I think that cleaning expectations will go down to somewhere between "lived in" and a "little bit of clutter".
I dont think this "showroom" level of clean is going to stick around.
Now that more people are single, there simply isnt time to work 40hours and do all the things that make a household run.
My feminist friends are constantly reminding me, that the 40 hour work week was built for men, that Society assumed, would have a wife running the household.
The 40 hour work week was not designed to have workers run a household, in addition to their job.
Plus, a lot of people cant afford to hire help.
What are your thoughts?
I WFH and even like that I can’t keep my home super clean. It’s just not very cluttered. I’m actually thinking of hiring help. I can’t even begin to imagine how difficult it’s for single mothers to work FT, parent, cook, aaand clean. The expectations placed upon women by society are absurd and unrealistic.
I currently live with a family member to split costs since we both work in the area, but previous experience with cleaning up other people's messes is one of my main reasons I'm working towards making enough to live on my own.
Coming home to a place with someone else's items and mess scattered carelessly and things moved out of place genuinely makes my brain go insane. Having to clean it up because the other person won't just makes it 10x worse.
Yuuup! I had my fair share of roommates and I used to live with a male partner and I’m never doing that again! I rather pay the price of living by myself. It’s so fucking worth it.
lol single mom of three… I pay for biweekly cleaning, have a “everything has a place and gets puts in its place” mindset to minimize clutter and deal with quick cleaning maintenance as we go between housekeeping help.
It’s certainly not showroom clean, probably more lived in than anything but I wouldn’t flip out if had guests over. A good friend is a single mom of eight and her home constantly looks like it got hit by a tornado.
During Covid lockdowns while WFH my house was messier than ever. Somehow being in it 24/7 desensitized me to the piles of things, weekends lost their special power to get me to do things around the house and I always told myself I could do a superclean 'any time at all!' so it was easy to keep putting it off. Before that I'd fantasized about working from home and how wonderful it would be, but I'm actually really bad at it as it turns out. Leaving the house and re-entering it is apparently necessary for me to really see my space, and having to put off most larger tasks until the weekend was apparently also necessary to give me a sense of urgency about it.
Same here
All I know is that a LOT of single moms who divorced their husbands claim that it's actually far easier in terms of cleaning and keeping a tidy house, because they basically don't have a man burdening her with all the messes HE makes daily. All a single mom has to do is care for the messes her kids and her make, and I can totally believe that.
I don't know of a single woman that doesn't have some sort of pet peeve or annoyance about her husband (or ex) leaving dirty clothes all over the place, leaving dirty dishes piled up, leaving shit out without putting it in its place, etc., and all this inb4 someone comes with "well MY man is the one in charge of cleaning" or "I have MALE friends/family and they're cleaner than me and I'm the dirty/messy one" and so on... congratulations, you're the exception to the rule; the majority of men dump their burden of house chores onto their female partners or even female family (usually mom, but also grandma, sisters).
According to at least one study, it's true that single mothers do less housework and have more leisure time than married mothers on average.
47F, divorced, 3 teens. This has been my experience. We do 50/50 custody, and my domestic, parenting and mental load workloads got way more equitable after divorce. Now my ex has to maintain (or not) his own household. According to the kids, he's still incredibly lazy and does very little. Meanwhile, my life got a lot better, and the kids and I enjoy our time together when they are with me.
Regarding OP's original point - Personally, I keep my place pretty clean, because I prefer it that way and it helps me enjoy my space. I work full time (and have kids part time), and estimate I spend ~15 mins per day cleaning the kitchen and ~1 hour per week on laundry, vacuuming, bathroom, etc. So for me that's manageable. That said, I intentionally chose to live in a smaller home vs larger, precisely so it was easier to maintain. Also decided to not have pets for similar reasons. But totally agree that cleaning is NOT a woman's job, nor should women be held to higher standards for cleanliness than men.
I always assume its a cis msn pretending to be a woman when i see comments like that
You’re completely right. I was floored by how much of my individuality I got back once I settled into divorced 50/50 life (have older kids, so I can’t be full 4B. 3B though? 🤣) I don’t know a single married mom who can maintain multiple hobbies of her own, work full time, and travel a few weeks a year like I can. Acquaintances assume I must be a weekend only parent because my life sounds so unlike what a moms life is supposed to sound like - but I’m doing my half! Imagine what the fathers have been getting to do all this time.
Everytime I see a married mother pleading to have time to shower, or take a class, or grab brunch with a friend, I can’t help but say if you were divorced, you’d either have time to do that or he’d at least have to pay you for doing it all. Right now he gets it for free and you’re getting . . . . ?
I’m a never married mom of two, now empty nesting as I got started as a teen. No one ever believes me when I say it was not that hard to do solo. And I know it was not that hard because I was solo. I managed to get my phd when my kids were young, no one guilting me about staying up late to study, no one negging me to take me down a peg or establish fake dominance in the relationship or whatever, no man sabotaging every accomplishment. Without having grown insecure man to drag me down, it was all completely achievable.
I 100% believe you. The kids are not the hard part, especially when you’re a kind and competent person, the kids tend to mirror that back to you. My dad still complains about how horrible it was for him to have daughters and was “joking” that I’d finally sympathize with him. I don’t. Turns out when you treat a growing girl with love & respect, she’s pleasant to live with. Maybe he should have tried that.
One thing I still haven’t been able to make sense of is the fact that while I was married, my husband seemed to be the one cleaning more often. Yet, when we separated, so now I had to do all the cleaning myself, (1) it didn’t seem like I was cleaning more, and (2) the place stayed cleaner.
How it is when I was solely responsible for cleaning, rather than one doing the smaller share of the cleaning, was it both less work and more effective? Did he just single handedly create such a disproportionately larger share of the mess? Pair that with the peace and quiet, and being able to plan around a reasonable amount of food consumption, I don’t see why any divorcees ever remarry.
They never put stuff back where it belongs, put it away instead of down or clean while cooking.
They put down dirty utensils on counters, use 47 different dishes but not even for mise en place, just 'cause, and then pile things in the sink haphazardly with no mind for washing up later. Then they leave the kitchen a mess with everything to get crustier with time, and then 24 hours later bemoan how difficult it is.
It's mind boggling.
The most maddening thing to me is putting trash in the sink. My ex would “clean the kitchen” by swiping everything on the counters into the sink, then wipe down the counters, and yes it looked cleaner from a distance, but whoever was left to deal with the sink (me!) was left with a disgusting mess that was way worse than if he’d done nothing. I thought it was just him, because what insane behavior that was, until my dad came to visit and also put trash in my sink. I immediately said we don’t do that here. He huffed but thankfully hasn’t trashed my sink since.
Filling a sink so it can't function as a sink is just an abhorrent crime to me. If I have to take anything out of the sink to actually be able to wash the dishes, you might as well have left everything all over the fucking counter and table and house for the matter. I'd rather collect it myself than unfuck the worst game of Tetris ever some man play-acted with half the dishes and pans in the place.
Yes, realizing that more than just one man in the world puts trash in the sink for a woman to come pick out after him, when the trash can is literally right there behind him, was enough to make me realize I was never going to cohabitate with a man again - years before I ever heard of 4B.
Being single is 100x better than digging trash out of a wet, bacteria filled sink that didn’t need to exist in my home.
Have you had a man who didn't squeeze out the sponges? There's few things more disgusting than grabbing a sponge to clean something and having bacteria water squirt out.
>They put down dirty utensils on counters, use 47 different dishes but not even for mise en place, just 'cause, and then pile things in the sink haphazardly with no mind for washing up later.
This shit makes me insane, not even as a joke. Seeing unwashed utensils left on the counter and sauce smeared on various surfaces is like pure insanity fuel for my mind.
I can't stand it! When I'm cooking I am always thinking about the mess I'm also making, because part of being a goddamn adult is understanding that when you make a mess you are the one that has to clean it up. So why not clean as you go??? WHY WOULD YOU MAKE IT WORSE?
I know why. Because the idea that mommy is going to come after them and clean it up, subconscious or not, has never left their minds. So like a 7 year old allowed to use the oven for the first time, they leave behind eggshells and coat every surface in flour and the wrapper from the chocolate chips is stuck by a smear of butter to the side of the counter when they're done, and who are they to care?
Yep. Men are forever confused little boys. I've never seen a man not do what you described above, or worse. I had a boss who was making almost a million dollars a year, but he would just leave his dishes all over the house, and on the floor? Sometimes, he would put them on the counter next to the sink, which was empty. Lol. Just the lunacy. And his Tesla was completely filled with McDonald's fries and cups, laying all over the seats and floor. What is wrong with them?
My brother actually leaves his cups and plates on the couch cushion beside him and then goes up to his room and to bed. When I lived there, it was my job to clean up everything and I ended up becoming really resentful of cleaning up after him. So I started not cleaning up any mess he specifically would make. I would leave every item of his where it was, and I would either leave his dishes where they were or put them upstairs, in a pile, outside of his room.
He still wouldn't take them. He would just walk by like he didn't notice them. And my mom would end up having to go and do all the extra work. And of course my mom would get pissed at me and say that I was just leaving more work for her, and making it harder for her, which is infuriating because he should be doing it. He's an adult! I know I'm preaching to the choir here.
Just a few hours ago, I went to visit my mom, and once more, my brother left his dishes, USED NAPKINS, and multiple empty soda cans on the couch. As he got up to go to his room, I said, "idiot, take your trash and your dishes to the sink. Women are not maids." My mom said I was being "too mean to him." He's 26 years old, by the way. Lol. I told her, "you realize he hates women, right? I don't care at all how he feels about what I say." It's so frustrating, and this, plus a million other little patriarchal problems, makes me want to distance myself from my family.
This! They eat SO MUCH FOOD.
I'm single and my place is always immaculate. I clean as I go, everything has a home, and I only bring things into my place that have a purpose and are also lovely to look at. People find time for what's important to them.
And I'm so unbelievably happy I didn't get trapped in marriage and motherhood, i.e., a big house full of clutter and ugly man-crap.
You're winning at life. The thought of sharing a bathroom or bed with people grosses me out! My place is decorated with rocks and feathers and treasures I find in the woods. A burglar would be disappointed.
Who Cooked Adam Smith's Dinner?: A Story About Women and Economics by Katrine Marçal is a book that goes into this topic; it discusses how a lot of economic models and analyses are flawed because they ignore how heavily men have relied on the unpaid contributions of women in the domestic sphere throughout history (E.g. Adam Smith had so much time and energy to write because his mother and cousin were cooking his meals and washing his dishes).
Philosophers usually were dysfunctional shut-ins, who if married abandoned their wife and children or forced them to live a life of poverty while they locked themselves in their attic to write. When you read the biography of a philosopher, you realize they did not live honorably, or particularly effective lives. So yes, it follows that their models are flawed and ignorant of the realities of the world they refused to engage with meaningfully.
The beautiful clutter my own mother had was one of the culprits of my own mysery growing up. What I mean is: the woman had many a dozens of VERY intricate, expensive and rare decorations - most (if not all) of them for visitors, as status symbols. I'm not even sure if she actually likes them... As she got older, I saw a shift.
They all needed to be dusted, some of them polished, cared for in very particular, special ways, they all needed to be placed in the exact right places and positions to look their best. Control. Maybe OCD. Who tf knows.
That's why I never got on the hate bandwagon of minimilasric millenial, IKEA, concrete gray spaces. I get it. Well... I never got on any decor hate bandwagon really cause I don't care about other people's spaces - you do you. Who am I to bash you. Even with super intricate decor. As long as I'M NOT FORCED TO MAINTAIN IT ALL or else I risk someone getting angry at me and abusing me.
I do understand my mother grew up in completely different times (she was born in 1944). And there's no fucking way in hell I'm spending COUNTLESS weekends and after work hours on waxing wood carved statues and furniture, polishing silvers and crystals, dusting corals and hand, flat washing expensive, "exotic" carpets. IF it's not what I wanna do.
Nah.
I was taught cleanliness as a mean of exerting control, self-control and coping. In the sense: if I feel I lack general life control = go, clean. Even if things are already clean at their max. I did not espouse this life lesson.
Women back in the day sought the feeling of power and control where they possibly could. To simplify... They couldn't control the husband cause man. They couldn't control their careers (if they had any). They couldn't control their children (not by default, you all probably know what I mean). Putting any boundaries down was a no-no...
So homesteading and cleanliness was what they had. Cause home was technically a woman's domain (lol, if husband allowed it).
OP, you got me real heated here, on this whole topic.
I will also never buy anything that is 'dry clean only'
Yep. I exclusively buy shit I can air dry. On a hanger where that's the very max of my effort. Keep in mind, I come from a region where dryers aren't a default and hand ironing shit is the absolute norm.
And honestly, I whip out the iron once every 5 years or such. And that's JUST cause I MUST make the very best impression for my own very best survival.
I absolutely love women who sew, are into fashion, fabric care, laundry techniques, etc. I love it all!
Tis not me.
ETA. I also love all OCD peeps. Just don't push your standards and coping onto me.
I do not have any patience for sewing either, and I hated when I used to have to iron my work clothes.
With the ironing especially, I personally get you 💯. But that's also because my mother made me iron (believe me or not) socks, towels and also panties. She claimed it softened the fabrics/threads and made those things feel better on the skin. She also loved her bedsheets starched into stiff planks.
I eventually made peace with the fact the woman was not a "normie". What the cause for this was exactly, I'll never know. She's in her 80s now and I couldn't get the vulnerability and truth out of her if I waterbiarded the woman.
All I know is she did her darndest to impact and train me with all her coping control mechanisms - as these sort of were what a proper woman™ was back in her days, when she got shaped as a human.
Nowadays, she'll still act shocked when the topic of me not ironing shit comes up. As if ironing is a gateway to everlasting patriarchal marital bliss... It's wild.
I enjoy having lots of extra time to read. House keeping is pretty far down my list of priorities. Reading about your mom makes me exhausted. I think some people love to exert full control over their domain.
Yeah, she was perpetually burned out and equally perpetually pissed/angry. In general, even now being around her (at her super old age) as a trusted family female member is simply exhausting - cause the programming still runs so very deep.
I can't even begin to fathom how many life regrets this poor woman has. Just because she had to claw at everything she ever wanted for herself - if it didn't fall into the patriarchal standard in the 50s, 70s, 90s and so forth (ETA. Topped with end of WWII and then decades of communism).
The home felt safe. This was where she could actually exert control. Which is no excuse for what this resulted in. But it does put a lot of things into perspective.
My mom is a control freak, and they have a lot in common. Mine is very concerned with her appearance in society. Probably because my family is abusive. We had to cover up all the negative! But she has maids doing most of the work like ironing her linen sheets. I can still smell that green velvet from the box that holds the silver flatware. My parents portrayed the picture-perfect family.
When I was with my ex-husband the house was a disaster and I could hardly keep it clean (his 2 chores of his own laundry and taking out the trash was too hard apparently). The man didnt clean the litterbox a single time. When I got tired and fell behind on it, he chose to game in a urine scented room rather than help clean it. He swept the floors once across our 2 year marriage. My quality life and home has significantly improved since being single.
I don't clean my place showroom levels of clean, but as someone who is still responsible for their own place, I still like to avoid clutter and filth when I can and usually stay on top by cleaning as I go (such as immediately doing dishes after eating, wiping up messes as they appear, wiping around the sink directly after washing dishes, cleaning the shower when grime appears, etc).
Dusting is one of the things I struggle with most, but I think household tasks are far more manageable when I'm only responsible for my own messes, as opposed to the mess and filth created by men and children in addition to cleaning up after myself.
We should also claim minimalism from the male fetishists. It was meant to be a lifestyle of no more than is needed, not a farcical display of going without any scrap of comfort.
Kitchen cleanup is also drastically easier if you don’t keep or prepare meat in the home.
In my current living situation, I'm the one who cleans. It's not really fair, but I do enjoy a clean living space and I'm a naturally tidy person (if it's messy, I feel unsettled or agitated). I put a lot of work into the house because I'm not working full time at the moment and I have the time to do a big clean every morning.
That being said, I know when I do live on my own, my living space will definitely look more lived in. I don't think most men even get close to realising what a huge job keeping an entire house immaculately clean is. I don't think most men experience the amount of domestic work a woman does in their entire lifetime.
My house is clean, cause there is nobody to make a mess there except for myself. I do deep cleaning every three months. I like when it's clean, and it's rewarding cause I know nobody will ruin it, and when I MYSELF do, I will hold no resentment while just cleaning it again. So I think living in nice, clean spaces will only become more common for women.
Single or not, it's those damned 40 hours a week that ruin everything else, be it cleaning or anything else.
That said, my friends always pay someone to come and clean. In my country, a messy house is considered pretty rude.
I feel like all I can keep up regularly is dishes, cleaning the kitchen counters, sink, etc, and laundry. But I eat simple one pot stuff. I try not to wear any clothes than need special washing or need to be hung up. I do this intentionally to reduce my demands. Having less clothes helps (I got rid of clothes that I would have worn to appease the male gaze.)
Bathroom and the floors rarely get done, unless it looks like it really really needs it or after I can’t stand it anymore.
There are too many demands and a lot of stuff just doesn’t get done. But like others have said, at least I don’t have the burden of also cleaning up after a man.
The women in my family would get bent out of shape about cleaning. They would be miserable if something wasn't perfect. From them i learned to never make myself miserable over a clean house. My regret at the end of my life will not be about wishing i had cleaned more, unless i am crushed from hoarding
Let's not forget that just living with a man-child is very taxing on our mental and, eventually, physical health.
SO. MUCH. EMOTIONAL. LABOR.
Definitely easier to keep clean living alone than it would be with a man or children around! I keep my tiny apartment presentable but I have systems that are woven into my daily routines so it's never a huge chore. While cooking I have a method to clean as I go. Even when having a friend over for dinner, I just tell them I'll clean up myself after they leave, because when they try help stuff ends up all over the place. It's just easier for me to do it the way I want.
I disagree. Most women enjoy a neat and tidy home, it’s peaceful and comfy
Many people enjoy a neat and tidy home. Assuming it's a female trait is a generalisation. It really depends on priorities.
I'm comfortable with organised chaos. I have places for things and I keep things in regular places for convenience but I can live with unfolded washing and a certain amount of clutter.
This is my choice and I am resistant to judgement. Occasionally I refer to it as 'living like a bachelor'.
Yeah, I live like a bachelor too. I like it. And I'm sure you were judged as a kid too for not being "naturally" good at cleaning?
I've never had a showroom house and never lived in one. I read what Angela Davis wrote about housework in Women, Race and Class in my early twenties, and though I can't remember the exact wording, I agreed, and feel these are more or less fairly recent bourgeois expectations. I honestly don't know anyone who expects real people to live in a showroom quality home. The "showroom" expectation never existed for many households and communities.
Practically, you can live in a vaguely clean and cosy home without putting that much time into it. I got a dishwasher, a robot vacuum and a washer/dryer and I just turn these on and go about my day. And I have a dustmite killing (apparently it electrocutes them?) handheld vacuum to kill the dustmites and I use that occasionally.
I honestly think this regular folk having a showroom house is a cultural expectation that has roots in a class system and availability of cheap/free labour for housework, and it's a fairly new thing, because for most of history most women have worked, including non-urban "housewives" who had to raise children and/or do things like bake bread from scratch and do sewing and farmwork, and keeping a beautiful showroom home is way down in the to-do list. I've never had people over that had this expectation, and never gone to their homes with this in mind. Personally I find visibly lived-in homes more charming, but you're the main person living in your home. It's nobody else's business if all your surfaces are covered in cat hair.
I feel like it's already happened. Maybe it's just me and my friends; but clutter is a vibe. We are millenial women.
I have seen it cropping up in places. I think its going to become the new norm.
Pretty easy for me to keep my house cleaner than everyone I have seen so far when visiting. I don't deep clean constantly, maybe 2 times a year, the rest is normal cleaning, and it helps a lot that i have a robot vacuum and mopper.
I disagree because of two (intertwined) things: Status and Capitalism.
Cleaning has become much easier over time (my mom handwashed sheets in hot water heated on a coal stove). Because it's becoming easier, having the same standards is not as high status as before, so standards became higher.
Compare it to fashions in weight: when it was hard to be fat, high status people were fat. Now when cheap, high caloric food is plentiful, it's far more high status to be skinnier.
Whatever status takes more resources is going to be higher status. People can't keep an immaculate house? The an immaculate house is now something to show off because it's showing off the resources needed (time and/or money) to attain that.
See Veblen's conspicuous consumption.
So as each step in cleaning has become easier, there was a higher step added on the status ladder. It's no longer just clean floors; there's now immaculate pantries, all everything in their own container, which shows off the resources (time to do that and money for the containers) to do that.
And a "clean house" is something that seems to be attainable for most people. It's not like becoming an expert athlete. But the social media level of "clean" IS unattainable for most, because most people don't have the time and/or money to pull it off.
That's when capitalism comes in with a "remedy" for the status anxiety: "Hey, you want a clean house but you don't have the time? Well it's EASY with our cleaning product/machine! In no time at all, this will give you the clean house you deserve!"
Of course that's a lie. No cleaner will instantly turn a dirty house into a clean one. So the anxiety circle keeps circling with a new product hitting the market that honest to god, cross their fingers, WILL make cleaning easier.
I think that if you are correct, then that's going to lead to sickness that takes a lot of lives, the governments will lose a lot of money to trying to salvage the situation, and the money they will spend will be greater than the money it would have cost them to prevent this. Even if that prevention was done via free house keepers hired by the government for every citizen.
Being dirty leads to minor sickness at a higher rate, it's not drastic, but if everyone is a little more dirty, they're sick a little more often, and that leads to more medicating, and more opportunity for strengthening diseases. Today the flu is not that big of a deal, but with all these sick people contributing to upgrading it, tomorrow it might be black plague level.