me saying it’s not art. I tried to reason with who ever this is saying it’s ai art generated. Why can they accept people’s opinions 😡 so I just blocked this piece of shit. Just wanted to share

33 points Kaizo_Kaioshin
"art requires feeling to be art"

Well I FEEL that ai art is art.

parent

9 points animestar218

Thank you I think that too

parent root

1 points Brospeh-Stalin

Just so you know, if you acknowledge that AI "art" isn't art, then I'm all cool. I use AI to generate images for fun (SDXL), but even I know that it really isn't art.

But I will say this: when I program, an LLM can really speed up my workflow if I know what I'm doing, and don't over-rely on it.

Even a cybersecurty class of mine gives us a free GPT-5 to use to help us solve different problems, granted that we don't get "LLM brain."

Edit: I'm not an anti. Just saying that calling AI images art is kinda incorrect. Make AI images all you want but don't call it art. I think OP already said that they have never felt it was art.

Edit 2: maybe op didn't say that idk.

parent root

1 points animestar218

Thank you for your comment

parent root

1 points Brospeh-Stalin

Np. I genuinely don't want to be mean or anything so I am sorry if I came out as disrespectful in any way.

parent root

1 points animestar218

That’s ok 👍

parent root

2 points Brospeh-Stalin

I will say this. You should definitely learn how AIs generate images. Specifically what the diffusion algorithm is.

It's actually pretty interesting if you like learning math.

parent root

1 points animestar218

Thank you

parent root
2 points Brospeh-Stalin
Well, according to Google and oxford:

Dictionary

Definitions from Oxford Languages · Learn more

art¹

/ärt/

noun

noun: art; plural noun: arts; plural noun: the arts

the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power. "the art of the Renaissance"

So if you can proove that writing prompts shows "the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination," then it will quite literally shut the antis up.

parent root

7 points Kaizo_Kaioshin

I mean...who wrote the prompt? Me

Who fixed it time and time again until it gives me what I want? Me

Who imagines what the image should look like? Me, always me.

parent root

0 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent root

3 points laseluuu

I stopped at 'does it need to be creative'

No, no it doesn't. But it can be. Same as doing pour art abstracts.

That doesn't float my artistic boat at all in the slightest, but other people like it.

parent root

1 points Brospeh-Stalin

I stopped at 'does it need to be creative'

Oh so you read the whole the whole thing, cuz 'does it need to be creative' is not found anywhere in my comment?

parent root

-1 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent root

2 points duckduckduckgoose8

You could argue trained artists are conditioned in the same way. Artists used to study dead horses hoisted to the cielings, observing every detail as the body decays. I think I like Ai's method, its more ethical.

parent root

1 points Brospeh-Stalin

its more ethical.

Just curious as to how so? From what I see on the media, all the big AI companies are being sued for training LLMs on copyrighted data.

parent root

1 points laseluuu

Haha no, sorry!

I'm using AI and it's arty as ****. That's a you skill issue.

parent root

1 points AutoModerator

In an effort to discourage brigading, we do not allow linking to other subreddits or users. We kindly ask that you screenshot the content that you wish to share, while being sure to censor private information, and then repost.

Private information includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames, other subreddits, and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

parent root

1 points BTRBT

This isn't the appropriate subreddit for this argument. This space is for pro-AI activism. If you want to debate the artistic merits of synthography, then please take it to r/aiwars.

parent root
2 points Key_Relationship_117

Yet if I scribble it's apparently better than anything AI can make

parent root
12 points AuthorSarge

It's very liberating to not tie yourself to what others think. I don't need the world to agree with me.

parent

6 points animestar218

Same here

parent root
15 points SkywardTexan2114

Just block people like this honestly, I've been blocking more people lately because at a bare minimum, a slight majority of the users are bots, trolls, or both.

parent

8 points animestar218

Yes I know I blocked that person just being a sore loser

parent root
6 points hello-xworld
The literal definition of art is to invoke emotion. If AI art achieves that, then by definition that is art.

So yes, if a piece of banana taped on the wall is considered art, then who’s to say AI art is not art?

Why is that so hard to understand?

Btw I think the poster you made is adorable. I hope you continue your journey!

parent
2 points animestar218
Thank you I appreciate that

parent root

3 points CMDRTornadopelt

I also love AI art, because it's freaking awesome.

parent root

1 points animestar218

Thank you I love ai art too

parent root

2 points CMDRTornadopelt

I like it for two main reasons.

It lets me see what kind of crazy concepts I can come up with, for shiggles.

...uh... yeah, the less said about my history, the better

parent root

1 points animestar218

Yes

parent root
9 points mah29001

All they say is slop. That’s always a flop to me.

parent

2 points animestar218

Yes

parent root
2 points tainted_judas1

As someone who dislike AI but like REALLY, this person is an asshole

parent

2 points animestar218

I know and I’m not against anyone who dislikes ai art just the rude one that attacked other people that like it

parent root
2 points Apathetic_Armadillo

I understand that posting AI on a subreddit that's banned it is bad, but it is clearly allowed on that one. They aren't being a noble crusader of good values like they like to think, they're just being a jerk.

parent

2 points animestar218

You are right about that

parent root
2 points ProGamer8273

Hey at least you beat John Dickhead in upvotes

parent

1 points animestar218

Thanks

parent root
2 points RemarkableWish2508

People: "Art requires effort and emotion"

Also people: "Coding requires no effort or logic... AI doesn't do it for me, it's trash!"

You can't reason with people who refuse to reason.

parent

1 points animestar218

I know they are stubborn

parent root
2 points BTRBT

Really, your best option is to just block these guys.

Retorts tend to just encourage them, and can never be effective enough to get them to stop. The only exception might be if you're genuinely nice to them, but that's up to you.

parent

1 points animestar218

Yeah I blocked them

parent root
1 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent

1 points BTRBT

This isn't the appropriate subreddit for this argument. This space is for pro-AI activism. If you want to debate the merits of synthography, then please take it to r/aiwars.

parent root
-3 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent

2 points BusyNoise315

Because you are suffering from mental illness..🤷‍♂️

parent root
-4 points Appropriate_Head_873

Your actually deluded holy

parent
-3 points Informal_Pressure_21

I advise you to remove that yellow filter from the art

parent

3 points GaiusVictor

For those who are interested in this, make sure to add the following to your ChatGPT prompt: "Avoid warm color cast. Set white balance to 6000k". You can also go for 7000k for a bright, sunny morning outside lightning, or 8000k for a cooler, blue lighting.

parent root

-1 points Informal_Pressure_21

Man I got downvoted for no reason

parent root

1 points BTRBT

So tired of the "no yellow allowed!" sentiment.

It's okay for pictures to have a yellow tint. There's nothing wrong with it.

parent root
-5 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent

4 points ItzLoganM

I don't think you want to stop seeing this sub tbh.

parent root

2 points animestar218

Don’t like it don’t bother commenting it

parent root

1 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent root

2 points AutoModerator

In an effort to discourage brigading, we do not allow linking to other subreddits or users. We kindly ask that you screenshot the content that you wish to share, while being sure to censor private information, and then repost.

Private information includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames, other subreddits, and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

parent root

1 points Brospeh-Stalin

you could mute the sub you know

I don't cuz I like ragebait

parent root

-2 points aight_imma_afk

I didn’t, thanks 🙏🙏

parent root
-7 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent

5 points Kubaj_CZ

https://preview.redd.it/7w3awleeom6g1.png?width=1024&format=png&auto=webp&s=8f865395511c6ca774e4b5ee5476cb8bff16de5a

parent root

-3 points [deleted]

[deleted]

parent root

5 points Kubaj_CZ

AI art isn't art? Then explain this

https://preview.redd.it/9ucjmd323n6g1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c0c6674d0d2702d3c3a5e184794626c53c6dc43d

parent root

-2 points [deleted]

[removed]

parent root

1 points BTRBT

This isn't the appropriate subreddit for this argument. This space is for pro-AI activism. If you want to debate the artistic merits of synthography, then please take it to r/aiwars.

parent root

Dictionary