Over the last few years a number of the craft breweries who popped up in the late 80’s-late 90’s have gone under. Who is next? I have a few hunches but let me know what yall think, it can be a very well known brewery like Sierra Nevada (which won’t happen just an example) or a more regional legacy brewery like river horse out of NJ.
I’m worried about the brewers who focused on sours, really any single style brewery
The Rare Barrel comes to mind. I had some bottles a few years ago (probably 6-7 years at this point) and they were amazing, albeit expensive sours. Looks like they were bought out recently?
Yeah they got bought by cellarmaker a couple years back
Yup, and it seems those types of breweries are stubborn and refuse to diversify their styles
I get what you're saying, but craft brewing needs more specialists, not less. I might buy an Allahash hazy, but I want something from their coolship. Brewers need to differentiate. There's so much of the same styles in the shelves today, please be stubborn.
It’s not about what the brewers want. It’s about what the customers drink.
We’re losing a great sour brewery in Nashville. Just found out this week.
They just lost the building to eminent domain, the brewery isn’t going under financially. There’s still hope they find a new location.
I hope you’re right, but I think you’re wrong.
Who? Please don’t say Southern Grist
Barrique Brewing and Blending
What?!?! Damn that is awful to hear.
Southern Grist is also going under (acquired by Xul)
That is a bummer!
My day has been immeasurably ruined.
Sours are the best tho
I agree, support your local sour brewers
midwest/missouri regional - Schlafly
they’ve been on a steep downward slide ever since the original founders left…
sucks as they were important for craft beer 30+ years ago in missouri; taking on big beer…getting laws changed to enable brewpubs and microbreweries in the state. all right in AB’s backyard.
Schlafly is a seasonal brewery in my mind so it wouldn't surprise me. Mostly pumpkin beers and maybe the Christmas ale but I can't see that being sustainable.
Could see it. I live 2 hours from St. Louis and visit at least once a year. I’ve never had one of their beers. As far back as 2012ish when I got in to craft they were seen as “grocery store beers.”
I know some old heads in STL that will support that place til it dies, but man I have no idea how they stay open. The beer is so underwhelming, and their spaces are big and empty whenever I’m there.
I love Schlafly. My partner and I travel every year from out of state to go visit their brewery!
I'm from Delaware. Dogfish has been struggling for years to stay relevant in the beer community. I see more of their selzters and mixed drink cans than beer on the shelves. The brewpub is not all that great and in a location that tends to ward off people looking for craft beer. It used to be 60 Minute at every bbq, now you see a lot more Fiddlehead IPA (VT) and Big Oyster beers (also DE). When i turned 21, Dogfish had so many good, eclectic beers. Now they all taste the same.
Idk, them and Boston Beer joined, so they’re up there as one of the largest craft breweries. And that company has done decent job of finding alternate brands leading to stable success.
Fair enough. I guess from the perspective of someone near the brewery, it seems less prevelant in the area. We used to be all DFH, all the time. Now its just... an option.
Victory and Dogfish have been around for 30 years now….two of my favorite legacy brewers. But damn if those mergers and acquisitions haven’t absolutely killed those brands.
I don’t know why corporations take a brand and turn it into absolutely generic slop. Do I really need 10 different varieties of Hop Monkey? Where’s Hop Wallop? (Oh, it’s on tap occasionally at their brewpubs now). Why are their cans and logos and design all look so generic and boring now? That’s it…those brands are BORING now. The beer is still ok…just boring and the same generic stuff over and over again.
Those breweries have lost their spirit because they don’t innovate anymore. Dogfish used to try all kinds of crazy new things. Not anymore. I can’t imagine DFH ever doing their Ancient Ales series again. Again…their beers are still…ok, but there’s a lot of new breweries doing some new things, experimenting and innovating a bit, and I’d rather try new or at least exciting than generic or boring.
Corporate beer sucks. Because corporate beer is either lower quality swill or boring mass produced soulless beer.
Oh man, Victory is so bad now.
Yeah, idk I spent a good chunk of my life believing the whole point of craft beer and being a craft brewery was to never sell out, silly me
100% I miss the ancient ales. ImmortAle was my favorite beer while it lasted.
I wish 16 Mile Brewing would’ve stuck around longer, they had some good brews, but I’m still a big fan of DFH and I love Big Oyster!
Big Oysters brewpub is out of this world. Awesome oyster chowder and crab cakes!
100%!!! I spend a lot of time in Rehoboth, and BO is one of the most solid places around there.
Here in Austin TX area, they are easy to find in the main grocery store chain that has a section for craft beers only. I get my fix from time to time.
Funny you mention River Horse. I finally made my way out to visit their brewery, and it was depressing. Their taphouse was barely hanging on. If Flying Fish could go under, I don’t see how River Horse sticks around unless their strategy was to pull back and go small and super regional.
They also purchased Duclaw about 2.5 years ago.
Damn, so THAT'S why DuClaw went to shit.
They used to send most of their great stuff to North Carolina but the only thing I've seen on a shelf in years is that goddamned Peanut Butter crap.
Used to be a HUGE DuClaw whore. Not anymore.
Husband and I went to DuClaw a few years back because it was my favorite brewery. We drove in 2hrs of traffic to get there. They were out of so many beers, and the food was HORRIBLE. Haven't had the beer since.
I remember Baltimore having a really good craft beer scene ten years ago. Recently was back for a college visit trip and I was shocked that most of the breweries had scaled back, closing their brewpubs and doing production only in the suburbs. We had a great time visiting one of the DuClaw locations, now they have one tiny one out by the airport.
Seems like any “legacy” craft brewery that dies off does it because of a few reasons:
Seems most successful breweries tend to stay local/regional or if they’re national to just keep going at their current production. Explains why a Russian River and Sierra Nevada are still in the business. #1 challenge for most breweries (as is true of many businesses) is scale. How to balance the size of the business with the financial costs to grow or maintain production.
They were slowly going downhill before that. Closed up all the brew pubs. Barely had a taproom (It was occasionally open to the public). Started churning out mediocre crap. Tried bringing back some of the old staples, but that didn’t last long. They went hard into sours and the “Sweet Baby _____” series.
Duclaw stopped selling where I’m at like 3-4 years ago, river horse to me is a sad story, in its heyday it was great, the Lambertville NJ location etc, once they left Lambertville they held on good for a little while but now even in NJ they’re distribution is scaling back hard
I thought the beer at River Horse was pretty good, but I’ve been to over 80 breweries in NJ and that was hands down the worst taproom I have ever seen in my life. Super depressing vibes there.
I’m amazed they got to be as big as they are, since I never thought their stuff was that good
Smuttynose in NH. Huge in the 2010s with finest kind IPA and some other great seasonals. Pretty sure they no longer brew their own beer and I visited last month and it was depressing. Even the employees don’t seem to care about their beer/success
Damn that's brutal to hear
Aw man, old brown dog will always be one of my faves
That’s really sad to hear. Smuttynose was always fantastic in my experience. Old brown dog and very old brown dog were top tier.
Loved Finest Kind IPA. Haven’t seen it on a shelf in a while.
Flying Dog? They still around? Or Heavy Seas?
Flying Dog is owned by MattFX (Saranac) and Heavy Seas aligned with some group
Flying dog is on the decline but still does decently where im at, better than others mentioned in the comments
Flying Dog moved out of MD up to NY for distribution. So beyond meh. Not sure how they are hanging on. Heavy seas is the biggest distributor in Maryland now but also meh beer. We shall see.
Both seem to have some financial backing that will give them a few more years.
FD pulled out of MI sometime around Covid. That can’t help.
Southern Tier
Their Girl Scout cookie flavored pastry stouts were my gateway into craft beer. So disappointed with how they’ve fallen off
I don’t see that happening . Them , victory and six point (and maybe more ) are all owned by the same company for a few years now .
I agree with you. But they seem so insistent on pushing their 2x varieties of IPAs and they’re the worst beers they make. Screams voodoo ranger juice force vibes.
The 15 pack of their varieties is quickly becoming inedible
I remember that era, they definitely tried to compete with new Belgium but got overshadowed hard
I agree, six point also still does really well for pumpking in the fall, really one of like a handful of pumpkin beers that still sells well.
Edit: southern tier lol
I tried visiting their smalltown taproom last summer and it was packed. I'm not sure how Cleveland, Pittsburgh, and Charlotte do
I have no basis for this, but Abita. It's been pretty consistently mediocre since its inception and they just don't seem to be adapting to the market at all.
They remind me a lot of Rogue in that it's a semi large brand you can find in many parts of the country, and it used to be considered good, but it's been left behind by craft beer becoming more interesting. What they offer is just not that exciting anymore.
I've never been able to figure out Abita. They have some solid beers; I think Turbodog is an underrated gem and a perfect lunch beer. But the stuff they choose to distribute widely, like Purple Haze, I find not great (and declined in quality over the years).
I guess what I'm saying is I don't know whether they need more innovation in their brewing program or in their distribution.
I think you’re right on the distribution point. I don’t live too far from there and I can usually find a great variety at our local grocery chains and stores but not much else when we travel more than a couple hours from home.
It’s no secret Great Lakes isn’t in great financial shape.
Don’t say that. I need to keep the Edmund Fitzgerald Porter flowing.
Yikes! Need to do my Cleveland brewery tour sooner than later!
Source? I'm fairly local to Cleveland and this is the first I've heard of this.
Absolutely false. One of the top craft beer sellers in OH.
Avery? I know little about them but they seem take up a bunch of shelf space and I feel like I never see anyone buy it. Including me. Maybe I’m missing something.
They are owned by Mahou San Miguel, same company that owns founders. They got the resources and money for that shelf space.
Drakes
I think that's a good guess.
Their beer is fine but they're in that dead zone of too big to be a cool kid boutique brand and too small to be in every grocery store in the country.
That middle ground is guaranteed death.
I knew someone in management there about 8-10 years ago and I'm shocked they're still in business after hearing how incompetent ownership and management was.
On top of that, their beer is pretty awful. They're loved in the Bay area though.
The Bay, that’s about it. They recently bought Bear Republic…like that’ll help
There are several good breweries on that side of The Bay that beat Drakes. I think Drakes was actually one of my least favorite spots over there and last time I was over there was like 7 or 8 years ago. Almanac, Faction, Alameda, and Ghost Town all pop to mind just off the top of my head.
Ghost town is my favorite here. Almanac is cool, but I think them and faction will also fall if the industry keeps going the way it is
I could see it. Faction's location is both great and bad at the same time. Faction has that large open area outside with a great view of the bay and the city but its out of the way. Almanac suffers the same issue of out of the way but doesnt have the view. I did like the rotating taps next door from Admiral Maltings. If I remember right there was a distillery and winery that opened out that way before Covid but not sure if that helped build up the area or if any plans for that stopped with the pandemic. Ghost Town was definitely my favorite for that area. Further north was Armistice Brewing in Richmond I think or around there that was smaller but really good.
Send me a balance sheet and I will let you know. The breweries that are highly leveraged are the ones that will most likely fail. Rogue had incredible distribution all over the world, and even a decent product, but still got swept under because they didn’t know how to manage their finances
I worry about the future of the industry, its a hyper-saturated market. I remember reading an article like 7 years ago about how there were officially over 10,000 craft breweries in the US, which has undoubtedly climbed since then. I live in the Midwest and every small town has their own little brewery now. Some of them have only on-site availability, some bottle/can and distribute their products around the state. Most are mid, some are pretty good, but there are just sooooo many.
Also, consumers are slowing down on discretionary spending due to economic conditions anyway.
One of the best ways to try to figure this out is pull up the production report from the Brewer’s Association from the last 3 years and see which breweries have seen a decline or are stagnant in barrel output in that time frame. Those are the breweries that are struggling. Breweries that are still growing aren’t necessarily “killing it” like they were a decade ago but there is a little less stress on the leadership team.
Lost Coast
I don’t know. They’ve got a good brewpub and i think they own a nearby hotel. They haven’t over leveraged or expanded beyond their means. Eureka is a good stop between NorCal and Oregon.
Would be fine with them brewing a new beer once in a while, though.
I always stop there on my road trips to Oregon, and I would say their beer is pretty mid, but still make a point to go.
I would agree they have a good location, for road trippers, they have the pub/restauraunt and have limited their expansion to keep it manageable (from an outside perspective).
Which hotel do they own?
Honestly shocked they are still around. Everything about them screams 90s. Love some of their OGs though.
They have terrible management and turnover issues. They advertise for new brewers every few months on ProBrewer.
Cigar City is a shell of its former self.
Cycle is gone.
I’m worried some other semi-big breweries like Sun King will fizzle out.
[deleted]
Too much voodoo ranger success for that to happen
Voodoo ranger sucks across the board
Yeah it does, but your average Joe Schmoe or cost conscious consumer sees a high octane beer, especially in a 19.2 format, for dirt cheap. It’s good bang for your buck. The shit flies off the shelves.
Yes it does, but man they sell a lot of them. Anywhere from people picking up 2 at a gas station to people in nice supermarkets buying packs. I think it’s an easy IPA for non-craft drinkers to dive into. Kinda like the miller/coors/bud to blue-moon pipeline.
And it’s the largest selling “craft” brand in America
Not for alcoholics trying to get a quick buzz off of a 9.5% abv 19.2 oz can for $3…
They’re about to drop a higher ABV one and the same cans as well.
I almost hope New Belgium folds with how bad Voodoo Ranger stuff is, and how widely it’s forced upon the US (if not internationally).
[deleted]
Yea, but that expanded 19.2 voodoo ranger lineup makes them a lot of $$. It’s the Four Loco for the semi sophisticated
Those voodoo ranger tall boys move like you wouldn’t believe
You can always tell the people in this subreddit who work in the industry and don’t lol. Thinking New Belgium is gonna go under anytime is hilarious. All the legacy craft brands are trying to figure out how to mimic their success because of how well they are doing.
My best friend works at one of their production facilities and his location just brewed their first beer since August.
I'd be curious to know what they make, also which production facility? I lived in Fort Collins the last 12 years and know many people who work at the facility in Fort Collins and that thing is churning out beverages 24/7.
The new one in SWVA. Used to be the Ballast Point east coast location years ago. They didn’t make anything from August to November, then some premade cocktail stuff, their alcoholic tea, and the sugar water they add to all their beers to raise the ABV. They brewed their first beer again just like two weeks ago.
I still unironically like Imperial Ranger tall boys lol I think the flavor is great and the high ABV is a nice bonus
450 printed money for years with those slushees. I def could see them going under in the next 5 years or so.
450 knows their target audience very well, but it’s debatable if said audience stays devoted. They may have a decent shot at attracting some NA converts since their ABVs are so low.
Voodoo Ranger is the best selling IPA in America. It isn’t going anywhere lol.
450 is dogshit. I live in the 3rd largest city in Indiana and our distributors don’t sell their beer here. Supposedly the lying about their ABV burned a lot of bridges.
I bought the new Belgium tripell six pack last month and it was refreshing to taste a Belgium style beer again. Go back to those roots!
It's a nice Tripel!
You bought the one six pack that liquor store sells a month of that style of beer. There is a reason they don’t make more of that style.
At this point I feel like New Belgium deserves to fail. I have only seen IPA's since 2023.
They might make Belgian beers, but they don't distribute them far. Even BLUE MOON has a strong ale that is not an IPA available near me. Its not great, but at least its not an IPA.
They have an all-Belgian mix 24pk in Costco country-wide right now, they’re doing just fine.
haha I was not aware. I heard Devils Backbone is making the store brand beer one of those places too👀
Deschutes makes the Costco Kirkland beers, their logo is on the boxes, but I wouldn’t be surprised if DB had another one of the big box stores on contract.
I had the Deschutes/kirkland vintage ale tonight and keep the Kirkland helles in my beer fridge for a cheap sipper. Both are solid. Don’t see deschutes losing their business anytime soon.
Agreed. That Helles has won two GABF medals so far, it’s on regular rotation in our fridge too.
DB is AB so it wouldn't surprise me
They’ll eventually rebrand to something like NB Beverages or something. They are starting to get into RTDs and make way more than beer now. Give it a few years but they officially won’t be known as New Belgium anymore.
I mean if Dunkin DONUTS can rebrand as Starbucks but Pink anything is possible.
I could see something like Souther Tier or Sixpoint - or another brewery that is part of a collective that isn’t pulling their weight. PE is probably better off discounting and re-focusing the efforts on growing portions of their portfolio.
Sixpoint barely gets carried in any good liquor stores in NJ anymore, if that isn’t a sign idk what is
I distribute Sixpoint, we move their stuff like it’s water. It’s a cash cow for us.
NY?
Florida
Florida is selling about 20% of the Sixpoint it did 5-10 years ago. If it’s a cash cow now you should have seen it when the brand was actually doing well down there.
That’s interesting
Oddly I’m not surprised, Florida is like 10 years behind in craft beer terms
Maybe that’s why it’s selling so well
After all this time they finally have a taproom in Brooklyn now, too.
No, they already closed that location. They do have a taproom in Manhattan still though.
Right. I think River Horse and breweries similar to their size/caliber are all but gone.
They moved their primary operations to Charlotte, NC a few years ago with the collective.
Night Shift in MA has gone way downhill since they stopped brewing their own beer during the pandemic. They were bought out by Jack's Abby about a year ago and the crazy part is I love everything JA puts out, but the last few beers I've had from NS were undrinkable.
Anderson valley recently did layoffs and Fal posted about how it’s not healthy financially and the current owners aren’t even paying themselves. Their flagship styles aren’t popular anymore. High chance they spiral.
One of the VC groups will throw in the towel. The brands may be sold but that will be the end of the brands as anything other than shells. Some wools argue they already are. Think Canarchy, craft revolution, 10th barrel.
Local regional one, but Henhouse in Sonoma County.
I wouldn't be surprised to see Elysian go under soon
Wondrous in Emeryville is solid as they come.
Who do you think will? I want to know.
You are too kind lol; in my opinion saranac, Weyerbacher, river horse, six point for regional legacy breweries in my area. Outside and more nationally I’d say Great Lakes, smuttynose and Firestone. At least by me Firestone has lost a ton of shelf space the last few years when it used to be a juggernaut for a lot of stores.
Deschutes
Nah. They make all the Kirkland brand beers for Costco. That gives them a huge reliable backstop
I’m a Black Butte lover so I hope not but they were supposed to build an east coast brewery in VA and never happened. They had a tasting room in the same area and it closed about a year ago. I think Covid put a hurting on them and Costco deal is volume but lower margin biz. You also don’t see their beer in the grocery stores on the east coast like you used to. Still find them in Total Wine & bottle shops
Their move into NA beers has been solid compared to some others. The Black Butte especially. I do hole they are sticking around for a lot longer.
Shut your dirty mouth, sinner. They expanded then retracted and are owned by a single family plus an ESOP. They've moved into contract brewing for Costco (Helles lager and the beautiful vintage ale) and seemed to have adjusted to the contraction ahead of the curve by closing their East Coast ops before they became unsustainable. Unthinkable, I could not bear this one.
Good to know about the contract brewing with such a large corporation. They make rad suds
The Kirkland Helles lager is the best price point beer in America and I’ll die on that hill. $1.16 per can where I live.
With the their deal with Costco I think they will be ok for a while.
Say it ain’t so. Although I haven’t purchased anything from this in years but I’m not local at all
Ugh hope not. One of my first craft beer loves.
I doubt it. Not only do they have Costco backing now but they have some of the best NA beers out there too which is a growing market still. I have a feeling they’ll be okay for a bit.
[deleted]
As a MA resident I can assure you they’re doing just fine haha
Distributing fairly widely in CO too, can confirm their beer tastes just fine
Odell, Saranac, Brooklyn, Troegs
Troegs is absolutely murdering it currently no way they go down
Agreed. I was just there for first time and it was incredible. I’ve been to hundreds of breweries across the U.S. and this was easily top 5 for me. Based on how crowded it was I don’t think they’ll slow down anytime soon.
No way for Troegs
Agreed. Troegs seems to be doing really well these days. Graffiti Highway is great. Mad Elf is still a staple for the holidays. Their lineup is very solid.
I think they’re going to be here for a while.
I hope so. I enjoy a lot of the Troegs offerings.
Tröegs isn’t over-extending itself with a lot of physical locations, like others.
Brooklyn is leaving their old taproom for a much larger space. Could see that backfiring.
I saw a lot of Brooklyn in France last summer. They got paid $130 million to have a partnership with Carlsberg in 2021 https://www.brewbound.com/news/brooklyn-sold-brand-rights-in-europe-parts-of-asia-to-carlsberg-for-130-million-last-year/ seems like they can weather the storm.
Yeah it's one of the rare American brands one can find pretty easily in supermarkets in France
Wasn't that over a year ago?
I dont think theyve moved yet. Have walked by the taproom a few times the last year and it looks active. Could be wrong tho
Oh nice. Feet on the ground info is better than online lol
Troegs is among the better PA breweries. Definitely one of the better big ones. I doubt they would have gotten themselves into any serious debt considering the way they've grown. They've got 3 or 4 very recognizable flagship beers. Brewpub is BUSY. And they're all over Philly.
I personally love nimble giant among others
Saranac and it's parent company, FX Matt, should be diversified enough in its brands and co-packing to face the current headwinds. But who knows, really?
FX Matt also brews other beers in their brewery (contract brewing), so they are making money to support their beer even when it isn’t their beer. Saranac is an Adirondack staple, and will be around for some time.
Agreed. My parents are from that area and I'm happy to see them being a viable community business with some summer concerts, etc.
They own Flying Dog now too
That’s funny you say saranac, what made me post this was the fact I had to check if they were even still in business. Troegs is safe in my opinion as well as Brooklyn, Odell I could see going under
Troegs is doing well in the home market- they will be around for a long time. Saranac is owned by FX Matt and I don’t think they’ll kill a brand like that- they have plenty of other ways to make money. Brooklyn - maybe. They have some international stuff that is impressive. Odell seems like a good bet.
Everyone seems to really love Troegs. I think they are the most overrated big brewery I’ve been to.
The breweries customer service is quite bad. They basically offer zero customer service and it seems like no one there has been trained how to handle the busy rush times. Me and a friend drove an hour and a half out there in the snow one time just to turn around due to how bad the service we got was.
Unless there beer has drastically improved in the few years since I was there, which I doubt due to them being a large place, you really didn’t miss much
Honestly I think troegs is pretty solid outside a few of their offerings, they make decent lagers, have some really good rotating IPA options and some good dark beers, the service at the brewery is just god awful though.
Bells?
I dunno. They actually have a nice variety! Hope not.
Agreed. I could just see it. Just like rogue. We all.knew they were behind in the market, but didnt want to believe it was a bad enough thing to kill them
Two Hearted still has good distribution, plus they are under Kirin now. If anything they’ll just make New Belgium make Two Hearted for national distribution.
That would be one of the biggest surprises ever. 2 hearted is still on tap in so many spots across the country and in fridges in a lot of states. I’m part of the 2 hearted cult and we won’t let that happen lol.
I could see it but also can’t, like it wouldn’t surprise me if they went under but also would idk
When's the last bells release you saw come out and thought "oh awesome! I bet thats good. I gotta get it?"
But I haven't ever really thought that because they make such standard bearers. Two Hearted is perfect. Expo stout, Black Note. Perfect beers.
Dead guy? No one really thought that was flawed or outside of being the American standard.
Bells makes standards well. The wheat is incredible, and the APA is the only example I send people to for a regular showcase of the style with no frills.
That said, those things alone arent surviving anymore. Even New Belgium started redoing all old recipes. I think we all thing fat tire is was worse, but its selling in higher volume because its a change of pace.
Antiquated breweries lose because of their Antiquated brewers. Adaptation survives
You’re seriously comparing Two Hearted, Black Note, Oberon, Expo Stout, etc. etc. etc…. to Dead Guy Ale?
No. Just no.
Two Hearted and Oberon are pretty popular where I live and have been for decades. As ubiquitous as Rogue was in the early days I never saw it in tap anywhere past like 2005 or so. Never saw anyone buy it after that. Whereas TH and Oberon were everywhere. At some dives and grungy music venues it would be the only good beer. It's still common to see on tap.
NB had some hype when they first showed up (due to the cult status of Fat Tire) but over time dwindled. I don't see them on tap, don't really notice them in stores.
Even if Bell's did die it's still not really the same as Rogue.
Well you gotta good point 😂
Double Two Hearted
The stuff that gets distributed maybe but they are standard get from the grocery store fair and Two Hearted and Oberon are often the only “craft” beer options at restaurants/music venues/even minor league ball parks that don’t have much craft options. But I have stopped at the brewery itself multiple times traveling between Chicago and Detroit for family and they have brewery exclusive six packs where I have picked up multiple where I said “that looks interesting and delicious”
I can 100% see Bell’s. They got bought at the same time as New Belgium, and New Belgium got all the focus. bell’s has next to ZERO footprints anywhere here in Florida anymore.