My husband and I, both in our late 30s, are expecting our first in April. My mother in law is over the moon excited about having another grandbaby and has been buying things left and right! We really appreciate the sentiment and donât want to come off as ungrateful or like we only wanted specific items, but she seems to have found a love for Temu recently. I know not everything from there is bad quality but clothing she has bought is extremely cheap. They book like if you wash them one time theyâll fall apart. They are cute as can be but the fabrics are so thin you can see through them, they have itchy rough sewing seams, really cheap plastic snaps and buttons that seem like theyâre going to fall off and be a choking hazard. A couple of footie sleepers have no buttons or snaps at all, so we would have to completely take it off of her to change a diaper! A lot of the tags say âwash separately, dry cleaning recommendedâ which is crazy for baby clothes! The baby toys sheâs given us also are very cheap plastic and do not look safe for babies. How do we address this with her without sound like spoiled ungrateful people? Sheâs the type you have to walk on eggshells around to avoid upsetting her and she takes everything personally and will argue that sheâs just trying to be a good grandmother and do something nice for usâŚbut I really donât feel comfortable putting our baby in these clothes and if we just donât let her wear them, she will definitely notice! & sheâs given us tons!probably has spent a few hundred bucks on these. There are so many retailers that you can buy cheaper priced baby clothes and items, so Iâm not sure why sheâs resorting to Temu. I donât mind getting used or hand me down items, it really bugs me that shes spending money on these cheap things! đđ
Go sweep up the egg shells and be frank with her, you are unable to use the baby items purchased from temu due to quality, safety, practicality. If you donât you will receive more temu items.
This, but⌠your husband should be the one having the conversation. Itâs his mom. Let him handle this round.
Normally I would take the approach of âaccept gifts with grace, even if you just immediately donate or regift them.â But with baby products, safety is at play and I think this warrants an honest conversation.
No, donât let the husband do it. He will NOT, trust me.
Yeah it sucks for her but if you canât be honest she canât be a good grandmother.
Maybe include that in the conversation like âI know youâll be a great grandmother, which is why we/I feel comfortable with having this conversation with you. I know you only want the best for (baby)!â
So beautifully said.
I agree with this and that your husband should be the one to have the conversation. Itâs good to start setting boundaries now before the baby gets here. Itâll only be harder if you donât set boundaries now as the baby gets older and she wants to be involved.
My mother didnât buy things from Temu, but Iâve had to set (even more) boundaries with her now that I have my own child. She doesnât understand my boundaries and definitely takes offense sometimes, but thatâs her problem, not mine. Itâs your job to take care of your baby the best way you see fit. â¤ď¸
This!
My godmother is the boundary pusher and she cries like a toddler when something doesn't go her way or maybe it's how I word it.
My husband (especially right now) ends up being the bad guy because he holds boundaries since I hate confrontation and have severe anxiety about it. My 2 are toddlers and I'm having a third baby (dealing with a lot medically not related to baby) so recently I just ignore everything unless I'm being hounded then I just snap at whoever is hounding me since I've tried (nicely) and my husband has (not so nicely).
I don't like Temu quality for me so I won't give it to my infant. Shein is iffy, clothes are mostly decent but I won't risk toys or products for baby (stroller attachments though I'll use them).
This is what I told my mom. She ordered something off a Facebook store and it was poorly made. I told her that it was made from cheap fabric and wasn't the best quality. She understood and stopped ordering from those types of places. Usually grandparents just don't understand that you can't trust all the online shops to make quality stuff until they see it for themselves.
This is true.Â
No advice but this is my nightmare. My MIL is 100% going to do this because sheâs already buys pure junk for the rest of the family.
Iâm seeing now there are many articles on the dangers of Temu chemicals. Maybe you could low key bring this up in advance to get ahead of it
Second this!
I thank god my mil hasnât found Temu or weâd be in the same boat đĽ˛
Temu is known to have a lot of recalls for baby toys- they donât have their website updated for recalls past 2024, but I would show your MIL their recall page on their site. Say you appreciate everything she is doing but after seeing the recalls youâre just not comfortable receiving anymore items from temu. I know it might be an uncomfortable convo, but ultimately it comes down to the safety/ comfort of your baby!
I agree. And agree if itâs your husbandâs mom, then he should be having the conversation first.
This is a perfect time for white lies. âI was showing some friends some of the cute toys you got for super inexpensive and they told me a story of someone who tested a bunch of toys from overseas retailers and they had toxins in them. They were shocked that this stuff isnât regulated better and is predatory marketing! Then I looked up all these recalls from Temu (Iâd recommend to find another site, too, just to make it a more general conversation) [show her the pages]. Iâm telling you because there is no way youâd know this otherwise and I know you care about our baby. So now weâre really trying to stick to a, b, and c brand that are safe. weâre ok if that means getting less things.â
I was thinking the same thing đ I would say âoh, we washed some of the clothes you got and none of them seem to be holding up in the wash unfortunately. Iâm not sure Temu has the best clothes quality, just wanted to let you know so you donât spend more money there since weâll have to toss themâ hahah
I really did wash temu baby clothes and they literally fell apart
I would be even former. "So now we are getting toys only from XYZ. If we get toys from other brands, we will donate or throw out"
I donât even think itâs a white lie, pretty sure itâs true!
Nothing from TEMU should be close to children. The stuff from there is full of chemicals. https://chemtrust.org/news/toxic-chemicals-temu/
Really talk to her about that. If she doesnât stop it just refuse to accept it. And throw everything away youâve received so far.
I may start posting these articles in Facebook, surely she will see it there. đ
Do it. And be open with her. Weâre adults. Weâre Modeling our behavior for our children. How will they start to learn to communicate openly if we resort to playing games? At least thatâs how I see it.
If you can, get on their computer/phone and lookup articles and videos about temu stuff being toxic and get that into their algorithms.
OP I would just send her the article with a very thoughtful gentle note - hey, we know you are doing this with the best of intentions!! so much has changed in manufacturing since you had kids and Iâm gonna share with you some stuff that has come to light recently. I know you wouldnât put your grandkids in harms way! Here are some brands that are great (Hanna Andersen whatever) - letâs look for a few pieces from great brands instead!
My mom is a temu lover as well and I got ahead of this by saying something along the lines of appreciating gifts very much but would love for them to be from reputable sellers (name some you like) and not temu due to the different standards/regulations countries overseas have. Frame it as safety for your infant and not personal. She totally understood.
Exactly same for my mom! She still orders a ton from there for themselves, but not for ger grandchild. :)
They say the boomers are the largest demographic on Temu. Itâs so true. If youâre planning on having more than one kiddo you can explain that you have higher quality items on your registry to reuse for the next baby and that you are concerned about landfill waste.
I was sitting here reading so many people say their parents and in-laws are big Temu shoppers and I was thinking wow I didnât know so many boomers shopped Temu. Then I came across your comment. Thatâs so interesting! I wonder why??
Yeah my dad keeps asking me if I've tried it. No thanks dad, I've lived through Wish 𤣠don't get me wrong I got a few good things on Wish, but Temu is like the Wish version of Wish- which is saying a lot. đ
I don't think he shops on it but sounds like lots of boomers in his friends circles do.
This is all so funny to me. I had no idea the boomers were all about Temu lol! I thought it was more targeted towards kids and super young adults to spend their minimum wage/allowance. Whole time itâs the boomers keeping the shop lights on lol
Boomers love "deals" temu uses stolen and Ai images to advertise something as $1 so they buy it.
"Ive been wanting something like this" and its something that should be worth $100+ being advertised as $10 so they buy it and think nothing of it.
oh god. i stay at my boomer auntâs house and i walked in to her bathroom COVERED in the exact same print and i knew immediately it was Temu. cheaply made shower, bath mat, towels, toilet cover and all had the same weird AI hummingbird print. it was so bizarre
Thatâs a good question! Is it about the thrill of a good deal? Itâs not like they donât have money. We know theyâve figured out iPhones for the most part⌠maybe they are proud for being so savvy? đ¤
I had to ask google because it was bogging my mind. According to google, you are correct, itâs about thinking they are getting a good deal đđź
Boomers are drawn to Temu for its incredibly low prices, treasure-hunt-like discovery of unique items, and nostalgia for "As Seen on TV" styles, combined with an intuitive, game-like shopping experience (spin wheels, freebies) that feels like a digital casino, making it easy to spend more time (and money) finding deals
Spin wheels đđ I canât đđ
Itâs crazy! My MIL once got mad at us bc we wouldnât sign up on the website to spin a wheel so she could get credit. Then a week later her phone had a virus and she couldnât use it and had to get another!!
Ive used temu before, only bought some cute stickers and stationary for scrapbooking and you can spin a wheel for "free items" but its only after you spend so much or pick so many items. I see the draw and fully understand why boomers fall for it.
This is so crazy to me. All the boomers I know wonât even order off Amazon, let alone Temu.
Boomers love Temu because the prices reflect what they remember from when they were younger. They just seem to conveniently forget or not have the ability to realize that the low prices are due to slavery and shitty business practices.
This is my MIL and to be honest I just gave up. She gifts it to us and I immediately throw it away, I donât even bring it in my house. The crap she buys is not even stuff that I feel safe donating. Cheap plastic chemical smelling clothes, toys & baby products. I donât care about brands but if something doesnât even have ANY brand name on it, no thanks.
Weâve told her over and over to not buy us this stuff. Weâve given her links. Weâve given her lists. Weâve recommended Walmart. Clearance stores. Thrift stores. Weâve just asked for gift cards. She doesnât care. She fully cares about quantity vs quality. She is in this weird 1 sided competition with my mom, that my mom isnât even competing in. đ She just wants to have MORE presents for the kids to open. But jokes on her I guess.
This! The one sided competition with the other granny is insane. My mam does anything nice for us and it's seen as a dig at them. My mam has organized a family Santa visit for us through a local community group she's involved in. It's low key, easy to get to and fun. No fuss. MIL is annoyed that they haven't gotten 'to do Santa'. We said to go ahead and book something then. Last year they tried bringing him to a mall Santa and he got upset and didn't want to. This year there was a big fuss about booking an experience and then nothing happened.
As you have tried to tell her that Temu is not healthy due to the chemicals in the clothes and poor quality your only resort is to refuse the gift immediately and if she insists say you will bin it! I know itâs harsh but thatâs the truth and maybe then she would rather not waste her money and contribute to landfill
Same. A lot of Christmas went in the trash. She buys 100 cheap toys from Temu and it all smells INSANE. I already know when I open a little cardboard box from her it's something from Temu that my daughter will never touch.
omg I donât know how I forgot to mention this also but she & my FIL are multiple pack a day smokers in their house. Itâs gross. So on top of the gross plastic chemical smell, everything is coated in cigarette smoke smell. đ¤Ž
Have your husband text her something like-
âHey mom, we just read an article that says that Temu may include toxins that may be harmful for baby. We really appreciate the gifts so far, but weâre going to try to buy the baby non-synthetics/chemical free in the future if you can keep that in mind. Love you!â
Iâve thought about this, but surely itâll open up a whole can of worms about us being soft millennial liberals⌠đŤŁ
And unfortunately you might just have to deal with that.
I think itâs good to start getting practice standing up for your child. As a parent, you are their #1 advocate. You cant avoid awkwardness forever, itâs best to just get comfortable being uncomfortable.
Iâm very sympathetic to the issue - I just had to have this same conversation about random unbranded toys sold on Amazon. But Iâm glad I did it!
Who gives a shit lol
Your babyâs safety > anything else
Edit to add: I say this in a laissez faire way, donât even think twice about the response!
I understand as my parents and in laws are similar but I think itâs good practice for future boundaries. My parents have not followed boundaries regarding their guns in the home and my sonâs safety comes before their feelings. Iâve had to have some TOUGH conversations but my son is worth it. Getting comfortable with communication and boundaries is so important when it comes to kids. Youâve got this! Firm but kind honesty is the best policy.
Some people do not want to be reasoned with. Â There are no magic words that will make this kind of person agree with your boundaries.Â
The best thing you can do is just have your husband tell her youâre concerned about lead and toy recalls. Â If she pushes back just say âok whateverâ and throw it away if she gifts it to you. Â
You donât have to be nasty and like do it in front of her or anything but she canât make you use stuff for the baby..Â
I have to pull the âok thanksâ and then just do what I was gonna do anyway frequently with certain in-laws, it gets easier. Â Also itâs easier for me because my husband, while very kind and loving, is not a people-pleaser. Â He has no qualms saying âthanks for your input but we are doing what the doctor recommended.â when people overstep.
It gets harder when theyâre toddlers and start opening their own gifts. Then itâs not so easy to get rid of the stuff. . If itâs still being bought.
Really? My MIL is conservative but understands you donât give babies lead, cadmium or arsenic.
My MIL buys sketchy Amazon brands, that are essentially temu stuff. Chemical smells, clothes that feel like actual plastic, toys with metal screws falling off, button batteries unsecured. (Yes, Amazon prime items, from Amazon.)
My husband sent her a bunch of articles. We asked her to buy from Target, Kohlâs(she shops there), Carters, etc. Sheâs much better now, but still sends this stuff sometimes and I return it or trash it.
I never complain, but my husband sets the boundary.
My mom rolled her eyes hard when i got a baby bjorn carrier and bouncer for my baby. Listen, ive had two kids (years ago) and was given the baby bjorn stuff secondhand back then, and it was amazing.
Im a frugal person but some expensive stuff is worth the price tag.
Iâm bracing myself for this because my dad is very into Temu and so is my (very affluent) MIL. Ex. For my birthday my MIL got me an outfit off Temu lol. My plan is to try to get ahead of it and bring up casually something like âI saw an article about how many chemicals are in clothing from Temu, SHEIN, etc and I couldnât believe it!!! Since I found this out weâve decided we donât feel comfortable putting our baby in these clothesâ. This is fact about clothing from places like Temu, if you didnât already know you should research it and if you do know, you can act like you just found out and are making a new informed decision! Oh another thread I got the advice to educate them on OEKO TEX certification for fabrics which is safe for baby and available in many affordable brands like Carters
I only buy Oeko tex Textils! So good to check beforehand.
And carters has frequent sales and great clearance racks
I got a ton of Carterâs zip-up footies on clearance at Macyâs for under $2 each!
Yes! This is why I donât get the need for Temu!
My mom stayed with us when our first baby was born (and she was super helpful, I'm so lucky) and we quickly found out our fave clothes were the footies with two way zippers, and the Carter's ones were really nice quality and held up through washes. I got a bunch of donated/hand me down clothes and I was dealing with all the impractical bits but after having to actually dress and undress a baby in them I was like ' oh this is why this piece of clothing barely got worn and they're passing it to me'
Maybe you can tell her "All my friends who have had kids swear by Little Planet/Burts Bees/two-way zips/these convenient ones, they say they're the best quality and most convenient" My mom is someone who does kinda want to keep up with what other folks are into. Like she's not going to know posh influencer name brands but she might be receptive to some direction.
Maybe taking your MIL to Carter's or another in person shop, or showing her how cheap their clearance can be (honestly sometimes as cheap or cheaper than resale places like Once Upon a Child)- I was pretty surprised myself!
Best of luck, hopefully we can ease her Temu addiction
I love the redirection using âthis is what my friends who have kids loveâ, totally using that!!
My aunt in law is affluent and makes North of 270k a year and LOVES Temu. She buys a shit ton of Temu crap and I would just appreciate the money she spent on the shit instead of the shit.
Totally! I think it might partly be an age thing? They get intrigued by the ads
People have done this to me a ton bc my husband and I had our first baby at 20 and then twins at 22. We had no issues financially supporting the babies yet folks always assume we did/do and give us heaps of ran down used items or cheap crap. Truth is, thereâs no nice way to decline. We at a certain point just decided to take it all. It gets donated or tossed out. Iâve had people ask about certain items and itâs an immediate âyeah that is just in the basement right now being washed/due to toy rotation/doesnât fit them anymoreâ or âwe have another version of that item and I had a friend in need and wanted to help so I let them choose which they wantedâ and stuff that people are really excited about, I slap it on the kid for 5 minutes and take pictures so the giver feels good about it.
I definitely have a story of 'poor sweet Debbie at church' a young mom in need, that I have entirely made up, who I am giving all my unwanted things to đ
Crazy that people assume that if you did have financial issues, youâd want absolute junk products. I get that itâs better than nothing (I guess?) but it just seems wrong to me.
I know!!! One friend of mine keeps giving me SHEIN hand me downs. I just take them and then throw them out đ. We're not struggling no rich but we live in a one bedroom. She probably think she's helping us. It's annoying.
Blame it on your pediatrician! This is actually one of my favorite things our doctor m told me⌠for stuff like this blame it on me! Huge family gathering? Nope doctor said no. Baby can watch tv with you? No again. When you have your initial meeting say the doc flagged this as a potential concern that theyâve seen cause skin issues in newborns clothing
Itâs so funny because my pediatrician said the same thing and I was like⌠Maâam, you donât know my mom. She does not care what we blame on you. Lol.
I feel like people like her weaponize their âhurt feelingsâ to guilt people into doing what they want and not speaking up. She may not fully realize this but she plays victim and itâs exhausting for everyone else.
I know you donât want to hurt her feelings but I think explaining honestly what youâve explained here and being firm that you wonât be putting your babyâs health and safety at risk for her feelings is the best route. She can return a lot of things still and you need to tell her before she spends more money on this garbage.
Your baby comes first and I think if she acts like that in this circumstance sheâs going to guilt you guys about all sorts of things involving the baby. You need to set the precedent that she doesnât get to boo-hoo and control things because this is so not about her.
I have a very strict rule about clothes my baby wears. He has eczema and has to be in high quality breathable fabrics. You could also make up a story about how a friend had a child who got a bad rash and now you are concerned about those products.
Once your baby is here, âthe pediatrician saidâŚâ is my go to line lol
Even better, OP you could enlist your pediatricianâs help in this, as Iâm certain theyâve seen this kind of thing before (they see everything)!
You could send a message to the doctorâs office asking for resources on choosing safe clothing and products for your baby and have THEM send you links to trusted sites that list what to buy and what to avoid! That way you could even show her (or even have your husband show her if thatâs a better option) that it came from the doctorâs office! It might even list stuff like Temu as unsafe or questionable (some mom back me up on this or correct me as Iâm still pregnant with my first and havenât visited anything like this yet).
The only issue is if itâs your first, most pediatricians wonât see you until the baby is born. Some of them do meet and greets during pregnancy, but itâs not common where I live
https://www.nbcchicago.com/consumer/fast-fashion-infant-baby-clothes-studies-find-high-chemical-levels/3731861/
Show her this
I would def offer some data and objectivity to why youâre not going to use the items so she canât argue
My MiL is a temu demon too. She gets us so much cheap crap from temu đ
Temu demon is hilarious đđđ
I just wouldnât put it on the baby and when she ask I would tell her you tried it on and different things gave her a rash or something
Does she live near you? We put our baby in that kind of stuff, took a picture and sent it to her, and then immediately got rid of it. Also if she buys enough she'll forget about some of it so as long as you're putting in an effort to make it seem like you're using it, that's sufficient.
But yeah there's no way I would use those toys, and I'd be hesitant about the clothes too because who knows what kinds of chemicals are on them.
You can also try redirecting by sending links to better brands when they have sales -- Hanna Andersson has massive sales, Primary, and Carter's. Like "Oh did you see this! Some of this is cute!" and hopefully that starts a new fixation for her.
Itâs so sad that we then have to deal with all the crap. Like, itâs not even stuff Iâd feel comfortable donating
She lives about 10 min from us so she will definitely be around a lot.
Then donât play games and be upfront. Otherwise it wonât stop.
If it werenât for the harmful toxins in temu clothes this would have been an option, but Iâd just rather not entertain it this way. My mom used temu shit to make rice balls for christmas so my husband stopped eating them (they had tuna so I skipped them). Gave me, 11 weeks pregnant, tea in a temu glass that probably has lead in it.
I sent her an article of our main news channel about the dangers of temu and other similar shops, but she keeps doing it.
Battling this with my MIL and BIL at the moment. Not for baby stuff but with my toddler. We asked for experience presents for Christmas/Birthday instead of toys. They got him some lovely good quality toys but bulked out the presents with tat from Temu. We've washed the clothes and the quality and texture feels really off and extra plasticy. I've put them in a drawer for a few months and we'll say he grew out of them. We've tried putting the foot down about this stuff but are accused of being snobbish and that they're being treated unfairly as we haven't given my parents any push back.
The first two years I made a list on Excel of suggested books and toys and asked them to tick off the list online. This kinda worked but they still went for much cheaper alternatives that weren't right e.g. we asked for a kids fabric tunnel and received a blow up tube for a baby to practice tummy time.
Now we have a rule that they can buy what they want but it stays in their house and he can play with it there.
He really loved one toy my parents got him this Christmas and insisted on bringing it home and to his other grandparents to play with it with them. This has pissed off the in laws.
Anyway my point is, this will be an on going battle, stand firm on the boundary and say you won't put your child in those clothes, cite health and safety concerns/recalls etc.
I LOVE the idea of things staying at their house. Iâd like to put the ride on paw patrol dog, bouncy ball tent, and construction table with like 2,000 pieces of plastic anywhere but in my home!!
Oh I know there's just so much stuff. And we've no.2 on the way and I'm so stressed about the amount of STUFF that has to come down from the attic and just exist in the main living areas again.
I also have a TEMU/dollar store MIL. I used to just not let my kid play with the stuff. Now my 3yo gets super excited about the stuff. So I just let it happen. But for the babyâŚno. I am cheap but I buy thrifted and second hand quality items. Not trash.
I just said this in a reply to another comment and then saw yours It gets much harder when theyâre toddlers and know what they are opening and want it.
I have a well meaning but similar MIL. Always buys and gifts cheap junk I have to dispose of. Before baby was born I was just super obnoxious and vocal about how we will only be cotton/linen or natural fibers, no plastic toys, nothing with batteries/lights/sounds. Was/am I very annoying about this subject? Yes. But baby is one and we have received very minimal âjunkâ for her. Be warned, this method has resulted in us buying 98% of her clothes and toys ourselves as these guidelines seem to be too difficult for most to grasp. But we are ok with it as her clothes and toys are all good quality and well researched.
My MIL also did this initially. Not really from Temu but extremely low quality toys and clothes. And would even demand that we put baby in them. Well we dint and openly told her the issue with every single one of them. Then those quickly stopped and we started getting gift cards instead.
It's such a boomer problem. And in the 80s they would have been offended/grossed out if their in-laws had given them some cheap random trash from down the market, but they just do not comprehend that they are doing the same to us. But worse because capitalism means that 80s random market shit was prob still way better quality than 2025 temu/amazon lol 𼲠For the baby we honestly just bin it, but it gets trickier later on when they give things to the kids directly and the kids are old enough to notice if you make things disappear.
Itâs crazy because she would have not put her kids in these clothes in the 90s, her kids her up wearing name brand everything!
This is tricky because she clearly means well, but yeah â those super thin fabrics with rough seams and weird care instructions aren't practical for a baby you're changing 10 times a day.
Here's how I'd handle it without starting a family war:
- Redirect her, don't reject her. Thank her genuinely, then guide her toward what you actually need. Something like: "We're so grateful you're this excited! We've got heaps of newborn stuff now, thanks to you, but we're going to need 3-6 month sizes soon. We've heard Cotton On Kids and Target have great basics that hold up really well in the wash. would you want to grab some of those when the time comes?"
- Use the pediatrician excuse. If she pushes back, blame someone neutral. "Our pediatrician mentioned sticking to softer fabrics without rough seams because of sensitive newborn skin and to watch for small plastic bits. We're just trying to follow that advice."
- Keep a couple of pieces for visits. Pop baby in one of her outfits when she's around, then change them after. Small price for peace.
Babies outgrow newborn clothes in a blink anyway. You'll get through this phase. Save your energy for the bigger safety battles like car seats and sleep gear where quality really matters.
Have you tried sending her direct links to what you need? Sometimes people shop better with a roadmap than total freedom.
Temu is known for having lead in the clothing Jsyk.
I just keep stressing that we only accept name brand clothes and gifts because while I appreciate the thought, I trust fischer price/Melissa and Doug toys and Old Navy/Tea Collection clothes far more than alphabet soup amazon and temu finds.
While I agree, I wouldn't say "name brand" only. They will think she's being extra. When in reality it's about the quality.
It feels extra to say but they take it better when you stress name brand means you can trust the materials to be non toxic.
And there is a little letting go of what other people think and drawing boundaries. I know they may think I am prissy but I just want to keep my baby safe
Is there any way she might have a slight shopping addiction? In general, I'm trying to cut back on useless junk, fast fashion, etc. I plan to become more minimalist as I work on those impulsive shopping behaviors, but it hasn't been easy!
Maybe you can speak with her about your concerns on the quality, but also, other ethical dilemmas with Temu and consumerism in general. Being a thoughtful consumer buying stuff now and again isn't so bad, but just burning money on junk shows perhaps a lack of understanding of these apps, economies, and the environment that has lead all of us to, well (points at the world) this.
There's tons of documentaries and videos available online such as YouTube that could maybe help educate her on why cutting back and focusing on quality or secondhand items would be best for baby, for her wallet, and for the world.
I am also here in solidarity
"I really appreciate all the buts you've been getting, but a friend recently let me know that they have a lot of recalls due to lax manufacturing and testing rules in China direct to website. Id like to avoid temu/shein/aliexpress for anything baby relalted please, just in case."
I sent my mother articles & studies on temu items & the toxicity of them and politely told her anything purchased from Temu would be thrown away. She was supportive of it and wasn't aware of the issues with their products. I encouraged her to thrift at local second hand stores if she wanted to shop & spoil him instead.
My boyfriend and I told his mum that we didnât want anything from Shein or Temu because of harmful chemicals, safety concerns, poor quality and unethical practises. She bought some bits anyway and said sheâd washed them with baby detergent. We told her we wouldnât use them and not to buy any more. Just had to be upfront! Youâll have to assert lots of boundaries when baby comes.
You put baby in the cutest ones for a photo shoot - I like to take pictures each month on the anniversary of their birthday for example. You send her the pictures. Then you take the baby out of it and throw it away or in clothes recycling. She wonât realize baby isnât wearing it all the time.
My husband and I have a few items like this and we decided to just do what weâre calling a media day so the people who gave the items to us can feel appreciated lol Pick a couple of the best things to take pictures of the baby in and then take right off. Send the pictures periodically as if the baby is wearing them spaced out đ
Media day đ¤Ł
Honestly, I just say thank you and regift or donate. Maybe take a picture in the outfit once, remove and give them away on Facebook!
Does she have a daughter that could be blunt with her? My sister-in-laws are so helpful with this kind of stuff because daughters can tend to say the honest, blunt, borderline cruel thing to their moms to get the message across. And not on your behalf, just a casual, âMom, why in the heck are you buying that cheap, crappy clothing for the new baby? I wouldnât put my kids in that shit and I bet they donât want to either, but are being too polite.â
These type of gifted clothes are the ones I send to daycare as extras and I âforgetâ to put babes name on it - in hopes it gets lost.
đ¤Ł
My MIL is a a slight hoarder so same issue, especially temu. So husband just tells her exactly what we want and if we do get some cheap stuff then we make the decision if we keep it or not. Once itâs in your house itâs your choice. But would say tell your husband to talk to her if you think it will get out of hand with the amount of stuff. Also best thing is put the outfit on baby once take a picture, send it and thats it. I get your concern especially having those cheap products on them with all the microplastics and crap fabric, babyâs skin is so delicate. Also encourage her to try a secondhand store if youâre open to that. We tell all our family our favourite brands and his size so they can keep an eye out. I mean we also buy secondhand mostly cause we would rather spend money on experiences and they grow so fast anyways. Once upon a child is awesome at least ours is great I hear some are hit and miss for price vs new. Also our local thrift store is so affordable. Like $1-2 for a carters brand sleeper in good condition but not as guaranteed to find what you want.
My mom also likes to buy from 'uncle temu' and I told her from the start that most products used to make the items sold there aren't regulated and haven't had the safety checks most other products entering the EU (that's where I'm located) have had.
She is the understanding type though and will always respect us in that sense so I didn't find it difficult to bring up. I just made sure to do it before she went crazy with it. I did tell her I don't mind thrifted or second hand baby clothes from brands that are well known where in located (local stores in the country) as long as they're not completely worn out and are still clean. Also added that I wouldn't want any stuffed animals from the second hand store because of hygiene. So she still has the option to buy cheaper things, it's more sustainable that way if she can't hold back and she already loves thrifting so it's a win win. This will be her first grandchild đ¤Ł
Is she going to be over a lot? Because they could all just go right to goodwill
Aka, the bin.
Mother in law means she's not your mother and you have a husband that has to deal with his own mother's bs. Products from Temu are unregulated and of incredibly bad quality. I would never dress a kid in their fabrics it or allow it to play with their toys.
Your husband must tell her to stop buying stuff from temu end of story. This is not your battle.
My mum has started to buy us items, all from Temu đđ My husband wants to get a lead testing kit to hopefully find some and stop her from buying more
lol my MIL does the same thing and always has! She gets things from the dollar tree. Most of the things we genuinely canât find useful because they break or they leak or donât absorb whatever the item is. So⌠we donate. She never asks. But I donât want to call her out. She doesnât have much money. I try to find some use of things. Like some baby items become accessories for my toddlerâs baby dolls etc. until they break.
Aw I feel like it changes things if the person doesn't have much money.
Aw I feel like it changes things if the person doesn't have much money.
MIL does this. I put a stop to the Temu junk. If any of it still comes into the house it goes in the garbage.
my mother is the exact same as d constantly buys temu junk for my daughter and baby and honestly i just keep throwing them in the bin. she doesnât listen to me when i tell her i donât want that shit so iâve just given up. hopefully youâll have better luck đŤśđť
Unless thereâs a chance a conversation will change her behavior just throw the gifts away. Donât feel even an iota of guilt. Sheâs giving you a chore.
My mother in law isnât as bad but she buys a lot of clearance items that arenât our taste or we donât need or poor quality items. My husband and I have tried talking to her but it doesnât change anything so Iâve given up. Anything nice enough I donate, anything cheapo I throw away.
Wasn't there recently an issue with toxic chemicals found in children's clothes from temu? This would be my main concern. Perhaps make a wishlist and have mil only buy from there.
Our baby (now 10MO) has sensitive skin. We have to only buy 100% cotton for her. You can try to use this as the reason you need higher quality stuff and will donate anything else
This is my exact nightmare. My MIL went wild when she heard we were pregnant, and bought (almost) the whole shebang.
Worst one she got were some baby bottles, which did not survive the stream sanitizer. (The bottom of the bottles developed some warping).
I thought, this can't be normal. I told my husband, and he said "But it's made of silicone, you said that's what you wanted"
"The nipples were silicone, but the bottle itself is made of plastic. I also don't remember telling your mom I wanted her to buy bottles." I told her, incase she wanted to buy bottles, that the nipples should be made of silicone. I did not think she would buy them from.. God knows where.
Husband insisted the bottles were made of silicone. Then his mother insisted as well. But silicone does not behave like this?? I had to find the freaking PET icon for plastic and take a picture of the warped icon on the bottom of the bottle for comparison.
When I told her about the warping, she said, "oh, maybe the bottle isn't meant to be steam sterilized". How else then am I supposed to clean them? Isn't having the option to sterilize the bottle supposed to be default?
I told my husband "I don't want to keep these bottles, i don't feel comfortable". We argue before we decide in the end to throw them away. He sighs and mutters under his breath, "It's a shame, these were good bottles" before chucking them in the trash. He does not get it.
When I bring up the dangers of cancer from plastics and chemicals, we have a whole argument as to why I'm overreacting. He somehow thinks it's more important not to offend his mom, than it is to protect our child. He doesn't believe me! Like. Hello. My mom had cancer. I know people who got cancer by drinking from warped plastic water bottles left in a hot car.
I can tell which of bub's clothes are from Temu. They are made of polyester, and they catch fiber from the washing machine like crazy.
Anyways, sorry I went on a tangent. I think Temu victims need a support group or something. I need to tell my MIL to stop buying clothes from temu, but it's so hard when we don't even speak the same language.
Thatâs crazy! Iâd be afraid to even put those in a bottle warmer
lol show her how itâs shit. Laugh about the missing buttons and broken books, then say âdonât waste your money. Open the LO a 529 instead!!â Grandparents love investing in babyâs future
My mother does this, I just put it on quickly take a photo and take it off lol I hate temu đ
20 things for $100 is still $100. Tell her directly. Thereâs no point in keeping junk or having her waste money on things you wonât use.
Itâs pretty common knowledge at this point that temu toys and clothes are not safe. Just tell her that every time they have testet Temu products most of them have come back as harmful.
This was me over Christmas!! We have a registry but my MIL just buys whatever Amazon stuff she sees from random Chinese brands. Of course with no gift receipts. Iâm sorry but I totally understand what youâre going through and have yet to find a solution. We are also in our late 30s and can afford higher quality items.
I had to have the Temu talk with my MIL. I educated her how many items are heavily laced with lead and I will not have anyone in my household with that crap. She understood
Anyone who buys me temu items gets thrown out or given away , I donât mess with lead contamination or child labor. Temu, wish, SHEIN, all of it. Itâs not worth risking your babyâs health. The clothes, the toys, especially anything you put in your mouth, etc are all contaminated.Â
Temu products also have way higher than acceptable levels of lead (even after washing them) so donât let them near your baby
Temu baby items have been found to contain lead. Also remind her that these items are so cheap because of slavery. Temu is a fucking cancer.
Youâre about to be parents, itâs time to stop catering the feelings of others when it comes to your childâs safety. I do think this is a conversation for your husband to have with his mother; a very blunt conversation that you both appreciate the thought and effort but you want her to save her money as you will not be using cheap items with the baby.
Omg this is so real. I also want good quality because we plan to have more babies so it will be reused!! I told my husband to tell her we will be picking out the clothing we are just being selective for future kids so we want good quality. Blah itâs an awkward convo. We deal with it for Christmas and birthdays but we decided we need to put our foot down for our baby. Itâs just a waste of money end of day we wonât use it
I had this with my own Mum too. At first I didnât know she was buying them so when I received them I just politely said theyâre not good quality and she is essentially wasting money. I said rather than her buying 10 poor quality things for ÂŁ1 I would prefer x1 for ÂŁ10 - quality over quantity and she was absolutely fine with this and understood once I had the conversation â¤ď¸
Seems to be an unpopular opinion but anybody in my life who requires me walking on eggshells because they take everything personally doesn't get the luxury of tact or diplomacy from me. I'm the type to say thanks and immediately put it in the trash can in front of them. There is no "magic words" with these types of people. They value their own joy in shopping more than the recipient's feelings. I don't exist to receive your temu shopping sprees so that you can feel good at my expense. I don't worry about their feelings because I find their actions offensive.
My FIL is the opposite. Buying items worth hundred from Dolce and Gabbana, Fendi etc. They all go straight into a separate drawer, ready to be resold. They're awful looking. Personally, I'd be binning the clothes.
Thatâs insane! Why put a baby in something so expensive for them to spit up or poop on?!
Beats me, it's just ridiculous.
$550 on a dress she wore ONCE (and only for photos). đĽ´
My MIL does this and while it bothered me at first, now I just thank her for the gifts and move on. Some are cute enough for our gal to wear and others I give away. Itâs just not a battle I want to have.
My mother in law consistently buys my daughter things from the goodwill and i know she means well but the majority have stains and are dark colored because of so much use. She also keeps buying sizes two times smaller. I have been handing garbage bag fulls to my mother and only keep a shirt so she knows âIâm using themâ. My mom has been donating them to this lady who has smaller kids than my daughter we tell her we have enough but she just loves spending money. She keeps buying wooden toys that has missing parts as well. I live in a small apartment too and im pregnant. Idk what to do right now on space. Im already stressed how many baby stuff she is going to start buying. Just accept and throw it out, itâs cheap anyways. Maybe give it to someone else who will use them? I hate saying no to my mil because she gets irritated but I do too đtoo much stuff i dont need
Nod and smile and then bin or donate the items you donât want. Or do what Iâd do which is tell her youâd rather she buy nothing than buy cheap and dangerous shit. Would probably sound better coming from her own son than DIL though.
My mum said she would get some stuff off temu and I shut that down real quick and said please donât cause I will throw it out. She asked why and I told her that they are cheaply made and you donât know what chemicals are used all over the fabrics. So she hasnât gotten anything from them thankfully but she does work at TK Max so she comes home with new outfits every shift đ
I had the same issue with clothes gifted to me by my in-laws. The sizing was majorly off, they were scratchy and had rough seams, mostly buttons instead of zippers and just felt poorly constructed. Thatâs not to say things made in China are always this quality but SHEIN/Temu are notorious for catfishing their product quality, so Iâm sure they looked very cute and high quality in photos but sadly didnât reflect so in person. They also ordered the most random sizes like 9-12 months, 18 months, seasonal clothes like heavy nylon coats which are meant to be worn in winter but if it doesnât align with their age itâs a waste. I think out of the 6 outfits they gave she maybe wore 2 once or twice and then they just fell apart or were too small to rewear more. The rest got lost in the mix because they were so much bigger and then just were never worn. Iâm 1000% certain they could have bought clothes for a similar price point that would have been night and day difference in quality if they just went to a local Walmart or Winners/Marshall.
I have a similar MIL and I told her that we made the decision to put our baby only in 100% cotton clothes. That makes it so itâs not about the brands and she can buy from wherever she wants as long as itâs cotton. She has forgotten a time or two and I have my husband remind her at that point âhey remember weâre only doing 100% cotton. We donât want you wasting money on something we wonât use.â It has worked really well and doesnât hurt feelings, but she definitely isnât buying as much as she would have without that barrier and thatâs okay for us.
My MIL is like this so much so she was buying maternity items for me as well. I struggle with textures and how things feel on my skin especially during pregnancy. At one point, I had my SIL bring up weird pregnancy symptoms and she asked about any of mine and I shared that. I stopped getting clothes after that but the baby clothes kept coming.
Honestly we just grin and bear it, itâs not worth the fight for me and we wash it as soon as we get it. Half the time it does fall apart before we even put it on our child and then we tell her honestly that it didnât hold up in the wash. The other half that does hold up gets put in the bottom of the closet until baby is âtoo bigâ. Itâs gotten better and sheâs been purchasing less from those sites lately
Tell her you appreciate the thought and sentiment, but for safety reasons, you won't be able to use those items for your baby. The safety and security of your baby comes before a grown adults feelings. I definitely wouldn't be putting my baby in temu clothing, it's all probably made of pure plasticđŹ
My MIL is a functional hoarder and gifted my kids bubble bath and soap she bought for my husband and âforgotâ to give to him. It was from the 90âs!!!! I just threw it away when she left. No way thatâs going near my babyâs skin. In general, if thereâs something unsafe someone gives my kids I just thank them and toss it. If Iâm asked about it I say we do a toy rotation and some toys are stored away. Iâm also a people pleaser(working on it) and a conflict avoider. In a perfect world I would just say something about the quality/safety.
Honestly⌠If you donât want to cause any bad blood because you are going to have to deal with her for the rest of your life (which is the case for many people in this situation lol) I would probably physically take her to baby stores with you and point out the cheapest clothing options available and praise how much baby likes them. And then make an effort to have the baby wearing them in front of her.
She may be relying on Temu because she cannot afford other things, and the stuff on Temu is very cute even if she cannot tell the quality is bad.
I am in the exact same boat; late 30s, husband and I expecting first in March, and it will be the first grandbaby for my in-laws. MIL is so excited and has spent thousands on stuff that is truly unusable, poor quality, and is cluttering our house. She is also very sensitive to perceived ingratitude, and I don't want to hurt her feelings.
We are just unboxing stuff carefully so that we can hopefully re-box it and donate it after a couple photos with the baby using it, and keeping tags on clothes so we can sell to consignment or donate. It's a tightrope between not wanting to have the baby use cheap or unsafe stuff, and preserving her feelings.
This is actually one of our concerns right now. Weâre pretty particular about what we eat and use ourselves, and that only feels more important with a baby on the way. I also wouldnât say either set of parents is especially careful about the quality of the products they use, which adds to the concern. We genuinely would prefer no gift at all over something low quality or potentially unsafe for our baby.
Early on we told all the parents that we totally understand how excited they are, but please donât buy anything for the baby unless we ask. If they really want to get something, we said we can send a short list to choose from. Our excuse was limited space and not wanting them to waste their money.
Itâs a tiny white lie, but weâre hoping it saves everyone from awkward situations and resentment later on.
Temu baby clothes and toys have been found to contain lead. There are various official warnings and articles. My step mother kept dumping boxes of cheap sh*t on us that we did not ask for and I finally just sent a text with an article link, stating the items were not safe for baby and I was disappointed to have to trash them since I couldnât live with myself if I donated them to another unknowing family.
You may also have good luck including âapprovedâ brands and stores. I told step mom what toy brands and clothing brands were okay. She continued to shop (albeit less because she was paying regular prices for things that are regulated and just cost more since the quality is better). Used what we wanted, donated what we didnât.
I wish I had sent her the baby registry later than everyone else because she did a huge buy out and didnât leave much for anyone else to buy. So maybe keep that in mind when you get your registry in order and published đ
Tell her you appreciate the thought but you are freaked out about baby safety so you only want to dress your baby in OKEO-TEX Standard 100 clothing to make sure it is safe.
My MIL did this too. But instead of $100+ worth of stuff she bought us 2 onesies and 2 plastic bowls from dollarama or dollar tree. We nipped it in the bud REAL quick. My husband called and told her we don't feel comfortable with stuff from those stores. She then rebutted that it's the last time she'll be buying anything for the babies (lol promise?). Then my FIL claimed we only like name brand stuff (not true, just stuff without lead in them lol). After he got off the phone, I found an article that says baby stuff is toxic from dollarama and he sent it over. After seeing that she was much less defensive.
I completely get this. My MIL is the same way. We have had the conversation with her about safety and quality versus saving money, but my MIL didnât listen and still buys most of her gifts from temu. At this point we say thank you, grumble all the way home, and throw it away or donate it to goodwill. It sucks! But I canât compromise safety for my MILâs sake.
Download the Capital One shopping extension on her device and show her the Carterâs website. They often have deals that make the clothing almost free. Maybe she will get into finding deals on good things. Also, Target has decent items and they are frequently on sale.
I did buy a few pj onesies from Temu, only bought if it was 100% cotton and used them very frequently. They were quite good. But I understand she may not be looking at that. Youâll just have to speak to her about it. I donât mind âcheapâ clothes for my child because all they do is spit up on it and eventually just make it filthy. I love me a good Walmart find. But it has to be 100% cotton. My son runs really hot so polyester is a no.
Not sure where you are based but I would look with a healthy dose of skepticism at stuff from temu or cheap US based manufacturing.
Be safe and buy from EU based manufacturers
lol my Dad went through this EXACT same phase. Basically if most of theses are new born clothes you can just do several at home photoshoots or choose a few days when baby will be with the grandparent to put them in the outfits, then pack them up for donations. Just be frank and say â Mom we have lots of stuff for baby letâs wait until he or she gets here before buying anymore because Iâll need your help purchasing (insert a larger ticket item).â I had my Dad go half for an expensive stroller /car seat combo and that ended the TEMU buying spree.
Just blame your baby doctor. Say Temu is unfortunately been listed as unsafe but you appreciate her effort. Point her to other stores if she wants to help out in the future
iâd tell her goodwill / thrifting is 100x better for baby clothes! they have so much organic cotton and 100% cotton options, all for $1.99. no shame in telling her you donât want those
Whatever you do, DO NOT use that stuff for your baby.
In my country (The Netherlands) they tested lots of toys and baby stuff from Temu and almost everything contained dangerous chemicals (cancer causing chemicals, hormone disruptors, just horrible stuff) And most of the stuff was generally unsafe with loose small pieces etc. It's criminal that they sell this stuff to people. And the way those apps work is just causing a gambling/buying addiction in many.
Iâm convinced that some of the clothes are made for baby dolls and not human babies.
Some people have pointed out Temuâs recalls and this is what my husband and I told his grandma! Bless her heart but she has a temu addiction lol we told her we were not comfortable with Temu items because they can bypass a ton of health standards which allows a load of toxic chemicals and metals to be engrained IN the toys and fiber of clothes and that we did not want to risk the health of our baby with those clothes. She seemed sad but was receptive and understanding that our childâs health was our main concern and she cared more about that than showering her in possibly dangerous clothes and toys. Focus on the health concerns! It can help her realize thatâs the priority she should care about too :) best of luck
This is a cautionary tale, I hope Iâm not projecting but I thought Iâd share my experience with how determental Temu/overconsumption/unchecked mental health has been to my family.
I have the same issue but with my own mother. Even before I was pregnant my mom was obsessed and kept buying me clothes and just pure junk from Temu. She has probably spent tens of thousands of dollars that she doesnât have since temu opened.
My moms issues lean more on the mental health side (she on long term disability for severe arthritis and other issues, bored and clinically depressed, on a lot medication, probably has ocd, has a very defensive and combative personality). Iâve been trying my best over the years to get her to realize how unhealthy her spending has been, how poorly made these items are and how toxic they are. But she refuses to believe it and uses it to look generous and thoughtful, aligns it with being a good person. Takes it as a personal attack if you say how shitty Temu is. I personally believe temu marketing is criminal and how they keep consumers on the app needs to be studied.
Because my mom is so combative, and nothing has worked in the past, my strategy now is to use tough love. Anytime she buys something I refuse it, throw it out, say how bad and ugly it is and how much they stink like chemicals. I ask her how much money she spent and what a waste it is. And itâs not like 1 item, temu gives her free suitcases all the time and she buys clothes and junk to fill them and gives them to me! Iâve probably thrown out 10 suitcases full of clothes so far. The last thing I did before really giving up was making excel sheet showing her how much money she spends. I thought maybe she just needs help understanding the financial impact it was having. Half her income was going to Temu and then being donated or put into the landfill. What a shame it was. But she kept doing it.
In a way i was trying to embarrass her, sheâs a very prideful person and refuses to admit anything is wrong, so embarrassment seems to be the only thing that got to her. I feel really really mean and extreme at time (Iâve gone months without talking to her) because I know deep down she means well and sheâs just suffering mentally but I couldnât accept how wasteful she was being, spending all of her money and then asking me or other family members for money to pay bills. It was consuming her. It got to a point where she couldnât store the clothes in her house anymore and she owed people too much money.
And me being her only daughter (I have a brother and a dad but they gave up years ago), I was newly married, trying for a baby and I was giving up on her. She lend on me so much before and now I had an âexcuseâ to not support her anymore. The last thing she did was ask me to send her money without my husband knowing and for me it was the final straw. She was also in a one sided competition (like another commenter mentioned) with my MIL who is really a very chill and thoughtful person clueless to the issues my mom has. My mom was making up drama and tension where there wasnât any. Now that Iâm refusing Temu baby clothes and toys she gives me, sheâs becoming more nasty towards me, saying I have a big head blah blah blah because I said I only want non-toxic organic clothing and toys and I just donât care anymore. Luckily my dad has stepped in after I made it clear that all of these issues were going to affect their relationship with their only grandchild if something isnât done.
Since getting married but especially after getting pregnant I really donât care anymore to protect my momâs feelings. Harsh and I wish I had a better relationship with my mom but this is where Iâm at. This is just a small glimpse into the many other issues that probably explain our dynamic better. But I really feel Temu played a big role in surfacing a lot of mental health issues in my mom.
Sorry this probably didnât give you a solution to your particular situation. I probably would have handled things differently if the issue was with my MIL and not my own mother. I hope youâre able to speak to your partner and they are able to support you and take the lead in dealing with their own mother in a way that doesnât affect your relationship with your MIL or make you out to be the bad guy.
Best of luck.
She has a lot of similar issues which is what makes it so difficult to discuss it with her.
Iâm dealing with this from my own mother. Your husband has to talk to her. It is his mother. If he canât do it thatâs when you step in. But it is most effective from him. I am constantly on top of my mother and making it clear that we arenât accepting junk. It helps that I have access to her Amazon account and I simply return things thatâs she sends to us on my own. If I didnât talk to my mom and deal with it myself we would be drowning in useless things.
We get a lot of stuff from my mil and 40% or more doesn't work and has to be thrown out. Occasional treasures. I get the temptation to not say anything, we've done it occasionally, but if I know off the bat we won't use it we're usually pretty firm about saying no this will not get used. Sometimes she can return or regift, and it really seems so silly for them to spend hundreds of dollars on the worst possible quality stuff when that could have gone towards things that last and get used, even handed down.
It's a very sensitive topic, if her kid can be quite firm then you'll have to address it less often.
As others have said, I had a very sincere but direct conversation and it changed absolutely nothing. We both agreed that temu/Amazon brands are; full of unregulated or unknown chemicals, cheap/breakable=unsafe, likely full of lead. The WHOLE THING.
Following week she brought over random amalgam of letters Amazon brand toys. I tried asking where it came from a few times and she snapped at me. So now it all gets tossed or put in a donation pile.
She buys so much, I don't think she even notices. The hard part is, if she actually spent the money on one good thing, it would be so helpful to us because we don't have a lot of support. I have to let that one go. It's no use. She's going to whatever she wants anyway. So I just plan accordingly. đ¤ˇââď¸
Literally same girl
Do we have the same sensitive self centered MIL? Lol. My mother in law is also like this. Except she only purchases cheap things ONLU for our baby because she doesnât like to spend lots of money on anyone but herself. Mind you she makes plenty of money not to skimp but sheâs never been generous so she does it because of other reasons besides âcute and cheap.â Iâve washed some stuff that has bled through and dyed other cuter baby items I have - that really annoyed me. Iâve since then told her no more clothes and that he has plenty already, and if sheâs wanting to buy anything we would love some toys. This helps her not get her feelings hurt either because she also would respond just how your MIL does in situations like this.
Iâve also donated some of what she gifted. Which sounds harsh but Iâm not drying my baby off with a microfiber towel.
I was ready to roll my eyes but WHATâ temu is crazy and even dangerous for baby items! Tell her the truth. đ
I agree with being frank and letting your husband handle it, but he can also send her articles on Temu. I typed "Temu Controversy" into Google and a bunch of articles appeared. It puts it in a way that she just didn't know how bad this company was and that's OK, but now she knows and is aware you won't be using anything from that company.
Unfortunately it is best to set boundaries early on. My mom was similar with trying to send me things we just didnât need or want and was stressing me out. Ultimately for my own sanity I stopped talking to her. My husband kept her in the loop for a while.
Boundaries are hard but it is something you will need to learn as a new parent. Better to start now and have less stress later.
My MIL does this too. She buys cheap and she buys bulk. Itâs especially annoying bc sheâs poor and should just keep her money for herself. She just gets so much joy out of shopping for the baby itâs very hard to stop her. For us itâs not even about the stuff being poor quality, itâs that itâs totally wasteful. My MIL is a tough cookie so we ended up having to donate essentially everything she gave us to charity to get her to stop/prove we were serious about not accepting an accumulation of useless junk.Â
Ask your husband to talk to his mom and let her know that you so appreciate her generosity but that these are not things you guys want/need for the baby. See how she takes it.Â
I think itâs a boomer/gen x thing with temu. Predatory algorithmic marketing is coming at them all the time. This is another similar convo to have w her. Sheâs in a vulnerable consumer group that will spend and spend on cheap items for grandkids and until she stops theyâll keep throwing ads at her.Â
Try mentioning to her that youâre really trying to stick to natural materials like cotton for clothes and wood for toys. Also say smth like you donât have a lot of storage space and are trying to be mindful of not overcluttering the space and not creating additional waste for the planet.
My MIL will at times give us items we have literally no use for. I'm not ungrateful for it, it is nice of her, but..... honestly its stuff she would throw away if no one else took it.
I have tried countless times gently saying oh we don't need this, etc. We won't use it, it may get thrown away.
I have resorted to literally throwing stuff away or giving it away to someone that actually needs it đ¤ˇââď¸ if she ever asks I remind her oh yeah we did not need it or weren't planning on using it. She gives us less random stuff and asks more now lol.
It still happens, but now I have no guilt over throwing stuff away anymore bc I tell her up front. Its definitely annoying, but it is what it is. I think she genuinely feels like she is helping. So if she chooses to give me stuff after I have literally said I don't need it, it will just end up in the trash.
If you bring it up your MIL may listen to you. These are my 2 cents in case she does not. đ¤Ł
Set the boundaries now or youâll regret it at 4 yr old birthday party.
Therapy had to be done before I even allowed them back in our lives. Trust me, do it before theyâre born.
My MIL did this too luckily with the items that werenât clothing I just told my husband we had too many stuff and werenât probably going to be used and he talked to her about it and gave her the stuff back to return it. The clothing however Iâm hoping to just get a picture of my baby in it and thatâs it or hopefully by the time she can fit in it my MIL forgets lol but I think Iâm just going to have to tell her not to buy the baby anymore clothes we have too much
Yeah I would break this habit now. Tell her how it is and that youâll donate anything you wonât use. I did this and had no problem following through bc everyone was warned lol
Oh goodness Iâm sorry
Is she around constantly? If not, Iâd be donating useable stuff or donating unsafe items so fast.
Just give it all away on buy nothing groups. If sheâs sensitive, but sheâll be helpful with baby then keep her happy imo. You donât want to burn the bridges that provide baby sitting in the future.
We emphasized to friends and family that being conscious consumers is important to us. That meant we wanted to avoid excessive stuff and encouraged buying secondhand and open box like from Goodbuy Gear (and maybe also overstating how little closet space our house has). Our motivation was getting out ahead of excessive clutter, but I could see it working as a diplomatic way of saying no more excessive cheap stuff.
Ugh Temu is yucky. Iâm so sorry you are dealing with this. Itâs really tough when you have someone who is overly sensitive and you have to stress about how they will act when you talk to them. Frankly I think itâs a type of narcissism.
I would just tell her how much you appreciate it but that you are concerned she is wasting her money as many of the items are unusable. Maybe show her? Have her check out Carters. They have great prices, super cute things, and the baby clothing is eco friendly. Maybe tell her that you would love anything she picks out from there, anything she thinks would be cute. Or you could give her a task. Tell her you need XYZ and give her some parameters (sizes, which stores, zipper or snap, etc.) and let her have some fun picking stuff out. She may actually appreciate some guidance.
I have a sweet friend who has offered to give me her hand me downs. I love hand me downs! The problem is she washes all her clothing is the worldâs strongest smelling laundry detergent⌠itâs terrible. Sometimes I have a hard time hugging her as it just makes me sick and burns my eyes. There is no way I will be able to wash that fragrance out of the clothes. I have tried talking to her about reducing fragrances in her home as she has some health issues, but I donât think she took to it. I donât want to offend her but I literally canât have her stuff in my home. Itâs hard when people mean well but it just doesnât work for you.
Awww how sweet. I'm sure she means well. Reminds me of my husbands father. I had to make him aware I would never allow my son to wear anything but cotton. Maybe approach it from a health and safety perspective and make her aware of how toxic cheap fabrics could be for your babies health.
Have the conversation now. It won't stop if you don't put a end to it. My MIL buys us soo many dump cheap toys. Even after having the conversation. I literally have told her "everytime you want to buy something, just put $1 in a savings account" for holidays we specifically ask for investment into her savings or an experience.
Find an article on the harmful stuff they put in their items, or even blame your pediatrician. When it comes to toys, anything that isnât BPA-free is an immediate no and something she can look for. Maybe give her example of stores youâd like to get things from
I too have this problem with my in-laws. Iâve told them numerous times to stop and get ignored. I donate anything that isnât a hazard and toss the rest
A lot of cheap products like that have leads and other chemicals in them I would use that as a example, basically just explain youre grateful but you dont feel comfortable using products you dont know are 100% safe for baby. If she trys to make it about trying to be a good grandmother well she should cate about babies well being. Its pointless to waste money on things youre never going to use and she should want the money going to something worth it.
Get used to having conversations like this with people about your children. Once she is born, your brain will switch and it will become easier. It's your job to advocate and protect your children, and to uphold your boundaries. Be firm mama :)
Sorry, but you have to nip this in the bud or it will continue and possibly escalate. And your husband should definitely be the one to have the conversation with her.
I have a hoarder MIL and we had to have a similar conversation, it did not go well. But we told her there are items we actually need and she needs to ask what we need before buying/ bringing random stuff.
For normal people, this should be acceptable. For all my family this is an acceptable boundary that i didn't even have to set. For my MIL, she is a hoarder and possibly has other mental health issues. So it was really hard, she pitched a huge fit and acted like we'd severed a limb. Sometimes she still storms out when we tell her no about something. And she still never asks what we need, but she has stopped bringing random (large, old, dirty bug infested) stuff over every time she visits.
The real consequence for her not asking what we need, whether she realizes it or not, is that she will never have the joy of seeing her grandson play with something she bought. For instance, at Christmas this year one of the things she brought was a tiny, very old, rocking horse... that was dirty and had bugs on it. It immediately went outside. She also got a ride on cheap plastic train, cute in theory, but my son is too advanced for such a thing and we got him a bike. Had she asked us or paid attention to what we'd said he'd like, it might be a different story.
Point is, if she's a stable individual, she will understand. She might be disappointed, but she'll understand. If she's not stable, it will be harder, but it's even more important to hold that boundary.
Best of luck! Remember, you get to decide what your child needs, no one else. You are in charge of protecting your child and their environment, don't let anyone take that from you or make you think otherwise.
My MIL did the same for our first, but I will say she got nicer quality items for the most part. For the parts that werenât as nice; our baby would just wear when she was around; or weâd put baby in like 2-3 different outfits and send a picture saying thank you & didnât mention that theyâre in the back of the closet when we were desperate cause baby clothes are still in the dryer.
My wise sister told me itâs ok to dump gifts that you donât want because I was giving out about a really weird toy someone bought my child⌠I hadnât actually thought about it a simply before then!
lol this is my life. I wonât put my baby in cheap feeling materials or polyester. I have said so many times I want cotton materials for him and she continues to buy temu like stuff or random second hand. So many cheap looking toys lol. My husband should say something but wonât so I just eventually donate itđ¤ˇââď¸
I would just smile and say thank you, but wouldn't use it. Maybe I'd throw it one when she's visiting just to make her happy but other than that, I probably wouldn't make my kid wear it. But that's just me lol