I just saw a post on r/veganfoodporn that I cannot cross post because this community does not allow images. Ok fine.
I identify as plant based, I’m not strict in what I eat (I rarely eat honey and whey protein and cross contamination doesn’t bother me too much) but I frequent the vegan subs for food inspo often.
Throughout my entire education of veganism, my personal decisions on what I eat and what I was raised on eating (father is an ital Rastafarian and has had a strict diet my entire life) I will never understand why a vegan would want animal imitation meals.
Why do you want to eat seitan that looks like real cooked steak? Why do you want it to look red and bloody if you do not support the consumption of meat? Why call it steak? Why be proud and celebratory of eating something that mimics what you are ethically against?
Mind you, this is a very extreme example, but in my mind it’s like someone telling me theyre ethically against pedophilia but enjoy watching Lolita porn. Does that make sense?
Back to food, I just don’t understand and none of these posts really answer it in a direct way.
Sure you want to feel included in social meals, I get wanting to slowly transition into a different diet, I understand the creativity. BUT if you are morally and ethically opposing the consumption of animals and animal byproduct, how can you enjoy eating food that artistically replicates the said thing you ethically disagree with?
This is not an attack, it’s a quest for clarity because that post I saw and the comments below it genuinely shocked the shit out of me. So much praise for food that looks dead flesh.
ngl i'm tired of seeing this question over an over
You’re a vegan on an askvegans sub, surely Youre going to continue seeing repeated questions, no? People will always ask similar questions.
But it’s not a sincere question. It’s a dig.Heavily implying vegan longing for meat and at least for me it’s completely untrue and food looks like food, not animals (usually) A patty is not a meat shape,a loaf is not a cow, and a nugget is not a chicken. Only meat eaters associate every nugget with a dead bird.
Right, my question isn’t sincere. Thanks for your input!
the issue is not the food, it is how it is procured. replicated animal products does not replicate the exploitation, abuse, nor death of animals.
you did not make a fair comparison in your post. the issue with pedophilia is child abuse, the issue with lolita porn is replication of said abuse. what you are implying of veganism is that it would be like saying someone can’t get themselves off from regular porn because the result (finishing) is the same as when they get themselves off from child abuse. see how this sounds dumb now?
We’re thinking the same way. It’s like comparing consensual bdsm to non consensual SA. Both might look similar but the former isn’t hurting anyone… more than they want to be.
So food replicating a tortured dead animal doesn’t bother you simply because it’s not an actual animal? Still weird to me but thank you for responding.
Have you ever played grand theft auto? Or any other violent video game. Have you watched a movie that replicates killing? It's weird to me your lack of ability to understand.
No, I don’t play theft or shooting or killing games. I don’t agree with that so I’m not entertained by it in a game sense.
Serial killer/murder/crime documentaries? 100% interested because I’m learning about human behaviour and the downsides of it, I will never play a game like that though.
Dont be obtuse. You have never watched a fiction movie where someone was killed?
I’m not being obtuse, I very clearly stated I’m entertained by real life depictions of death to learn about human behaviour - much like this question, I am not entertained by fictional or game like forms.
did you like.. not comprehend my comment? or do you just want to put others down over nothing?
How did I put you down? If I read correctly, you stated my question asking was dumb. Which is uncalled for since I never disrespected you. But because I responded with the same energy you responded with, I’m now putting you down? Sure, bud.
perhaps the word should have been “silly,” but this doesn’t excuse that you have used language to paint vegans as disgusting in your original post and every subsequent comment. all to the extent of still being ignorant when people have replied explaining why your question wasn’t founded in any genuine manner. you’re rage baiting, and that is a prime example of disrespect.
I don't eat anything with realistic skin, bones, tendons, beaks, claws, hooves, or sinew. But after you process protein, a patty, nugget, or sausage shape is a convenient and familiar way of presenting and consuming it. Let me know next time you see a flock of nuggets, herd of burgers, or a drove of sausages.
But realistic muscles are ok? Or fat/muscle marbling in vegan sausage is ok? This response is like out of sight out of mind.
None of my food has imitation muscle fibres in it. And when you mix fat into protein or carbs it tends to marble if the mix is not 100% homogeneous. Have you ever rubbed margarine into flour to make cookies? Also why do you mash up dead pig flesh and shape/slice it like a cucumber? Just eat a real cucumber.
Maybe I’m tired but I don’t understand the dead pig flesh comment if you’re ok with eating vegan sausage. Further more, it’s not meant to look like a cucumber, it was meant to use up all the animal products and placed in intestines as a casing. So I really don’t understand your example.
Why dye seitan red to make it look like dead flesh?
Ethically, my issue is with the cruelty of meat, not what it looks like or tastes like. Think of it like this, if I was making a horror film, I'd be ok with using a fake corpse instead of a real dead body, but I wouldn't be ok with using a real dead person. Some people like their food to remind them of what they used to eat when they were young - they want those same flavours and textures without the cruelty of a real dead animal body involved. Why is this a problem for you?
Who said it was a problem? Why are you so defensive?
Carnists are always asking us this. It seems like you/they don't want any vegan food to resemble meat in any way. I'm just explaining it's not the shape or flavour that is the issue for us, it's the cruelty and the fact it's the corpse of someone that didn't want to die, was afraid, suffered.
Well I’m plant based, not a carnist. I understand what you wrote and your stance. And like others have mentioned it’s the system that you are in opposition of rather than what it looks like.
I guess I’m just having a hard time seeing the value of consuming replicas solely for comfort or culture. To me that’s a personal gain rooted in past behaviours that you are now ethically in opposition of. That’s where the rule is disjointed to me.
But facts are facts, and cauliflower steak isn’t produced by mistreating a cow so why not eat it and enjoy it.
Thank you for the conversation.
I think the value is that it doesn't hurt anyone if it looks or tastes like meat, and it can encourage those who are reluctant to give up their old favourites.
Because I'm feral.
Also your comment about Lolita is more disgusting than food that looks like meat. Likening fake meat to a p3d0 is fkn wild. Please don't.
I guess the same could be asked about why you occasionally eat honey?
I’m not a vegan, I’m plant based. I don’t feel ethically wrong about eating animals. So I’m fine with eating replicated meat foods. I came on here to ask vegans an ethical questions.
A lot of us use to eat meat, some of us even enjoyed the taste? It sounds like youre asking with a answer already in mind in your head. To compare us to paedophiles is crazy though.
I’m asking to change my perspective on the practice of eating something that replicates the very system you are in opposition of.
I very clearly stated my example was extreme, I do not think of vegans as pedophiles and if that’s what you took from my post, I can’t help you on that.
I dunno man, it’s not like vegans don’t think animal products taste good or are enjoyable. It’s not about that at all. You still might have the itch for a steak or roast or chicken, and so you scratch it with imitation. Where’s the harm in that? The whole point is that there is none.
I think it's kind of the same reason a lot of people say they would never go vegan. Most of us were raised eating animal products and those meals can have sentimental and cultural value, even if you no longer want to contribute to the harm you once did with the "real thing". So we make replacements to satisfy a craving without doing any actual harm. It's usually about nostalgia and carrying on cultural traditions without needlessly contributing to animal harm.
That makes sense, thank you Siobhan. I guess I’m just trying to understand why vegans will feel comfortable eating it if it replicates dead flesh. Even if it’s not dead flesh. From an ethical standpoint.
No animal needs to be exploited and killed for mock meat. People play shooter video games, but no one is confused about those. No one is actually being shot. That’s the ethical difference.
Why not farm your own animals or eat halal? Why choose veganism? Please know that I’m not trying to be difficult, I’m just asking about alternatives since you still enjoy the texture and flavours but disagree with the system.
I suggest checking out the sidebar on r/vegan to understand why people choose to practice veganism.
Because, again, no animal needs to be exploited and killed for mock meat. Exploiting and killing animals myself doesn’t solve the problem, and do you know what halal means? The animal isn’t even allowed to be stunned before it’s killed. There’s no humane way to kill a sentient being who doesn’t want or need to die.
This isn’t a difficult concept to understand. Vegans do not want to harm animals. Most vegans were raised to enjoy certain textures and flavors. Mock meats fulfill that taste preference without hurting anyone. Taste is one of the main reasons why many people don’t want to go vegan. When you make familiar tasting vegan foods, it makes it easier to stop paying for animals to suffer.
Thank you
When alternatives exist, why perpetuate a system that causes needless death and destruction? There's literally no need to kill an animal when you can get basically the same thing without any of the harm.
Some of us vegans grew up as meat eaters and certain foods are just nostalgic to us. While I’m vegan for life for a multitude of reasons, my Black ass is gonna eat deep fried chicken-esque textured food and cheesy imitations whenever I get the chance within a healthy moderation. 😆 I don’t need a beak, feathers and feet to make it weirdly anatomic but getting that mouth feel without the death is pretty rewarding.
I immediately knew you were talking about the blood seitan when I saw the title, which was the post above this one 😆 Looks crazy but I’d prefer someone eat that 100% of the time versus eating cow flesh. I think the more non vegans see that they don’t have to give up EVERYTHING they are used to eating with a vegan diet, more of them will be inspired to make the switch or at least eat a few less animals than before. We have to take victories where we can.
I respect that, thank you so much!
No problem at all 🙌🏾
“For the same reason people use dildos! Looks the same, feels the same, fills a hole & no hearts are broken in the process.”
The ethics flair is tagged, I’m not asking about using what’s on hand.
Came here to say that 😭😭
some vegans, like me, just dont like animal products and dont consume vegan "cheese" or vegan "meat" or anything that resembles animal products.
So I guess this question doesn’t really apply to you. Would you say you’re an ethical or non ethical vegan?
I just dont like animal products. If that helps animals its a bonus.
Personally, I don't. I don't like to pretend that I'm eating an animal. That's gross and weird atp.
This is a question my boss asks me all the time, and it seems that she, and many people, just can't understand a person being vegan if they aren't aesthetically repulsed by meat and animal products.
They understand that its an ethical stance, that we're vegan because we take issue with the harm and exploitation of animals, but I think a lot of people understand and relate to that objection, but push it down and repress it because they like the taste of meat. As a result, when they meet a vegan person, they figure that that person, in order to truly follow through on their ethical objection to the procurement of animal products, must not like those animal products very much, otherwise it would be too hard to resist, right?
That's the sequence of assumptions that creates this recurring question. The answer to the question is simple: animal products do actually taste good, especially if you're raised eating them regularly. Burgers are delicious, sausage is delicious, cheese and steak and cheesesteaks and bone broth all taste good. I refuse to eat any of them because their production depends on reprehensible practices, so I eat the next best things: veggie burgers and plant-based sausage and fake cheese that feels like plastic and all kinds of other imitators, because the existence and accessibility of these products makes it easier for me to be vegan and still eat a variety of fun foods.
Thank you so much. As simple as a response this is, I really appreciate it.
You’re right, my assumption is that if a person is repulsed by the mistreatment of animals then they should be repulsed by food looking like said mistreated animal.
But I guess this is about compartmentalism more than anything.
i didn’t go vegan because i don’t like the taste or texture of meat. do you really think this question hasn’t been asked a million times already? use the search function.
I did, did you really have to comment if you’re tired of repeating yourself?
Burgers don't look like animals. Neither do steaks, for that matter. It's just a shape that's convenient to cook & eat.
Steaks don’t look like animals? I mean, steaks a pieces of muscle and dead flesh, what is not animal looking about that?
Do vegan steaks look like that or are the just the same size, shape & color?
A) it doesn't resemble animals in any way. A burger doesn't look like a cow, bacon doesn't look like a pig, and nuggets look more like dinosaurs than chickens.
B) I love the way it tastes, but the way it gets to my plate is horrific. There's a very convenient way to change that journey to one that doesn't exploit animals and doesn't change the flavor or texture. So the question becomes, why wouldn't I like the option that gives me the same flavors and leaves the animals alone?
Thank you for part B, that makes sense
The honest answer for you is that food is one of many vehicles for culture.
I grew up taught to eat meat and went vegan. I liked steak, but I did not like how it was produced or the treatment of another conscious mammal like that.
It's not about it being gross or anything for me, although I might have an animal protein allergy. I honestly do not care if my plant-based burger "bleeds" or not, I care how it tastes and if it "hits right". Other people who do care have expressed to me that it's somewhat comforting to have a vegan version of a food that's as close as possible.
When I cook with a plant-based steak like those delicious mycelium steaks, I'm looking to replicate a taste, texture, and overall feel of a dish I remember and enjoy... just without the requisite suffering.
Why? Culture. Enjoyment.
Not everything has to be this big ethical/moral pointing of fingers like you're doing OP. If a lab figures out how to grow steak from ethically sourced cell cultures or someone figures out a 3D printed plant-based inch-thick steak, I'm going to fucking eat both of those suffering-free foods just the same. As long as I'm not allergic, heh.
For me my concern lies with the treatment of conscious animals under the aggregated human systems. People will likely always consume meat, that doesn't always have to be a statement of failure or complicity on our part. We represent massive drops in meat consumption personally and my exact style has omnivores who hang out with me get vegan food every so often.
I'm already vegan, so my personal impact is near-maximal. I can't make choices for others or make personal impact for them. All I can do, as I'm already vegan, is show the folk around me there's a different way to be.
I like to think of it as I work against the systems, not the people trapped in them like I was.
I’m not pointing fingers, why can’t I ask a question and use the ethics flair to gain some understanding?
Like you said, culture is huge. Growing up with a father/family who is strict in their beliefs and diet has framed my understanding of why people choose veganism. So when I see people outside of this cultural framework, I question it.
If you want lab grown steak or ethically produced meat, why not just eat halal? Like why choose veganism over the other options? Or what’s stopping you from raising your own animals and gently killing them rather than supporting the system that harms them?
I took the finger pointing from your extreme example, so my apologies for misjudging. Usually when people use these extreme kinds of examples and ask this question, it's because they are trying to point out what they feel is flawed vegan logic.
The short answer for you as to why not eat halal and ranch my own animals is that I live in a city, have zero space for even my own garden, and it's just generally not an option where I live. I'd have to "buy" halal which... how do I know it's different?
The longer answer is that I don't want to and shouldn't have to justify "why not" raise and kill my own animals. What's stopping me is my choice, personal agency, and that I think it's kinda fucked up. To me that's not companionship, that's keeping an animal until I decide to kill and eat it.
I've fished, cleaned, and cooked my meals before when camping (before I changed my diet) and every so often I'd consider solely eating fish or something like that on a rare occasion. I haven't yet, but who knows. Conscious animals may be visually dissimilar from humanity, but I firmly disagree with the exclusion of humanity from that category.
A cow is a mammal, can make friends, experience joy, be missed by her friends, want things, have agency, and basically everything humans do socially. Obviously there's language barriers, but that's basically a cow-shaped consciousness and the similarities to humanity make me have too many ethical and moral questions about factory farming and raising animals specifically for consumption.
It's complicated so there aren't easy answers like I feel you are expecting.
I’m not expecting “easy” answers. I don’t think anything marked as an ethical conversation will ever be answered in an easy way.
I feel like you’re on the defensive side, I get it. I’m not here for that so I’ll keep the rest brief.
I appreciate your detailed response. While it makes sense and I understand explicitly everything you wrote, I will still find it odd to see vegans eat meat like food.
I understand the autonomy and agency, the comfort and culture, the system and distrust. It’s just one of those concepts to me that will forever be odd despite the many times I’ve asked and that’s because of the culture I grew up in. Just as you acknowledge, culture acts as our framework. Thank you for reading and for the conversation!
Yep, it basically all boils down to what feels right to us as individuals, aligns with us culturally and spiritually, and that we enjoy. Meat-like plant-based food just lights up the brain in a good way and, to be honest, I didn't stop eating meat because I didn't like it. I just couldn't deal with the personal moral/ethical weight, also it might have been slowly attempting to kill me.
The defenceiveness is because often these questions aren't asked in good faith, as you appear to be asking it. Often it's a bad faith question in which the asker is attempting to point out what they feel is a flaw in logic.
I'm glad you appreciated my detail. I honestly gave you such detailed answers despite the defenceiveness because I was hoping you were being genuine and asking in good faith. I appreciate that you also see that these are... at the very least complicated, if not outright difficult things to explain motivation and such for.
Personally I grew up feeling "out of place" so a lot of human things feel "odd" to me, so I understand that such a different perspective than yours will feel strange at first. What really helps me is that every person is their own little walking world, we all have a mysterious depth that only we can truly know and express. Everyone needs to be free to make their best decision for themselves, regardless of how we feel about it.
For example, spirituality is one of those things where I just accept if a friend is a certain religious denomination and aim to connect instead of anything else. I'm not big on organized religion, but I do like beliefs and although mine aren't regular they are fairly easy to describe via "well you think 'the Creator' is this, I think they're the entire universe. otherwise the same."
So, if you'd like to continue this discussion as I've actually quite enjoyed your responses; Why do you eat the way you do? What's your view on meat and the ethical/moral concerns behind them? Can you pinpoint why veganism feels "odd", like is it just that it is a very different perspective on food than you're used to?
Spirituality is an excellent analogy, I thought to use it in my original post example comparing an orthodox vs non orthodox religious practice but I thought the Lolita example made more sense at the time I wrote this. Veganism is definitely on a spectrum and from some of the responses I can see that even if it’s replicated food, some vegans are absolutely not interested in it.
Well to be frank, I have a disordered eating disorder. To describe my eating practices without mentioning that, wouldn’t be a wholistic and honest response, so there’s that tidbit. With DE, I’ve tried nearly every single diet or exclusion/restriction you can possibly think of over the last 20+ years. Mostly related to health or weight.
Currently I am plant based, which I’ve been many times in the past, the longest for 6 years. I eat this way mainly for health, like reducing inflammation or skin/autoimmune issues, which is a great benefit for me.
While I find it sad that humans kill living sentient beings in such a harmful way to the point where the destruction in ecology and our environment is obvious and I am in no way proud of that - I don’t find it ethically wrong to kill and eat animals. To me, it’s a factor of our ecosystem.
I guess I’m just having a hard time seeing the value of consuming replicas solely for comfort or culture. To me, that’s a personal gain rooted in past behaviours that you are now ethically in opposition of. That’s where the rule is disjointed to me.
Rastafarian beliefs (which is my foundation and introduction into veganism) states that people should eat food that is catered to vitality. Fresh, homegrown, non preserved, non chemically altered, unprocessed lively foods (this is where “ital” comes from). It’s not rooted in opposition of systemic harm to animals in the meat/dairy industry.
So, when someone tells me they don’t agree with the system but eat foods that are examples of the system, it seems contradictory. Not saying one has to be “orthodox”, right? But it’s like, if you don’t like the mistreatment of animals, then stand on it and don’t consume products that look like the product of this mistreatment. This is my thought process, not a judgement or finger pointing.
Why consume red dyes to make mushroom look bloody? Why call a meal “chik’n” when it’s just TVP? Why feel the need to carry on comforting an aspect that was normal to you as a child if now as an adult you decided to break that way of thinking? Why wouldn’t eating lively foods that don’t mock dead foods be enough if the moral practice here is to shut down the system? I hope my response was read with genuine curiosity rather than judgement. Thank you for asking!
[removed]
Your comment was removed because you must be flaired as a vegan to make top level comments (per rule #6). People come to AskVegans looking for answers from vegans. Please flair appropriately using these instructions: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205242695-How-do-I-get-user-flair-
If you are caught intentionally subverting the automod by flairing as a vegan when you are not, this will result in a ban.
If you are a non-vegan with a question, please create a new post following the sub rules #2-5 for questions. Thank you.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
/thread
I went vegan to reduce animal suffering. Not because eating animals is “icky”.
It’s easier to make the switch when the food looks and tastes like what I ate for the first 20+ years of my life.
Yea I understand that, I highlighted that in my post, thanks.
[removed]
Your comment was removed because you must be flaired as a vegan to make top level comments (per rule #6). People come to AskVegans looking for answers from vegans. Please flair appropriately using these instructions: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205242695-How-do-I-get-user-flair-
If you are caught intentionally subverting the automod by flairing as a vegan when you are not, this will result in a ban.
If you are a non-vegan with a question, please create a new post following the sub rules #2-5 for questions. Thank you.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[removed]
Most vegans weren’t born vegan. Most of them have decided to become vegan at some point in their lives. Because of that, many have experienced eating animals and may even have enjoyed it before realising how immoral it is.
That being said, imitating familiar flavours is not immoral as long as it does not involve harming other beings. Veganism is about reducing harm, not rejecting flavours.
Vegans don’t avoid meat because they hate the taste. They avoid it because they don’t want animals to be harmed. Plant-based versions allow them to enjoy familiar flavours and textures without the ethical cost.
Also, calling something a “steak” simply indicates the shape or the way it is prepared. It is usually accompanied by words like “vegan” or “cauliflower,” making it clear that no animals were involved.
I really don't know how to explain it better and can't help if it's still not clear...
People often crave foods they ate in childhood (i.e. comfort food). Many vegans, such as myself, didn’t become vegan until we were old enough to choose our own diets. Mock meats and such allow us to enjoy vegan versions of our comfort foods.
[removed]
Your comment was removed because you must be flaired as a vegan to make top level comments (per rule #6). People come to AskVegans looking for answers from vegans. Please flair appropriately using these instructions: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205242695-How-do-I-get-user-flair-
If you are caught intentionally subverting the automod by flairing as a vegan when you are not, this will result in a ban.
If you are a non-vegan with a question, please create a new post following the sub rules #2-5 for questions. Thank you.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.